Sengoku Komachi Kuroutan: Noukou Giga - Vol. 13 Ch. 61 - Quarantine

Aggregator gang
Joined
Jul 30, 2018
Messages
321
Seeing the numbers of infected and dead in other provinces made my hands tremble a little. Reminded me a bit too much of when I was obsessively checking Covid numbers. The infected vs deaths percentage in the manga was so very high, my god…
 
Double-page supporter
Joined
Aug 19, 2020
Messages
436
IIRC, her phone actually still works with a manual charger and uses an offline encyclopedia app for random bits of her knowledge. Besides her being taught by her grandad and sister about almost everything including using a spear that almost sounded like they knew she will need it.

Or maybe that was from another isekai/timeslip manga. These can all easily overlap with each other in my head.
How can she use phone when there is no electricity
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Apr 25, 2019
Messages
61
How can she use phone when there is no electricity
She uses a handcrank charger. You plug it to the phone and generate a charge by quickly turning the handle (like a fishing reel). Hers is very small and compact, but some models you see online come with a built-in torch and weather/radio. It's a very useful emergency item in situations where you may lose power or off the grid (like hiking, or getting isekai'd hahaha)
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jul 16, 2019
Messages
219
Tbf knowledge about quarantines and healthy eating aren't exactly complicated. It's just revolutionary for those in the past because they don't know the background behind it. Heck, I'm no doctor and even I know what to do if I get sick, especially with an infectious disease like measles or other variations of pox.

Take for example, washing hands. Nowadays, we all wash our hands to get rid of germs and it improves our health fantastically. But if you were in the past, people would just laugh at you. Something so simple and obvious now is crazy to think of in the past.

You don't have to know exactly how it works (me not being a doctor and obviously not an expert in virology). You just have to know what works and use that.
yeah oc but like the whole stages etc. was clearly not common knowledge
this and the appropriate diet (thats not what an agricultor knows, but a doc or nutritionist lol)
if they established that she was a maniac of diet tips etc. in earlier chaps, okay thats fine the, but they didnt and it seems like they brush it off as 'common knowledge from the modern times/she was studying agriculture' but either of those explanations are lacking imo (quarantine and good hygien oc doesnt count in what im criticizing, that is indeed common knowledge)
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jul 16, 2019
Messages
219
Because she was trained extensivly in this field by her grandparents I think her family knows about their time travel ability and teach them all this shit.

I mean her uncle joined her in going back so theirs that so they know the trigger in going back. Pretty sure they can return anytime Uncle just has a goal before he let her return just an assumption though.
interesting theory!
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jul 16, 2019
Messages
219
About MC knowledge in illness, it is possible that she has learn in her highschool. You will be surprised on how much we asian student has to learn for each class. In history class we may learn about this pandemic and how it end, in science class we might learn about where or how you can find which vitamin. Not to mention that her grandpa friends that specialized in their own field has come to visit her granda very often, she must have learn thing or two from them for sure.
oh yeah im not asian so that may be why
if it is indeed normal then okay! sits well with me
but thats truly incredible to be learning things like appropriate diets in HS! they should make us learn that too TT thats super interesting
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jul 16, 2019
Messages
219
ikr! i too often drop when it becomes so wtf that i feel like im reading a self-insert-mary-sue-wattpad-fanfic hahaha but this manga still deserves a ten for the drawing the execution and the characters! if i could put 9,5 itd be better since shizuko is indeed a small mary sue when she isnt supposed to be one (just in agriculture not every field lol wtf she not even 20 x) ) but since we cant on mangadex, ill settle for a ten ^^
I feel mostly the same with the technology cheat in any manga lol. Most of the time, it annoys me enough that I drop the series because of it unless they got an alright reason for it (e.g. Jin's MC being an established doctor and Dr. Stone's Senku having an extreme interest in science and working for it step-by-step).

This story makes up for it with heart and a lovable MC, though.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jul 16, 2019
Messages
219
Initially Akechi never expressed any dissatisfaction over Shizuko. In fact, he was cordial and respectful to her whenever they interacted. The author only now decided to make Akechi have reservations about her. It's not a huge issue but it does bother me.
well we never digged into his thought before right? like it was just shizuko's pov no? maybe im mistaken i have to admit its been a long time since i read all that and we already at chap 61 x)
 
Fed-Kun's army
Joined
Nov 27, 2020
Messages
24
He still had some reservation when he first met her as well. However, it's merely of her methods and results gives him pause (rather than herself as a person), as they're considered unorthodox for most within their era. For example, when Nobunaga had a distaste for the food that was served in the capital, Mitsuhide couldn't comprehend the reason as he saw nothing wrong with the food. When Shizuko showed up and told him that she had a solution, Mitsuhide automatically assumed that Shizuko would prepare a meal even greater than the capital's. However when he had saw that she had prepared meal that Oda was used to, Mitsuhide had a doubtful expression until Nobunaga tried the food and expressed his satisfaction.

It's similar to this. Mitsuhide didn't show any disapproval or doubts, even when Shizuko told him about the outbreak, and instead opted to act quickly at her command. It wasn't until she detailed her plan that Mitsuhide showed his doubts and disapproval. Which amplified he learned that Shizuko opted to share similar plans of handling the outbreak with even enemy lords.
Any reservations he may have had, at that time were not readily apparent/visible. The author never visually conveyed Akechi specifically to have any doubts or concerns about her. Granted, the only other time we had any interactions between Shizuko and Akechi was at that time he was accompanied by Toyotomi so the author couldn't really exclude Toyotomi. However, Toyotomi and Akechi's shock/reservation as to Shizuko's revealed solution wasn't due to her being a female but rather on the solution itself. As you've said Shizuko only recreated the local cuisine and only laced the same with ample spices.

Akechi didn't show any disapproval or doubts to her as a woman before or at least it was never visually conveyed as well as all other male detractors-turned-allies of Shizuko. It was a shock how Akechi just had any mental reservations about her and they only visually conveyed it in this chapter.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Mar 18, 2020
Messages
137
Press F to Nippon Plague God for playing Plague Inc. in Sengoku Japan setting .

You tried your best, but you didn't factor transported individuals such as Shizuko into the equation.

GGWP.

As for Mitsuhide... don't do it, Mitsuhide. Don't even think about it.

Uncle Atsushi already have Kato Danzo and his band of flying ninjas under his employment, and it would be a terrible shame to have your name be put into their shit-list.

As for the after-effect of the pandemic, I imagine other clans, particularly the far-off, non-hostile clans such as the Shimazu, Date, etc will start to warm-up with the Oda.

This is a good thing, for there are many ways to total domination other than military conquest (as demonstrated in Civilization series).
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Sep 30, 2018
Messages
831
Any reservations he may have had, at that time were not readily apparent/visible. The author never visually conveyed Akechi specifically to have any doubts or concerns about her.
Of course not, because we saw things from Shizuko's pov rather than Mitsuhide's, and Shizuko had already completed her dish and presented it to Nobunaga before Mitsuhide realized what it was, and he once he did, he was doubtful of it. On the other hand, if Shizuko had told Mitsuhide exactly what she was going to make for Nobunaga, then we would've saw even more reservation from Mitsuhide.

And once again, Mitsuhide's reservations regarding Shizuko has to do with her methods and results, not herself as a person or even the fact that she's a woman. Even in this chapter, he was respectful enough and willingly followed Shizuko's orders of setting up a ward when she told him about the outbreak. It's not until he learned of Shizuko's plans, in which he showed doubt and reservation.
 
Aggregator gang
Joined
Jan 30, 2023
Messages
108
I can't wait for the Imjin War, if Shizuko hasn't caused enough butterfly effects for it not to happen.
Nobunaga(if he survived) / Hideyoshi ambition to look outward combine with Shizuko / Ashimitsu in command will most likely lead to a creation of a new navy, one with bigger ship and focus on gunpowder weapon.

And if shizuko can somehow make a stirling engine strong and efficient for naval uses. The introduction of gunboat and early hybrid steam and sail merchant ship to beter secure supply line. i dont see korea winning this one, as japan navy will actively hunt Yi fleet

as a Yi Sun shin fan. i dread this future
 
Fed-Kun's army
Joined
Dec 20, 2018
Messages
185
Nobunaga(if he survived) / Hideyoshi ambition to look outward combine with Shizuko / Ashimitsu in command will most likely lead to a creation of a new navy, one with bigger ship and focus on gunpowder weapon.

And if shizuko can somehow make a stirling engine strong and efficient for naval uses. The introduction of gunboat and early hybrid steam and sail merchant ship to beter secure supply line. i dont see korea winning this one, as japan navy will actively hunt Yi fleet

as a Yi Sun shin fan. i dread this future

Finally, someone who understands my comment and relates to it. :salute:
 
Joined
Nov 26, 2019
Messages
1,313
I would think that Shizuko is well aware of all the atrocities and crimes against humanity nihon committed and would not help...



That's a possibility, at least a small shrine build for her.



The one I want to see it Ii Naotora.
Anyone else?
I really think we shouldn't talk about what happened in true history's politics. You'll get banned from the comment section. I did it before and get banned because of that, just because I am trying to compare the manga and true history to make prediction of what's about to happen in the manga.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 25, 2018
Messages
1,497
I really think we shouldn't talk about what happened in true history's politics. You'll get banned from the comment section. I did it before and get banned because of that, just because I am trying to compare the manga and true history to make prediction of what's about to happen in the manga.

Why exactly that happened? Because mods are cowards (or worse, you can imagine in what way I mean) or because you supposedly gave "spoilers".

But still, I have my fears about that point, because it seems the average japanese only knows the "bad things done to them", seems like school makes no effort of even hides all the crimes they committed, some worse than the atom bombs.
Shizuko may have some hard limited about what she could do, for example, no bio weapons, but it seems that in a few chapters she uses a very modern weapon that could easily be adapted to destroy a whole city with low effort. This is another risk, she is gambling too high, assuming that these technologies will remain a secret and not leak. That one if anyone else discovers how it's made it's over for Japan, she is nothing thinking about the consequences of her actions sometimes I think and it's only natural for us readers to ponder and share thoughts about these possibilities.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top