Shinigami ni Sodaterareta Shoujo wa Shikkoku no Tsurugi wo Mune ni Idaku - Vol. 8 Ch. 51 - Battle of the Plateau 3

[Galshmer]

I'm sorry, but that's actually how the DMCA works. Originally, a host was held liable for any copyright infringing content, the DMCA allows hosts to pass along responsibility, by saying "we're not the ones who are infringing, it's the uploader who's doing stuff", but in return, if the uploader wishes to contest the copyright, the host has to pass the information of the uploader to the claim submitter.
This isn't mangadex throwing scanlators under the bus, this is literally how the law works.
To clarify when a DMCA claim is made, a host must legally choose one of three options
1) Take responsibility of the upload, and contest it in court themselves. This is non-viable for any hosting site, as they would never escape legal hell
2) Take down the content immediately, without contest. This is what youtube most frequently does.
3) Pass responsibility on to the uploader, giving the uploader the chance to decide whether their content is fair use or not, and contest it if it is. In order for this to happen, both the uploader and the claim submitter must have knowledge of each other.

Doesn't mean that people aren't allowed to be upset about MD implementing that. Copyright law in general is complete and utter BS.

I for one can't wait to have to go back to pirating manga the old fashion way. ( Sarcasm, if it wasn't obvious enough. )

 

[Amimikamoon]

The irony is that, without piracy, I would be less likely to buy manga, not more.

All of the series I own physical copies of are stories that I discovered through piracy and decided I liked enough to buy, because why the hell would I chance buying an unknown series and potentially wasting a lot of money on something I ultimately don't like?

 

[terranmcv]

Ellis' older brother's name is different between manga and novel.
In the novel, his name is Luke Crawford.

 

[nomadicengi]

I think they are letting the enemy troops to move and be within the vicinity of the decoy forces so the communication between enemy forces will be paper thin. They also have to move a thousand troops as well without the enemy noticing so I'm pretty sure they are forced to take things slowly.

Let's be real here. This is a medieval era fantasy where messengers have to use horses or run on foot to maintain the line of communication so they pretty much need to wait for the messenger as well.

 

[Wolvenworks]

takes too long, why they still didn't launch the attack and instead yapping some bullshit right there?

It’s called “expository banter”

I'm sorry, but that's actually how the DMCA works. Originally, a host was held liable for any copyright infringing content, the DMCA allows hosts to pass along responsibility, by saying "we're not the ones who are infringing, it's the uploader who's doing stuff", but in return, if the uploader wishes to contest the copyright, the host has to pass the information of the uploader to the claim submitter.
This isn't mangadex throwing scanlators under the bus, this is literally how the law works.
To clarify when a DMCA claim is made, a host must legally choose one of three options
1) Take responsibility of the upload, and contest it in court themselves. This is non-viable for any hosting site, as they would never escape legal hell
2) Take down the content immediately, without contest. This is what youtube most frequently does.
3) Pass responsibility on to the uploader, giving the uploader the chance to decide whether their content is fair use or not, and contest it if it is. In order for this to happen, both the uploader and the claim submitter must have knowledge of each other.

It’s the Americans’ fault then for making DMCA, so maybe if we kiss the orange’s ass enough, he might just repeal it for political gain lol.

 

[Scrabbleman]

I'm sorry, but that's actually how the DMCA works. Originally, a host was held liable for any copyright infringing content, the DMCA allows hosts to pass along responsibility, by saying "we're not the ones who are infringing, it's the uploader who's doing stuff", but in return, if the uploader wishes to contest the copyright, the host has to pass the information of the uploader to the claim submitter.
This isn't mangadex throwing scanlators under the bus, this is literally how the law works.
To clarify when a DMCA claim is made, a host must legally choose one of three options
1) Take responsibility of the upload, and contest it in court themselves. This is non-viable for any hosting site, as they would never escape legal hell
2) Take down the content immediately, without contest. This is what youtube most frequently does.
3) Pass responsibility on to the uploader, giving the uploader the chance to decide whether their content is fair use or not, and contest it if it is. In order for this to happen, both the uploader and the claim submitter must have knowledge of each other.

i think the law is broken and should be changed.

 

[Nemo2342]

Well as said on the End Card, current situation kinda sucks.
But, as long as there is no Strike, i'll continue.

It takes a long time when you have to be on high alert for mayo. Totally understandable.

 

[Kanade0021]

Thanks for the translation!

 

[Saury]

Damn, that's some serious secondhand embarrassment for the little bro ...

 

[BanzaiYuri]

"THE COMPANY" Damn, instead of Lethal Company it's Legal Company 🥀

 

[AngleBoi7]

Doesn't mean that people aren't allowed to be upset about MD implementing that. Copyright law in general is complete and utter BS.

Well, the other option would be MangaDex shutting down, voluntarily or not.

 

[Shinigamisama]

Those siblings are hilarious. Be careful Claudia, Olivia might not want some competition over Ashton. Ah yes a fangirl.


Kudos to you for continuing this!

 

[Claith]

I'm sorry, but that's actually how the DMCA works. Originally, a host was held liable for any copyright infringing content, the DMCA allows hosts to pass along responsibility, by saying "we're not the ones who are infringing, it's the uploader who's doing stuff", but in return, if the uploader wishes to contest the copyright, the host has to pass the information of the uploader to the claim submitter.
This isn't mangadex throwing scanlators under the bus, this is literally how the law works.
To clarify when a DMCA claim is made, a host must legally choose one of three options
1) Take responsibility of the upload, and contest it in court themselves. This is non-viable for any hosting site, as they would never escape legal hell
2) Take down the content immediately, without contest. This is what youtube most frequently does.
3) Pass responsibility on to the uploader, giving the uploader the chance to decide whether their content is fair use or not, and contest it if it is. In order for this to happen, both the uploader and the claim submitter must have knowledge of each other.

This does sum it up. YouTube and other services go a step further with closing accounts after "strikes" which isn't part of the law. They just need to remove the content, which is fair in some cases. I'm guessing it is a bad method to try to limit repeat offenders and lower their work. Seems to only generate ill will from what I've seen.

The issue really is when media isn't licensed in the US (or appropriate region), but it's claimed as if it was. There isn't a way to properly fight false claims and get any sort of restitution.

Personally, I'd buy more series if it was by volume and not nickle and diming per chapter with strange time to read mechanics.

 

[isoycrazy]

This does sum it up. YouTube and other services go a step further with closing accounts after "strikes" which isn't part of the law. They just need to remove the content, which is fair in some cases. I'm guessing it is a bad method to try to limit repeat offenders and lower their work. Seems to only generate ill will from what I've seen.

The issue really is when media isn't licensed in the US (or appropriate region), but it's claimed as if it was. There isn't a way to properly fight false claims and get any sort of restitution.

Personally, I'd buy more series if it was by volume and not nickle and diming per chapter with strange time to read mechanics.

Just because the work isn't licensed here doesn't mean the author or publisher in another country loses ownership at the boarder. I doubt Disney would like someone making fan translations of their works in other countries.

 

[Lyncoris]

Bruh why they talking like they're at a picnic

Well the what you gonna do? Run to the enemy at the cost of you positional advantage and exhaust your army?

While some character have some power. Most of the army is regular human. While the battle (ie when clash between two people)should be fast, take some info from frontline, deliver that info to commander, take next move from commander and tell the soldier at frontline, moving an army like the commander command, it take time. And to have effective ambush you need so the enemy at the right position, in this case where detachment army is far from main army

 

[TheGodEmperor]

You have a discord server to follow for news? And, yea, would expect that kinda response from Mangadex

 

[TheGodEmperor]

Just because the work isn't licensed here doesn't mean the author or publisher in another country loses ownership at the boarder. I doubt Disney would like someone making fan translations of their works in other countries.

Depends tbh.if a country don't give a shit about your IP ownership and wants to allow others to use it inside, then sucks for them. But, ya, most countries fairly good at working together over blatant IP violations

 

[isoycrazy]

Depends tbh.if a country don't give a shit about your IP ownership and wants to allow others to use it inside, then sucks for them. But, ya, most countries fairly good at working together over blatant IP violations

Fair enough

 

[E421T]

You have a discord server to follow for news? And, yea, would expect that kinda response from Mangadex

Am making one.
Not done yet though since i had some other stuff to do and also have almost zero discord knowledge.
Should be finished by next chapter.

 

[ilusatus]

Siblings banter in the middle of war?
I can see that happened back then.