SSS-Rank Dungeon de Knife Ippon Tewatasare Tsuihou Sareta Shiro Madoushi: Yggdrasil no Noroi ni yori Jakuten de aru Maryoku Fusoku wo Kokufuku-shi Se…

[MangaDex]

 

[spawnknight]

So I'm guessing the mage girl will leave the party once she finds out that MC is alive...(if she survives against that undead woman that is...)

 

[Ninoren]

Good she is aware, cuz no matter what she says she deserves death just as much as the other party against the undead terror, since she practically also had part in attempting to kill Rei

 

[ciera]

thanks for the updates

 

[ElectroSlam]

Ah yes she’s totally still his friend it’s not like she also left him in the dungeon to die. And she should be completely forgiven just because she feel bad about it.

 

[DarkMatter77]

Ah yes she’s totally still his friend it’s not like she also left him in the dungeon to die. And she should be completely forgiven just because she feel bad about it.

Ghost girl said “you have been coming here so many times” and we know that dungeon is not something you can do solo. So she has been risking her life many times to save him

Even if one says that she could have done much more, that doesn't invalidate what she has done and is trying to do for him.

 

[MakerT1]

Ghost girl said “you have been coming here so many times” and we know that dungeon is not something you can do solo. So she has been risking her life many times to save him

Even if one says that she could have done much more, that doesn't invalidate what she has done and is trying to do for him.

All she did was standing at the bloody entrance and looking at it. The most evil one isn't the one who killed you, it the one that knows but doesn't care. Anyone could have regrets, but when you have a chance to do something and you don't. How is that any better, it even worse

 

[ARealCoolGuy]

I seem to recall she was alive and well when the party left rei behind to die, so NOW she is suddenly finding the courage to try and help him?... What a load of rubbish. It's survivors guilt, but totally earned and deserved survivors guilt. Words and actions have their moment, and she completely ignored that moment when he actually needed them.

I hate it when comics try to redeem irredeemable characters in stupid ways. Everyone is just going to get along when they meet in the future and it sucks.

 

[welcome2atlantis]

Geez, these high rank dungeons... even waiting in right outside of its gate might get one killed.
Monsters patrolling outside the gate? Isn't that like, half a stampede already? :/

 

[HartSkai]

Ah yes she’s totally still his friend it’s not like she also left him in the dungeon to die. And she should be completely forgiven just because she feel bad about it.

fr tho HOW are they "friends"? I guess her name is fail Feil for a reason.

 

[SupBroZX]

Ghost girl said “you have been coming here so many times” and we know that dungeon is not something you can do solo. So she has been risking her life many times to save him

Even if one says that she could have do, she wants to remove the guilt on her chest by saving the MC or suicide by monsters while searching for him.ne much more, that doesn't invalidate what she has done and is trying to do for him.

<Erased>

 

[androgynous]

Not everyone has the strength to stand up and do what's right!
I'm sure everyone judging her as irredeemable has, at least once, see some injustice, bullying or something similar, and pretend to not seeing it!

 

[xSauriaNx]

Not everyone has the strength to stand up and do what's right!
I'm sure everyone judging her as irredeemable has, at least once, see some injustice, bullying or something similar, and pretend to not seeing it!

bystander effect.
also, this is fiction, people will voice things far cry from truth... or at least parade as.

 

[Wyrm]

I hate self-pitying characters like this.
Bystanders to bullying cases, who persuade themselves that they are also victims. (Which is not entirely wrong, but far from the same level of victimization as the actual target.)

The part that is the most telling is how she laments that she couldn't save Rei because she was afraid for her life. I'll grant her that much. They were in a dungeon that far surpassed their capabilities and were... ah wait, totally safe because they were not under attack at the time and were about to use teleport stones to go back. So, a bit of a stressful situation, but far from an actual crisis. They even had even stones to bring everybody back, but three members of the party deliberately chose to abandon Rei, after stabbing him. It wasn't a "necessary sacrifice" so much as a straight-up murder. Still, I'll grant her the "fear for her life". Not so much because of the dungeon monsters... but more because of the three human monsters she teamed up with.

The problem is what happened afterwards. She disagreed with the party's decision, she saw her "friend" be tortured and left for dead, and still she stuck with this party... who went on and "sacrificed" several more healers in the same way. At this stage, this is not a "fear for your life", it's outright complicity. So spare us the self-pity.

This chapter is supposed to make us feel sympathy for her, but I just can't. (Similar situation in this manga.)

I'm not saying that it's not a credible characterization. Humans can and do behave like this. I just don't feel any sympathy for these types. There is a point where they lose it for me. For Feil here, that's after they killed another white mage. For that other example, that's when the "friend" allowed her party to go after the MC's party that last time. They might deserve redemption, eventually, but they have a lot to do to get my sympathy back. Wallowing in self-pity doesn't cut it.

 

[StormSen]

I don't believe that anyone complaining here about her choice would have chosen any differently in that situation.

If she had rebelled against the leader, he would have simply left her there to die along with Light. Just calling them out on it probably would have been enough for her to be left behind.

OTOH, there are things that she could have done. She could have reported it to the authorities. Even though there was not enough evidence to convict, the accusation would be there, and likely that would have saved more lives.

In addition, she could have left the heroes party.

In short, it's not her decision in the dungeon which is the problem, but rather her inaction afterwards.

 

[Shawnino]

i called it in chapter one. She will join him.

 

[rexmundi]

suddenly flashback

 

[Dwarfy2k]

So she regrets what happened but didnt tell anyone and just wanted to deathwish into said dingeon.... she deserves no redemption. At least she understands thats her fate too sadly I bet MC forgives her.

 

[HelioCesar]

Lmao how are people defending her? At some point we all must have over-looked injustice or bullying to a degree.
But i am betting my left ball that not even 1/10 of the people who did it tried to argue that the other person would see them as friends or anything the like right away.
To redeem something like that takes a shit-ton of effort and actions from the over-looking person. Not some, "i am sad and woried ".
She could have reported them, she could have left the party, dang it she could have stole the remaining stone and fleed with him, she would have much more of a chance in doing it than him. There is a reason Plato said "silence gives consent".

 

[Kami_Nana]

I don't believe that anyone complaining here about her choice would have chosen any differently in that situation.

If she had rebelled against the leader, he would have simply left her there to die along with Light. Just calling them out on it probably would have been enough for her to be left behind.

OTOH, there are things that she could have done. She could have reported it to the authorities. Even though there was not enough evidence to convict, the accusation would be there, and likely that would have saved more lives.

In addition, she could have left the heroes party.

In short, it's not her decision in the dungeon which is the problem, but rather her inaction afterwards.

Another point that should be brought up is how she feels she's lost her voice within this shitty party. It's effectively robbed her of her self worth and confidence.