SSS-Rank Dungeon de Knife Ippon Tewatasare Tsuihou Sareta Shiro Madoushi: Yggdrasil no Noroi ni yori Jakuten de aru Maryoku Fusoku wo Kokufuku-shi Se…

Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jul 4, 2020
Messages
237
Him being hesitant to kill does make sense. Soldiers are trained to be as desensitized to it as possible and even they have trouble with it. His "they can atone!" mindset is incredibly naive though.

I have a bad feeling that Nenemoa will be dead or very close to it, breaking his mentality on killing. Hopefully he's able to save her, but that dream was pretty brutal for it to not be foreshadowing
My main problem is he's supposed to be an adventurer. It's not like he hasn't killed before, and with every other depiction of Adventurers in media, part of their job is also capturing bandits. So him being so adverse to killing that he lets known murderers walk away is a bit too naive to make sense

As for Nenemoa, her owner is shown to have connections to some sort of evil laboratory, so if she IS alive when he finds her, it won't be long before she's either dead, or turned into some monstrosity.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Nov 7, 2019
Messages
451
My main problem is he's supposed to be an adventurer. It's not like he hasn't killed before, and with every other depiction of Adventurers in media, part of their job is also capturing bandits. So him being so adverse to killing that he lets known murderers walk away is a bit too naive to make sense

As for Nenemoa, her owner is shown to have connections to some sort of evil laboratory, so if she IS alive when he finds her, it won't be long before she's either dead, or turned into some monstrosity.
Yeah, I'll give you the adventurer bit, but also remember that he was a (not very good) healer (iirc, there's a lot of these abandoned by your party and I haven't seen him do any healing lately so I can't remember lol, I just know he was a back liner). So he probably didn't have much actual combat experience. Being in a party where things are killed and being the one doing the killing is a bit different.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Sep 24, 2018
Messages
168
My main problem is he's supposed to be an adventurer. It's not like he hasn't killed before, and with every other depiction of Adventurers in media, part of their job is also capturing bandits. So him being so adverse to killing that he lets known murderers walk away is a bit too naive to make sense

As for Nenemoa, her owner is shown to have connections to some sort of evil laboratory, so if she IS alive when he finds her, it won't be long before she's either dead, or turned into some monstrosity.
Since when does being an adventurer in this manga mean he has kill people? He has killed monsters yes, but that is very different thing from killing another person. That isn't in the job description of one in this manga as far as we know, so that's a poor argument saying its a part of his job for him being unwilling to kill people. I do agree this trope can be tiring but here it at least makes sense and if this chapter is any indication he himself realizes he may have no choice later down the line. So him refusing atm isn't a bad thing.
 
Supporter
Joined
Mar 20, 2019
Messages
996
Mercy to an enemy who clearly won't atone is a cruelty against the innocent
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Feb 25, 2023
Messages
227
So... the only way we can have a more competent MC is killing the girl... He needs that wake up call, but I hope he does not do a 180 and turns in to mister edgy mcedge, he just needs to understand that some times the most peaceful approach is to kill
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jul 17, 2023
Messages
300
So is his going for breakfast a consideration for Liana, a pre-planned stop from before the foreboding dream, or a detour to delay facing his fears? It doesn't feel planned with that conversation, and while I would normally think the first option it does feel like the last option here.
 

Me

Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 21, 2018
Messages
714
Author could have skipped the whole scene and just put a margin note next time MC forgives the wrong person: "I know, don't @ me"
Aww, c'mon. There's a space, the forums shouldn't have pinged me for this one!

Hi.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Apr 23, 2018
Messages
202
I agree with killing the demons, the lizard man and werewolves already killed a ton of folks.

He was able to have the Divine Lancer atone for his sins and hopefully he'll be rehabilitated.

There is a time and place for everything.
 
Fed-Kun's army
Joined
Sep 8, 2024
Messages
321
Yeah, I'll give you the adventurer bit, but also remember that he was a (not very good) healer (iirc, there's a lot of these abandoned by your party and I haven't seen him do any healing lately so I can't remember lol, I just know he was a back liner). So he probably didn't have much actual combat experience. Being in a party where things are killed and being the one doing the killing is a bit different.
Well, MC is ranked 1 in terms of white mage, ordinary white mage can only increase healing rate of a person, while MC can regenerate damaged tissues of a person (with the price of exhausted his aura). He have actual combat experience, that's why to compensate his weakness, he learns a lot about monsters mechanic etc to make sure the party can return unharmed (or at least minimize their damage) by rarely uses heal. (chapter 6 revealed by Kanata).

I admire his hard work, diligent, and persistence, but his half-assed resolve will get him nowhere.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top