SSS-Rank Dungeon de Knife Ippon Tewatasare Tsuihou Sareta Shiro Madoushi: Yggdrasil no Noroi ni yori Jakuten de aru Maryoku Fusoku wo Kokufuku-shi Se…

[ohms]

Another forced redemption of a character we care nothing about. If you wanted to create a believable redemption plot, at least make us familiar with the said character before hand. This feels ass pull and utterly pointless.

 

[StLL]

nice

 

[HiiroMimori]

Yes, what she did is still wrong, she didn't act because she's afraid of losing her place in the party, but at least she aware of it and need to be punished as well like the other party members (but not too severe).

 

[RMXStudio]

I'm not saying that it's not a credible characterization. Humans can and do behave like this. I just don't feel any sympathy for these types. There is a point where they lose it for me. For Feil here, that's after they killed another white mage. For that other example, that's when the "friend" allowed her party to go after the MC's party that last time. They might deserve redemption, eventually, but they have a lot to do to get my sympathy back. Wallowing in self-pity doesn't cut it.

I agree wholeheartedly. It's a credible personality, just not one I sympathize with.

 

[Tildeath]

Ghost girl said “you have been coming here so many times” and we know that dungeon is not something you can do solo. So she has been risking her life many times to save him

Even if one says that she could have done much more, that doesn't invalidate what she has done and is trying to do for him.

It absolutely does invalidate it cuz she's only doing it for herself she doesn't genuinely believe he's alive she's just there to quench her guilt and feel like she tried
As an example imagine you watch your "friend" get beaten, stabbed and tossed in the ocean while you just do nothing and you never see him come back up then years later you come back to that same ocean to dive & search for him even if that ocean is filled with dangerous sharks do you believe you're doing it for him do you genuinely believe he'll be alive years later what do you think you'll find? do you even have the audacity to consider yourself his friend just for doing this?
That's basically what she did to him.
If she was threatened I'd at least understand she's a victim too but she was just like "they're not listening to me so that's rough for you buddy 🤷🏻‍♀️" she watched her "friend" get repeatedly beaten, stabbed and kicked into a river that flowed to the most dangerous floor while he was unconscious, had no fighting ability, food/water but cuz she feels guilty and comes back years later to look for what his bones? it's ok?

SUMMARY: She didn't do shi for him she just tried to make herself feel like she tried. She's just as guilty as the others. And I don't care if sum1 says "well you would do nothing too" it doesn't make it less terrible and do not project yourself onto me I would never do nothing especially not for someone supposed to be my friend.