I've been meaning to put this kind of character interaction somewhere, but I can't really find the right place/project to fit it into yet.
- - - - - - - - - -
A few weeks ago I asked a friend of mine why he was so unwilling to give his personal opinion on whatever we'd talk about. It didn't matter what the subject was; from philosophy to recent events to movies to porn preferences, when pressed to give his thoughts he'd usually just give an evasive answer, accompanied by an uncomfortable smile.
"Depends on the circumstances".
"I'd have to read more on the topic to give you an answer".
"I don't think I really care deeply enough to have an opinion."
This habit extended beyond our long-winded conversations. We'd been best friends for over six years, and I still didn't know what he did for a living. When asked, he'd just give me that uncomfortable look again, like a cornered animal. He'd then ask if I really needed to know; that he could do so, and I had nothing to worry about, but he would much rather not. I thought myself a good friend and, frankly, I didn't really care enough to force him just to satisfy a passing curiosity. I knew him for long enough to know it probably wasn't prostitution, or anything illegal. This was just part of his frustrating but ultimately harmless quirk.
When I asked him why he was so cagey when it came to opinions, I started by giving him my view on the matter (as would often happen in any of our conversations). As a kid, I told him, I was very passive within my friend groups, and would just go with the flow. That I'd nod, maybe laugh, or just stayed silent even when I had a different opinion or, heaven forbid, disagreed. And how liberating it had felt as I grew up when I found that people (good people, at least) would actually listen to my perspectives. Maybe not agree with them, but even then at least take them into account. I concluded by telling my friend that I was more than happy to say hundreds of dumb statements if it meant not staying quiet when something really needed to be said.
My friend patiently listened to my opinion to the end (as he so often would), even as it slowly lapsed briefly into a vague societal rant. He then shook his head. "I understand the feeling," he said "but I can't personally agree with it. I'm all for freedom of speech, don't get me wrong. But if I had to choose between giving an opinion based on vaguely understood information, or something I don't feel passionate about, I'd rather just not say anything at all. Opinions and people change, but I'd rather say more things I can look back proudly on even over several years than ones I'll just regret in a few weeks time."
I shrugged, explaining that frankly I was much more interested in hearing his opinion as my friend, someone whose company I already knew I liked. I wasn't really looking for objective truths in other people's personal opinions, just a better glimpse at their characters. "I don't really expect other people to do the same as I do." he replied with a vague wave of his hand "I guess it's like you say, just a part of my character. I prefer things this way."
In the end, we politely agreed to disagree, and ended the conversation there. His reply however continued to bother me. I still strongly believed that, if a middle ground was out of the question, then it was far more preferable to say something, to voice even a not fully coherent thought or feeling, rather than let the moment slip past and be lost for good. But still, I had to think; how often had I given my opinion on things I didn't really care that deeply about? Passing interests. High concepts like death of the author or historical periods, which frankly didn't affect my personal life as deeply as my heated arguments over it warranted. And these were hardly strange or odd behaviours, either. Not as uncommon as my friend's near-paranoid commitment to caution seemed to be, at least. Everywhere you'd go, on the Internet and outside, it seemed you'd be bombarded with the quick, easily digestible personal thoughts and opinions of ultimately strangers.
Reflecting on this, I quietly thought to myself how blessed I was to have him as my friend.
- - - - - - -
I guess this turned out to be way more than a few stray lines in the end.