People are acting so weird about MC.
Its obvious he founds the girls hot and would be all over them if he wasn't fucking scared about them reproducing out of control if he kisses them.
Specially after learning from Cherry and her daughter, than they can be dangerous.
So what are you expecting from him?
He wont kiss them, he doesn't want more problems (too late, the police has them now) and he doesn't want to kill Cherry because he likes her.
Its not a situation where you can really act with confidence. All the possible options suck.