Double-page supporter
- Joined
- Dec 3, 2023
- Messages
- 27
The reverse harem tag made me think that it had romance but to be honest, I was just venting my frustrations because I recently finished the live action romance genderswap show that I mentioned in my comment and it just made me realise how boringly manga and anime handle genderswap themes and romance in general so I vented my frustrations in the comment 😅.
I think one of the reasons why I think genderswap themes in Manga and Anime are so boring is because they make the MC too dull, too adaptable, too simple, too one-sided, or too boring. Or sometimes they make the story about the genderswap itself, which makes it just boring.
One of the best examples of a good genderswap story is Fake Saint of the Year. Everything about it is just good for a genderswap manga/novel. The MC is overpowered, yes. But they're not dull at all. The later chapters get much more generic though (novel chapters), but that's fine because the story adds build up and y'know what.
A bad genderswap story is something like ONIMAI. Onimai, although a comedy manga, doesn't really have anything else other than just the comedy aspect. Like in the latest and newest chapters, it's always about school or how the MC gets pestered by the friend group, but it's getting so dull to the point where you just want to click out instead of reading more.
The point is: Genderswap mangas/novels aren't good unless they actually have some decency or rationality in them. It's an extra tag, but if done right, adds more depth to the story.