Tensei Shitara Ken Deshita - Vol. 15 Ch. 73 - Alchemist Eugene

Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 19, 2023
Messages
6,708
Half insect? His eyes look more demonic, though. I'd expect either normal human eyes, or compound eyes.

A cat liking bitter things is kind of unusual. Though they also don't have a taste (literally) for sweet things. Well, she's only "half" cat.

Fran enjoys being picked up. Really. She's just being a tsundere about it, because she's a cat. Well, actually, she doesn't seem to mind terribly much. Just a bit unamused.

She's also unimpressed by that Charlie's Angels pose.

I like fake eyepatch girl. She's weird.

Dressing up as maids is never wrong.

A man of culture.

The author has no clue. I love this story but pricing has always been the weakest part.
Random numbers go!
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Oct 12, 2018
Messages
1,811
First the tea, then the “Magic Water”. Were we all thinking the same thing?
 
Fed-Kun's army
Joined
Aug 27, 2023
Messages
13
The pricing does not translate to USD, it translates to Yen. The Scarlet Maidens are actually being heavily underpaid.

In the novel it explains that they were working underpaid because Fran and Master promised to feed them for free for the duration of their work. Like Colbert they have foodie tendencies. For some reason the manga cut that part of the conversation out.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Nov 17, 2018
Messages
2,096
What the fuck 10,000 gold each? What the hell happened to the economy, I'll be a salesgirl for that much money.
So 1 copper coin is 1 gold, and 1 silver coin is 100 gold, and 1 gold coin is 10,000 gold because it's all Yen-derived with prices being much lower overall for a lot of basic things. They are being hired for a considerable amount of work, across multiple days, to assist with everything; the salary is more than understandable.

That aside...
FRAN IN A MAID OUTFIT!
FRAN IN A MAID OUTFIT!
FRAN IN A MAID OUTFIT!
FRAN IN A MAID OUTFIT!
 
Fed-Kun's army
Joined
Jul 10, 2018
Messages
250
damn, that dog woman was drawn twice as thick as her compatriats
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Nov 11, 2019
Messages
973
So 1 copper coin is 1 gold, and 1 silver coin is 100 gold, and 1 gold coin is 10,000 gold because it's all Yen-derived with prices being much lower overall for a lot of basic things. They are being hired for a considerable amount of work, across multiple days, to assist with everything; the salary is more than understandable.

That aside...
FRAN IN A MAID OUTFIT!
FRAN IN A MAID OUTFIT!
FRAN IN A MAID OUTFIT!
FRAN IN A MAID OUTFIT!
So they named the currency "gold". Probably should be translated to "gol" or "golt" or "golde" not to confuse people
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Nov 17, 2018
Messages
2,096
So they named the currency "gold". Probably should be translated to "gol" or "golt" or "golde" not to confuse people
1) No. Not only is there a long history of this so only those new to such stories could possibly be confused (I mean, it WAS explained already earlier, so it's more a case of forgetting what you read, unless you just skimmed and didn't read it, and that's still on you, just even more shameful) but it's an homage to video game series like Wizardry and Dragon Quest and such, that are the original inspiration for many of these types of stories.

2) NO. Fuck ALL localization bullshit. It's gold, translate it as gold, period. If your brain can't wrap its head around the currency being named the same as the largest individual coin, that's on you.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Aug 16, 2020
Messages
1,529
wonder when Amanda will arrive :thonk:
( will she be nyooming the moment she receives the message :pacman: )
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Dec 26, 2018
Messages
3,139
2) NO. Fuck ALL localization bullshit. It's gold, translate it as gold, period. If your brain can't wrap its head around the currency being named the same as the largest individual coin, that's on you.
Assuming in original "gold coins" were "kinka", and currency was "gorudo" (that is, very distinct words), I do not mind if the translation uses "gorudo" as a name of the currency, to keep them distinct.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Nov 17, 2018
Messages
2,096
Assuming in original "gold coins" were "kinka", and currency was "gorudo" (that is, very distinct words), I do not mind if the translation uses "gorudo" as a name of the currency, to keep them distinct.
Transliterating instead of translating is better than most other forms of localizing, but it's still localizing. It's like when fan translations for Coiling Dragon came upon O'Brien's name in Chinese, [奥布莱恩], and transliterated it as "Ao'bu'lai'en" or "Aobulaien" to exoticify it, when it's just "O'Brien".

We don't get confused when using one dollar bills or coins in currencies called dollars, so calling the currency gold while the largest coin is also called gold should be completely understandable. Once again, if it's not, that's on you, the reader, for not being able to grok it. Especially when references to actual gold coins are written as "(value) gold coins", and any non-coin values are written as just "(value) gold".
 
Joined
Dec 19, 2023
Messages
7
Transliterating instead of translating is better than most other forms of localizing, but it's still localizing. It's like when fan translations for Coiling Dragon came upon O'Brien's name in Chinese, [奥布莱恩], and transliterated it as "Ao'bu'lai'en" or "Aobulaien" to exoticify it, when it's just "O'Brien".

We don't get confused when using one dollar bills or coins in currencies called dollars, so calling the currency gold while the largest coin is also called gold should be completely understandable. Once again, if it's not, that's on you, the reader, for not being able to grok it. Especially when references to actual gold coins are written as "(value) gold coins", and any non-coin values are written as just "(value) gold".
The reason we don't get confused using other currencies is because we don't have things called the dollar bill that has a value different than a dollar. Just because there is logic to the distinction in the series does not mean it is good logic.

They already have a value for 1 gold set to 1 copper why still use gold in this way? Why not just say 1 gold coin, it's the same value as 10,000 gold
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top