The Friends-Eater Classroom - Vol. 3 Ch. 22 - Game 10 - Bone (Part 1)

[MangaDex]

 

[faniki]

Who's hiroaki again? shouta's childhood friend?
Also not surprised at how fast that girl turned on kanae

 

[Oz_otR]

Jesus these mofos go straight for the arm?!? hes got toes and fingers no?

 

[hxppythxughts]

Here’s hoping that shouta isn’t “extremely good natured” anymore after his Waifu got fucking eviscerated

I wanna see the mc be badass for once

 

[Ominous]

I can't help myself from thinking about that bone instead of a bone.

This image here does not help: https://prnt.sc/jwzonb

 

[Nick86]

Why a whole arm? A finger is enought.

 

[criver]

Cause the manga is dumb as fuck. The author can't even realize there's an easy way out for most of these.

 

[LysandersTreason]

Seriously, it also doesn't even say how MUCH bone. Literally could use a digit from a pinkie, grind it up into a powder and split it as many ways as necessary

 

[Dysisa]

Ever heard of the saying "better safe than sorry"?

 

[Harvester]

If I recall correctly, losing the ring finger is the least disruptive digit to remove... the pinky actually has some significant, if subtle, use. Third or fourth toe is probably even better.

 

[criver]

@Dysisa: Ever heard the saying "fictional characters are at most as intelligent as the author"?

 

[Dysisa]

@criver
I most definitely have, but I think this one is a case of them being intentionally written dumb for the sake of ~drama~ and to rile up people like, by the looks of things, you.

 

[criver]

@Dysisa: Ah, the age-old "I was only pretending to be retarded" explanation it is.

Authors should be employing your argument more often when criticized. That way we'll know that their bad writing is intentional, but they're actually god-tier.
/s

 

[Dysisa]

@criver
Do you only see things in black and white or something? The writing of this manga is terrible, but you are completely failing to understand why because you're trying too hard too criticize both it and the author. "The characters are dumb so the author is dumb" is the same kind of idiocy as "this character is a piece of shit so this author is a piece of shit". It's almost like it's a recurring trend across the entire horror genre for characters to be dumb and illogical since that's what makes the story move forward, for better or worse.

To put things clear; this manga sucks, and so does your criticism of it. Have a nice day.

 

[criver]

@Dysisa: What exactly is your point? You seem to agree that the author can't write to save his life from what I gather. But you also seem to believe that there is no correlation between his terrible writing and his intelligence? Is that it? You're pissed that I am stating the obvious fact that character depth, intelligence, and believability is mostly limited by the author's creativity, experience, and intelligence?

I mean it would have been one thing if you just said that implying something about the author's intelligence based on his characters is pretty farfetched and I would have agreed (at the end of the day my original statement has the implication the other way around anyways). But you had to pull out "an argument" about how commonplace terrible horror writing somehow justifies the terrible writing in this piece of work. Is that a joke?

Then you even state that "that's what makes the story move forward". As if one couldn't have a plot development in a horror without having intellectually disabled characters. Hello!? Last time I checked their school didn't seem to be a special institution.

Forget the fact that you even managed to "quote" me by rewriting what I stated to fit your narrative. You like strawmen that much?

 

[owlette]

this is so stupid, does it have to be an entire arm? just exactly how big does the vaccine have to be? does it have to be an entire bone or just some part of it? even if it was an entire bone, you can just take off a knuckle from a finger, it's not that bad

i wish the author would at least clarify and say something like "the vaccine of the bone has to be at least one foot long" or something since they're automatically going for an entire arm bone. how tf are they planning on eating an entire arm bone anyways?

honestly if they just used their brains and got medical equipment and only took off the minimum amount of a body part i'm sure they would all live

 

[Paru]

you could cut off the tip of a finger or toe ffs, don't just go straight for the whole damn arm

 

[Vahlokdotiid]

Bitches love a bone.

 

[Early]

I think a finger would be enough

 

[Corb]

One digit from a finger would do it.