This Villainess Wants a Divorce! - Vol. 1 Ch. 12

Double-page supporter
Joined
Feb 20, 2018
Messages
881
@RamenRider I feel you're missing my point. The book Canaria got this information from wasn't a retelling of actual events from one person's viewpoint. It was a novel. A work of fiction. Written by a fiction author. If there was nothing in the book indicating anything regarding your theory, then that stuff didn't happen. If the author didn't write the original Canaria to be a poor misunderstood girl who really was innocent, then she wasn't. That's all there is to it.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Oct 16, 2018
Messages
542
@Madcat6204
The logical route to what you're stating if taken to an extreme would mean the world simply does not exist outside of areas the characters traverse and the universe will cease to exist when they get to the final page. There's also no chicken or egg type confirmation as to if the (fictional) author was influenced by the existence of that world or the (fictional) author creating a fictional story created a universe. or even that the universe being the same/similar isn't merely an astounding coincidence.
All your argument really has accomplished is display you attempting to be a wet blanket without any substance backing it since the story is in progress and any details from the (fictional) author are at the whim of the (actual) author, so I'm not really sure why you're even bothering to start an argument neither side would possibly win due to the meta nature of it?
 
Double-page supporter
Joined
Feb 20, 2018
Messages
881
@RamenRider

Because you started it? You made a theory about the original Canaria... who was written by her author to be a specific, limited, villain character who got her comeuppance so the true heroine could get together with the protagonist. In a real world, yes, there could easily have been complexities to her character that no one else was aware of. But... she wasn't a real character. There never was a true "original" Canaria. She was a work of fiction, a literary contrivance. A collection of specific tropes used solely to interfere with the "destined" lovers getting together. I spoke up because it seemed like you'd forgotten that the "original" was a work of fiction, and were treating it more like a time-travel story, where the original Canaria was a real person who could have had unknown motivations and been misunderstood. I was attempting to remind you that, as interesting and tragic as that would have been, we already knew it wasn't the case, because our heroine has read the novel and knows what sort of person the character Canaria truly was.

Regarding the existence of the world, I feel you're still not getting what I'm saying. In the original novel, that our heroine read before she died and was reborn here, there WAS nothing outside of what was written. It's a NOVEL. The only content in it is what the author has put there. There is no universe or world involved. There is nothing outside what the author has written. That's the case with all books, manga, movies, tv shows, anime, stories, and any other fictional medium: the only content that exists is what the author has written, and there is nothing else outside of that.

THAT, has no bearing whatsoever on the world our Canaria is now living in. She isn't inside the book, she's in an actual world that is basically a "what if this story were real" sort of thing. For her, yes, there is plenty that can and does exist outside of what the novel covered. We've SEEN that: she had no idea the prince's palace and household were being robbed by greedy employees until said something to make her suspicious. For her, yes, this is a real world where a great many things may exist outside of what the novel covered.
 
Member
Joined
Apr 3, 2018
Messages
202
Im barely on ch 12 and mindblown theres 52 chaps so far. 😭 like i already feel all excited and happy, i cant imagine the pain amd angst to come as i keep reading.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jun 10, 2020
Messages
3,308
Wheeze he's like 'wow this tree reminds me of her' lol does it bear fruit or something? I'm curious to know the correlation
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 8, 2023
Messages
4,072
Your telling me this 4d chess fmc didnt think to check on her husbands household for a year? She knows what this is all like.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top