To all haters out there

[kamiofgods]

First of all, you guys clearly don't know how hard it is to make a good manga. It takes hours to build a entertaining and engaging storyline, even more time is then spent drafting how the manga looks and then drawing it takes up most of the time.
Second of all, if you think something is bad just don't say anything. Like I always say, spread love, not hate and if you want to spread hate, do it right. The only way to do it right in your case is by sending a proper email to the author complaining about the things they did wrong. Which is a hassle you people are too scared to do.
Finally, you have to remember, all manga are made by real people putting in an immense amount of effort so we can appreciate the work they made and be entertained by the things they made. Don't say "oh this manga sucks" or "oh they did this wrong" without saying what they did right at the very least. You have to realize that they have feelings too and if you continue with all the hate they might just stop making manga all together, no more bad manga sure but no more good manga either. Imagine a world without manga. With all the hate that world might become a reality in the future.

 

[MrIncognito]

If something does cause manga to disappear forever, I assure you it's not going to be people leaving non-constructive criticism on Mangadex

 

[Yatsuki]

What's the drama this time?

 

[orechan]

If something does cause manga to disappear forever, I assure you it's not going to be people leaving non-constructive criticism on Mangadex

also why would the mangaka be crushed from hate in a language they most likely don't speak on a website they don't go on

 

[Basic_human]

This dumb, saying criticism is bad

If it's bad id say bad, if it's good id say good. Even God get criticized.

build a entertaining and engaging storyline

If it's good no one will criticized.

stop making manga all together,

Most of axed manga are result of publisher axing it because it's doesn't sell

Also most of isekai derseve to cancelled anyway seeing all of it just copy paste format overpower MC slop.

 

[Robinisback]

Unrelated, but Harem sucks, if you incorporate it in your manga, you're earning my hate and your manga sucks.

 

[Basic_human]

Unrelated, but Harem sucks, if you incorporate it in your manga, you're earning my hate and your manga sucks.

Might be dumbest thread in a while lmao

From mind came thought, everyone is different in one aspect to another. Conflict come in bundle when everyone have mind on their own

 

[Robinisback]

Might be dumbest thread in a while lmao

From mind came thought, everyone is different in one aspect to another. Conflict come in bundle when everyone have mind on their own

So true, it seems that OP has forgotten that only time fans email author is when they're send death threats, seems like they've forgotten what the comments section is for.

 

[Basic_human]

So true, it seems that OP has forgotten that only time fans email author is when they're send death threats, seems like they've forgotten what the comments section is for.

For some extend I agree with him stop hating, like what Hirokoshi receive is really bad.

But saying criticism is bad all together is something different entirely.expectingt me not to shitting on kanokari while series I excited for getting axed is like expecting bread not to get moldy

 

[DavidianMillerian]

okay this has gotta be so stupid that I have to talk in uppercase and end my sentences in periods

gasp
I will now carefully deconstruct almost every part of whatever you just shat out.

Second of all, if you think something is bad just don't say anything. Like I always say, spread love, not hate and if you want to spread hate, do it right.

Non-constructive criticism is bad, sure, but if you wanted a place where ALL criticism is silenced, then just get a time machine and move to the Soviet Union.

The only way to do it right in your case is by sending a proper email to the author complaining about the things they did wrong. Which is a hassle you people are too scared to do.

"Too scared" is not the right combination of words. It's more like: "It's not worth the effort."

Finally, you have to remember, all manga are made by real people putting in an immense amount of effort so we can appreciate the work they made and be entertained by the things they made. Don't say "oh this manga sucks" or "oh they did this wrong" without saying what they did right at the very least. You have to realize that they have feelings too and if you continue with all the hate they might just stop making manga all together, no more bad manga sure but no more good manga either.

They have feelings, I get it, we get it.

But like @orechan said, are they really gonna be on the floor, bawling in tears, having an emotional breakdown, cancelling their manga and stop making them over a few guys' words in a language they don't understand nor speak, and in a website they'll never visit?

Imagine a world without manga. With all the hate that world might become a reality in the future.

Like @MrIncognito said, if something does cause manga to disappear forever, it certainly isn't going to be non-constructive criticism from people that don't even speak the same language as the author.

Look, dude, you have MASSIVE balls to even THINK of posting this and thinking that people would agree with you.

Sure, some parts of what you said, I agree, like what @Basic_human said, some manga don't deserve the hate that they get

But if you think your thread would do anything to stop these people, then I gotta reveal a shocking truth to ya:

NO ONE CARES.

sigh

I rest my case.

 

[Manko-sensei]

I cannot help but think that the post itself was a satire/troll attempt to make people blow fire. The funny part is the "a world without manga" as a result of hate, when publishing manga is all about making money and even NTR sells. And well, a world without manga has existed for hundreds of millenia of human existence, and most of that time had no wars or modern hate

 

[Robinisback]

okay this has gotta be so stupid that I have to talk in uppercase and end my sentences in periods

gasp
I will now carefully deconstruct almost every part of whatever you just shat out.


Non-constructive criticism is bad, sure, but if you wanted a place where ALL criticism is silenced, then just get a time machine and move to the Soviet Union.


"Too scared" is not the right combination of words. It's more like: "It's not worth the effort."


They have feelings, I get it, we get it.

But like @orechan said, are they really gonna be on the floor, bawling in tears, having an emotional breakdown, cancelling their manga and stop making them over a few guys' words in a language they don't understand nor speak, and in a website they'll never visit?


Like @MrIncognito said, if something does cause manga to disappear forever, it certainly isn't going to be non-constructive criticism from people that don't even speak the same language as the author.

Look, dude, you have MASSIVE balls to even THINK of posting this and thinking that people would agree with you.

Sure, some parts of what you said, I agree, like what @Basic_human said, some manga don't deserve the hate that they get

But if you think your thread would do anything to stop these people, then I gotta reveal a shocking truth to ya:

NO ONE CARES.

sigh

I rest my case.

I second allat, my honor!

As the defendant has implied, the plaintiff is trying to build a Totalitarian regime in the manga industry, hence, I request a sentence of 10 repeated readings of Rent a Girlfriend as a sentence!

Also, Every time Kazuya gets a boner, the plaintiff would have to take a shot.

 

[BakedBanana]

Unrelated, but Harem sucks, if you incorporate it in your manga, you're earning my hate and your manga sucks.

Also unrelated but if your manga is a one-page per chapter, it probably sucks too.
I give Ri-chan a pass.

 

[Angry_Panda]

Looks like someone just discovered the internet!

 

[Basic_human]

Everybody except nyan be like this lmao

 

[Doedoel]

To all the manga haters, I have one thing to say to you: middle finger.

Also I sentence you with explosion from my mind.

 

[BzzBzz]

And well, a world without manga has existed for hundreds of millenia of human existence, and most of that time had no wars or modern hate

Wrong. Manga is known for 50,000 years at least.

Well, more like doujinshi than manga... but still 😎

 

[kamiofgods]

dont know how a misunderstanding lead to all this but what i meant is more or less just keep things to yourself even if you hate a manga. perhaps i exaggerated some parts but seriously. its tiring to always see people downgrading a manga just because it doesnt suit their tastes.

 

[kamiofgods]

If it's good no one will criticized.

i made this thread because of people posting useless(not even constructive) criticism which a large majority dont even agree with. like just imagine you enjoying a manga, deciding to check the comments and the first thing you see is criticism which the comments afterwards disagree with and in most cases are just complete 100% opinion and no facts. im not saying people cant have an opinion but i am however saying people shouldn't voice out opinions which dont help anybody and in most cases just cause people stress

 

[kamiofgods]

Looks like someone just discovered the internet!

not really. i just woke up one day and chose constructive violence(using text) would prefer physical violence(i havent been in a fight for so long im bored) but thats a hassle