Tomodachi tte Konna koto surun da. - Vol. 1 Ch. 2

Dex-chan lover
Joined
Oct 29, 2019
Messages
172
Thanks for picking up Yukio Yuki's manga, her works are always so wholesome and adorable so it's great to see another work being translated. :hearts:

That being said, and forgive me for being blunt, but it's really hard to read it as the translation is just horrendous. Some sentences don't make much sense and the grammar is a hit and miss(miss in most cases). It ends up just being distracting and instead of enjoying I have to force myself to ignore most mistakes and try to make sense of what is actually being said which kind of ruins the reading experience. :nyoron:

Now obviously every reader here is in no position to simply criticize it, seeing as you're doing everything on your own and without any form of compensation so we should be just be happy about the fact that someone's decided to get it done, so if you want some help I can at least do some proofreading to see if it would somewhat improve the end result.
 
Active member
Joined
Apr 18, 2026
Messages
12
Thanks for picking up Yukio Yuki's manga, her works are always so wholesome and adorable so it's great to see another work being translated. :hearts:

That being said, and forgive me for being blunt, but it's really hard to read it as the translation is just horrendous. Some sentences don't make much sense and the grammar is a hit and miss(miss in most cases). It ends up just being distracting and instead of enjoying I have to force myself to ignore most mistakes and try to make sense of what is actually being said which kind of ruins the reading experience. :nyoron:

Now obviously every reader here is in no position to simply criticize it, seeing as you're doing everything on your own and without any form of compensation so we should be just be happy about the fact that someone's decided to get it done, so if you want some help I can at least do some proofreading to see if it would somewhat improve the end result.
I would highly appreciate that! English isn’t my first language 💕🫰🫰🫰
 
Last edited:
Fed-Kun's army
Joined
Mar 22, 2024
Messages
42
Now obviously every reader here is in no position to simply criticize it, seeing as you're doing everything on your own and without any form of compensation so we should be just be happy about the fact that someone's decided to get it done
i've never understood this mentality. just because someone shit out garbage for free doesn't make it not garbage nor does it make it above criticism. say for example i fed the new chapter of sasakoi into chatgpt and uploaded that completely unedited, would you then be required to be happy about that?
don't bother replying, i won't read it.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Oct 29, 2019
Messages
172
i've never understood this mentality. just because someone shit out garbage for free doesn't make it not garbage nor does it make it above criticism. say for example i fed the new chapter of sasakoi into chatgpt and uploaded that completely unedited, would you then be required to be happy about that?
If you'd read my comment thoroughly, you'd notice that I said "simply criticize", meaning that people shouldn't just say stuff like: It's garbage; You've wasted everyone's time; Why bother doing it in the first place if it's rubbish; etc.

If you want to provide criticism for someone's voluntary work, how about you do it constructively? Point out the errors you've noticed or how the job can be done better by giving tips, instead of just throwing plain insults.
don't bother replying, i won't read it.
Perfect example of entitled people who expect everything to be handed to them whilst never doing anything themselves.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Mar 3, 2020
Messages
779
thank youuuuu!
I'm very glad to have this starting to get translated~

also your translation isn't horrendous by any means. there weren't that many errors overall (and most were pronoun issues?). wayyyy better than MTL to be sure
but that is certain to improve with a proofreader going forward :3
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Aug 10, 2023
Messages
1,478
A real, "Oh no! Not the consequences of my own actions!" moment there, lol. If you didn't want her to fuck other people, you shouldn't've said that's normal for friends. Use a different lie!
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Nov 20, 2023
Messages
16,792
lol interesting to come across the 'gaslighting' term in a non-psych manga (altho feels more like straight up lying)

i wonder if mc's gonna come across a previous 'fwb' that the other girl had
Funny part is Ayu would immediately tell Riri who the call was from if she just asked. :wooow:

Considering she only studied and didn't have other friends i'd assume it was a relative lol
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top