Grant us eyes! Grant us eyes!The Brain of Mensis bringing them to a world of Winter Lanterns? They're in the Nightmare of Mensis!
![]()
Thank you for the explanation! That makes sense why oni die when they wish away their horns; but I wonder, if you wished to be the you of right before you became an oni, would that work? Or to become a child again? Perhaps I don't exactly get it, though...Phew, I almost thought I would have to wait another year for the next chapter. It's really not fun trying to read the raw. Though I can say for certain the next chapter is the best one for this volume. Well, the long wait gave me time to think about what mantra means in the story.
Mantra is metal casting, not alchemy — like that biscuit image in chapter 29. It reshapes the world the way a mold reshapes metal. The key insight is that casting changes form, never substance. Metal doesn't become wood. Oni are therefore humans in a different shape, not a different species.
This explains three mysteries at once.
Animals don't become oni through cannibalism because animals don't become anything. A wolf doesn't dream of being a better wolf. A crow doesn't look at its reflection and imagine a different version of itself. Only humans live in a constant state of becoming. Children think about what they want to be when they grow up. A woman marries and becomes a wife. A monk shaves his head and becomes a holy man. A lonely boy reads manga and becomes an otaku. People change their names, take on titles, adopt new roles — every stage of human life is another act of becoming something else. That is mantra.
This is also why wishing to stop being oni causes you to die. It's the same as wishing to stop being human — you stop being human when you die.
And finally, the gods are different forms of reality. The sun, the river, the mountain — they were there before humans. But then humans came and their mantra reshaped and gave the sun, the mountain, the river new forms as gods. The kami are the spirit within each phenomenon, given form by mantra. A very Shinto and Japanese view.
Oooooooh... I love the way you worded this, marvelous explanation, friend, simply marvelous.Phew, I almost thought I would have to wait another year for the next chapter. It's really not fun trying to read the raw. Though I can say for certain the next chapter is the best one for this volume. Well, the long wait gave me time to think about what mantra means in the story.
Mantra is metal casting, not alchemy — like that biscuit image in chapter 29. It reshapes the world the way a mold reshapes metal. The key insight is that casting changes form, never substance. Metal doesn't become wood. Oni are therefore humans in a different shape, not a different species.
This explains three mysteries at once.
Animals don't become oni through cannibalism because animals don't become anything. A wolf doesn't dream of being a better wolf. A crow doesn't look at its reflection and imagine a different version of itself. Only humans live in a constant state of becoming. Children think about what they want to be when they grow up. A woman marries and becomes a wife. A monk shaves his head and becomes a holy man. A lonely boy reads manga and becomes an otaku. People change their names, take on titles, adopt new roles — every stage of human life is another act of becoming something else. That is mantra.
This is also why wishing to stop being oni causes you to die. It's the same as wishing to stop being human — you stop being human when you die.
And finally, the gods are different forms of reality. The sun, the river, the mountain — they were there before humans. But then humans came and their mantra reshaped and gave the sun, the mountain, the river new forms as gods. The kami are the spirit within each phenomenon, given form by mantra. A very Shinto and Japanese view.
Pleasantness: 5