Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Mar 6, 2018
- Messages
- 186
@papercraft When did i say they have consent? You keep nitpicking on the fact i said that i think mangadex is the lesser evil. I have never disagreed that mangadex is illegal or is in the wrong.
"THIS SITE IS NO BETTER THAN ANY SITE HOSTING mangas/manwhas/manhua UNLESS THEY ARE EACH INDIVIDUALLY GIVEN CONSENT BY AN AUTHOR. You literally ignored that fact and pushed on your views without evidence. "
Dude there are literally bunch of websites who earns money with illegal scans. That doesn't justify mangadex at all, but there are different levels of wrong. All of them are illegal and doesn't have permission but you are ignoring the part of the profit.
For evidence, there are literally bunch of scanlators groups who always ask to not upload on aggreagators website because they earn money with ad revenue. Look for the manga credits. That isn't a new information at all. Mangarock rings a bell? They are dead now, but when they were active they even had their own app and offered a premium subscription before.
If you think an illegal hosting website is the same as one that profits on illegal content, well i don't agree with this notion, for me they are still bad but not on the same level. And you think otherwise.
This argument is over, we are getting nowhere with that as we have opposite views and we are just circling around.
" I never got dismissive about THE AUTHORS. "
Yes, you didn't and i had said previously i was glad you don't antagonize the authors and it was my mistake. "
"I got MAD AT SOMEONE who READS ILLEGAL THINGS and THEN DISMISS TRANSLATORS to TRANSLATING ILLEGAL THINGS. You KEEP IGNORING THAT FACT. Stop creating your own assumptions, and then argue to someone for something you can’t argue."
NO ONE DID THAT. THE COMMENT WAS LITERALLY " RESPECT HER WISHES " AND " THE LEAST WE COULD DO IS TO SHOW SOME RESPECT " . I rly don't see where you got all that from those comments.
The whole point was " let's not say insensitive things when the author gets mad, just be respectful ". But you skipped that part and went directly to ARE YOU TELLING PEOPLE TO STOP TRANSLATING ?? YOU HYPOCRITE.
I'm also tired. You ignore my points, change things and i'm the one creating my assumptions?! I'm ending my part of this discussion too, even if i keep replying more you would probably still keep pointing abt MANGADEX IS WRONG, even thought i have never disagreed with that.
"THIS SITE IS NO BETTER THAN ANY SITE HOSTING mangas/manwhas/manhua UNLESS THEY ARE EACH INDIVIDUALLY GIVEN CONSENT BY AN AUTHOR. You literally ignored that fact and pushed on your views without evidence. "
Dude there are literally bunch of websites who earns money with illegal scans. That doesn't justify mangadex at all, but there are different levels of wrong. All of them are illegal and doesn't have permission but you are ignoring the part of the profit.
For evidence, there are literally bunch of scanlators groups who always ask to not upload on aggreagators website because they earn money with ad revenue. Look for the manga credits. That isn't a new information at all. Mangarock rings a bell? They are dead now, but when they were active they even had their own app and offered a premium subscription before.
If you think an illegal hosting website is the same as one that profits on illegal content, well i don't agree with this notion, for me they are still bad but not on the same level. And you think otherwise.
This argument is over, we are getting nowhere with that as we have opposite views and we are just circling around.
" I never got dismissive about THE AUTHORS. "
Yes, you didn't and i had said previously i was glad you don't antagonize the authors and it was my mistake. "
"I got MAD AT SOMEONE who READS ILLEGAL THINGS and THEN DISMISS TRANSLATORS to TRANSLATING ILLEGAL THINGS. You KEEP IGNORING THAT FACT. Stop creating your own assumptions, and then argue to someone for something you can’t argue."
NO ONE DID THAT. THE COMMENT WAS LITERALLY " RESPECT HER WISHES " AND " THE LEAST WE COULD DO IS TO SHOW SOME RESPECT " . I rly don't see where you got all that from those comments.
The whole point was " let's not say insensitive things when the author gets mad, just be respectful ". But you skipped that part and went directly to ARE YOU TELLING PEOPLE TO STOP TRANSLATING ?? YOU HYPOCRITE.
I'm also tired. You ignore my points, change things and i'm the one creating my assumptions?! I'm ending my part of this discussion too, even if i keep replying more you would probably still keep pointing abt MANGADEX IS WRONG, even thought i have never disagreed with that.
