what are the most realistic manga in terms of characters you ever read?

Joined
Mar 25, 2018
Messages
14
now whether the story it self is realistic or not doesn't really matter. the story could be space monkeys fighting a banana overlord and still be ok.

for example to get you to what i mean by "realistic":

in terms of characters, monster is more realistic than naruto. both are not exactly realistic, but when you compare them you can say one is more realistic. everything is relative. the most realistic manga in terms of characters telling doesn't have to be exactly realistic, it just have to be the most realistic one compared to whatever you have read or in your experience or your manga journey.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jul 4, 2018
Messages
5,172
I don't feel like digging through my readlist for now but two mangas I instantly think of are 5Toubun no Hanayome and Kenja no Mago.
 
Member
Joined
Jun 21, 2018
Messages
223
RE Zero. With all the edge that people think that the series has, they don't realize the fact that the characters are very deep themselves and their actions are realistic enough to see the psychology behind the characters.
Fom the start of the series and our two main characters:
there's Subaru, that seems like the typical isekai'd character with no cares in the world, but you can see from how he tries to place humour in his own situation is his way of coping from being isekai'd. He also shows clear actions of someone in stress. He attempts to solve situations preemptively and complains when things don't go his way, gives up when he fails (multiple times, in fact), and implodes in a grand fashion.
There's Emilia that appears to be the token heroine of justice, but lacks all of the important details. She lacks confidence for one, doubts even her savior (Subaru), things that would be realistic for someone with her background.
Even the secondary characters aren't merely orbital characters and are fueled by their own interest and show their own quirks.


Other than that, there's Otoyomegatari, Mushoku Tensei, The Lady and Her Butler (a manhwa, but whatever), Akagami no Shirayukihime and Radiant (doesn't really show until rumble town).
 
Double-page supporter
Joined
Nov 9, 2018
Messages
374
still not sure what you mean by realistic but I'll go with the definition of manga that has characters that feel like a real human

and what I want to mention is, ironically does not feature human at all, Beastar

I think I know more but that's just one from the top of my head.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jul 4, 2018
Messages
5,172
K now I sort of have time. I went through my readlist and got eight that caught my eye in terms of well-built characters. I put in a decent amount of effort to hopefully spark your interest as well. No spoilers given in any of the following.

5Toubun no Hanayome
20679.jpg

Description:
Uesugi Fuutarou is a poor, antisocial ace student who one day meets the rich transfer student Nakano Itsuki. They argue but when Uesugi realizes he is to be her tutor, he tries to get on better terms. While trying to do so he meets four other girls.


This is one of my favourite romance mangas of all time and coincidentally the only harem that I really love so far. The protagonist, Fuutarou, is your normal straight-A student who puts 110% effort into every assignment and test when he suddenly meets five quintuplets who are on the verge (they've way past this lol) of failing class.

The mangaka is quite the genius. The plot of the manga remains highly unpredictable despite the average-sounding synopsis using a clever mixture of cliche-breaking scenes and trope-defying character personalities. The side characters here have a big part in how each and every story arc plays out despite being side characters and the main ones have constantly-developing personalities that it's quite life-like. Every arc has a development for every character and this continues on from the beginning to the very end. I love how each and every plot twists unfold and the essence of each character shines bright. As character growth and their interactions with one another develops continuously, so will your favourite waifu since the author really knows how to play with your emotions MIKU FOREVER.
nakano_miku__go_toubun_no_hanayome__render_057_by_yamyumchann_dd0gqqe-pre.png

Yajin
27870.jpg

Description:
Ghosts can't be seen.
Ghosts can't be touched.
We don't even know if they exist.
Onda Iko is a middle school student.
Onda Iko can see ghosts.
And there's one... haunting Onda Iko's room.
The adventure story about boys, girls and ghosts starts here!


This is a fast-paced horror manga about a girl who suffers from her ability to see ghosts and two boys who just happened to relate to her. Without spoiling, I can say that this is a very action-packed manga. It's more shounen then seinen tho.

The plot progression and characters are all very well-written and organic. They are teenagers, the manga perfectly encaptures the essence of that - their fears, their curiosity, their reflexes, immature quick-thinking is exactly how a teenager would react. And the "adults" (can't say cause it's a spoiler, they're more like older figures than adults) are great as well. They don't panic for anything except for things that you would expect adults to panic to, their experience and maturity are very easily noticeable through a combination of actions and words. If you want a good horror-action shounen, I highly reccommend giving this a go.

Pseudo Harem
30945.jpg

Description:
The story of Nanakura Rin of the Drama Club, who has indisputable talent as an actress, and her senpai in the same club, Kitahama Eiji. With the power of her acting, Rin teases Eiji with a variety of personas, giving him the harem he's always dreamed of!


This is a cute and short manga about two high schoolers. The twist is that the girl acts like some character trope you see from a generic harem when the boy jokes about wanting a harem and it's been an inside joke ever since. Each chapter is five pages long iirc and the atmosphere is very cute and light-hearted, read this if you want to relax.

Since it's so light, it's very hard to mess this up so it's no surprise that the characters are good - but no, if you're expecting good you would be surprised by amazing character progression (not in the romance progression side but in the character interaction side). You still see some romance cliches like one misunderstanding the other's confession and stuff but in terms of character personalities, the mangaka pulled it off incredibly. I might be overexagerating but trust me this is dope.

Kenja no Mago
18964.jpg

Description:
Thanks to various magic, the human race has been saved from calamity many, many times. Retaining his memories from his previous life, a boy, Shin, was picked up by an old man known to the world as the "Magi."
Shin was brought up by the Magi, who had retired to a secular place, as his own grandson. With the memories of his past life, he absorbed the Magi's craft and grew to be able to develop his own magic
Then, the grandfather told him he has to become independent when he reaches the age of 15.
"Ah, I forgot to teach him common sense."
The grandson who has grown beyond the level of normal people, lacked common sense; the common sense of the world. So to learn how to socialize, he goes to Earlshide Kingdom City to be admitted to Earlshide Advanced Magic Academy.


Yeah that synopsis sounds generic but I promise you it's good. There's the anime running this season as well.

As far as isekai goes, this is pretty basic. But what I love about this series isn't the isekai - it's the characters. The characters are pretty believable and surprisingly none are two-dimensional. This is a case of "don't judge a book by its cover" or "premise is dull but execution is great".

Character development comes slow but steadily, rather praiseworthy imo. The author transformed a boring premise into a fun and enjoyable isekai about a generic protagonist who gets more OP every chapter who is transformed to be memorable and charming by using a rich set of side and main characters who accompanies him everywhere. As he further breaks the balance of power of this new world, he and his crew progresses in their personalities and interactions in an attractive way that clicks with the readers. I really love well-written characters and this generic isekai has really sparked my interest which is why I'm putting it in this list despite having a 7.49/10 rating.

And one more thing: my favourite character here is the antagonist. Maybe I haven't seen enough to become the wiser but as of right now, this is by far the best-written antagonist I have ever seen. I'm talking strictly-antagonist, not first-antagonist-then-protagonist. It's hard to explain without spoiling so you'll just have to take my words for it. I'll sum this up into two parts: backstory-antagonist, and present-antagonist. Backstory-antagonist tells the story of how he turned into the villian of the story; how he started out like the protagonist and you and me, normal people - that's what you would think. He was much more than normal, which further dramatizes his transformation to become the villian. He was supposed to be the protagonist of his story but was forced to become the villian by circumstances that he did not deserve a single bit. Present-villian is very simple and relatable, he have one goal and nothing else, in fact, a lot of the conflicts in the latter chapter are run by his underlings rather than himself (not a spoiler) and even this transition of source of conflict is taken care of steadily and with wisdom.

TL;DR
This manga has great characters which make its generic plot actually very fun. Give it ten chapters.

Maou-jou de Oyasumi
19193.jpg

Description:
Sshhh! Princess Syalis is trying to get a good night's sleep. Some shut-eye. Forty winks. Catch some Z's. Long ago in olden times when people and demons lived together in—well, disharmony, really—a demon king kidnaps a human princess and imprisons her in his castle. Bereft, the princess's subjects beat their chests in anguish…until a hero arises to spearhead Project Rescue Our Princess! While waiting for her knight in shining armor, what's an imprisoned princess to do...? Teddy-bear guards with bat wings are all very well, but her dungeon cell is bo-o-o-ring! So, she decides to wile away the long hours by sleeping. Now if only she could get comfortable…and didn't suffer from insomnia...


This is a cute comedy about a loli who absolutely wrecks her kidnappers in the name of some sleep.

More onto the characters, everyone is lovely. You can be assured that character growth and interactions are both well-written, I'm gonna head into the why. The demons in this manga are your basic JRPG enemies but they are written to have human personalities so that they are super relatable. The hostage princess also just wants some shut-eye - everyday; who doesn't? Everyone has unique traits, past, character design, obsessions, embarrassing things, and overall form a very wholesome family which would be incomplete without each other. I need an anime adaptation. I must have it

Can't really say much cause it's better to experience it yourself. The manga is incredibly funny and relatable, I mean it have 11 volumes so you already know that this flies really well in Japan.

Sachiiro no One Room
22284.jpg

Description:
One day, a fourteen year-old girl was kidnapped... or so the police have been lead to believe. Actually, she tried to run away from her abusive parents and was helped by her stalker who then shelters her in his apartment. Although he considers his actions as kidnapping, the girl is happy about the situation and proposes to him, with the condition that if they are caught, they will commit suicide.


This is one great piece of a psychological drama manga. Unfortunately I will have to describe the characters in a very vague way since there's so much to spoil. It's basically a different take on Stockholm syndrome (not exactly but yeah). This is a story of how a girl finds protection in the adult who "kidnaps" her. Everything is not offensive and the author clearly takes the characters' different situations throughout the story very seriously in order to create an enticing story with exceptionally moody atmosphere. The actions of the kidnapper runs on crystal-clear yet somehow incomplete motivation iirc and it is in his best interest to protect the girl he kidnapped. There are also new characters in the latter chapters which I can't describe because revealing who they are is a spoiler in itself, just know that they improve the story drastically which keeps it from turning into a boring forced drama.

Everyone reacts organically enough that they won't break your suspension of disbelief yet unpredictable enough such that you must read the next chapter to discover what happens next. It's the Goldilocks zone for psychological manga characters. Great read.

Mieruko-chan
31792.jpg

Description:|
All of a sudden, a girl is able to see grotesque monsters all around her; but no one else can. Rather than trying to run away or face them, she instead musters all of her courage and... ignores them. Join in on her day-to-day life as she keeps up her best poker face despite the supernatural goings-on.


Great horror-comedy. It plays in the strengths of both genres and despite having the same premise being repeated in every chapter, it never gets old.

Character developments are pretty slow here but interactions are pretty spot on. Ordinarily, I wouldn't put this manga into this list due to the aforementioned fact, so why did I? Chapter 9.

You must read until chapter 9 if you decide to start this. That was something incredibly hard to pull of in storywriting yet the mangaka did it so perfectly and perhaps better than most can do.

The comedy's pretty t0op-notch too.

She Doesn't Know Why She Lives
33275.jpg

Description:
Izumi Sumi, a 25 year old part timer struggles through anxiety and depression, pondering the meaning of her own life


Read this for depression :)

No seriously, there's nothing but depression here.

That's pretty much it. Writing a depressed character without making it sound so much like an angsty teen or Eeyore is quite though. This manga does it quite well. Repeat this for a couple volumes and you're set!

Holy crap I spent over an hour on this...
 
Contributor
Joined
Jan 21, 2018
Messages
1,083
The first one that pops in my head is Yomawari Sensei, but that one is non-fiction. (You can read it on the scanlator's site)
It's also a really good manga to boot!

Normally I would dig through my list for more, but I'm kinda chasing deadlines Tehe☆Pero
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Sep 16, 2018
Messages
2,809
@Zoce I think this one is pretty "realistic" I guess...
Konjiki no Word Master

In my opinion the main character is quite sensible which is why I say it's "realistic"
But frankly I share mostly because I like it, and want others to know about it as well so my bad (lol).
Now that I mentioned it again I wanna re-read that again.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top