Sooo... If Ezekiel was/is in love with either version (Athy and Athanasia), what does he like about them? They're both different people, even in both their kindness and having experienced a similar background growing up, they're different. They can't be soulmates since they're literally different souls as well. Does his love differ between the two? Plausible. Was he just bewitched by our princess' beauty? Very plausible. I need me an explanation.