Yukizuriman's One Night Stand - Ch. 16

[MrTurtleMan]

With current medicine, we're able to maintain the bodily processes of people who have suffered brain death. It's said in the chapter that the body they got for this monster was "fresh", which can only mean that it recently died and is being animated by the parasite.


1. That is absolutely not how comas work.

2. The fact that you can distinguish between a coma and brain death, and can imply that not all coma patients are brain dead (putting aside that that's absolutely not how comas work), means that even you know there's a difference between a coma and brain death.

"Is the body alive?"
"Yes, we sent a monster to get a fresh one"
you are legitimately just stupid or you're lying to defend the MC and the plant monster, either way talking to you is fruitless because you won't even read the chapter to see, yes they outright say the person is alive

 

[Eighty-six]

you are legitimately just stupid or you're lying to defend the MC and the plant monster

1. Who even comes close to describing a body as "fresh" unless the person already died? In fact, who talks about a whole person as a "body" in the first place?

2. There is no original personality demonstrated for you to come to the conclusion that there's still the original consciousness there. The person evidently originally died, and the body is currently alive on account of the parasite. That's why they only ever talk about the body, and never the person. Nobody comes close to mentioning the continued consciousness of the original person because it obviously isn't there.

3. You're the one fighting so hard to label this guy as a rapist, despite the very obvious narrative incongruencies with that idea in this chapter alone. He successfully seduces every single monster girl up to this point, refuses to have his way with a monster girl when she's not into it (despite his reputation among the monsters as a monster-rapist, an obviously intended irony) and unwittingly accumulates a harem in the process, but we're somehow supposed to understand that he indicated almost immediately after that he's fine with raping a still living person not in control of her body? Despite not being okay with having sex with an unwilling woman? You think Hamita's just doing a hard three-point veer into rape in an aside conversation, this late in a romcom? Even if you actually thought this, are you not going to acknowledge that's obviously not the intention and chalk it up to a writing fumble?

You want to read Temu Rapeman for no reason, and you wanna make it everyone else's problem. Also, I'm not going to take being called "stupid" by someone who doesn't know the difference between a coma and brain death, nor let someone accuse me of not reading-- or lying-- despite misrepresenting the characters as talking about the "person" despite themselves quoting them talking about the "body".

 

[Shamz]

Dude really turned his IkemenPimp mode on

 

[Redsaint]

I mean really guys this is Hamita writing this manga.
lets just assume the worse possible case for this poor woman.
that not only is she still alive/aware that she married to another man.

 

[Friendly-Sentence710]

"So is that body alive" "Ah yes"
apparently you 2 can't read

She is dead. She has ceased to be! She is an ex-nurse!

I think the answer requires details we won't ever get from Hamita. Is the brain completely dead, like no brain stem activity? Did monsters kill the nurse or was she already dead? Was the body all the way dead and Mistletoe brought them back up from a cold start, or was the body still alive just with no brain activity? If you are dead, can you still own your body?

Readers: "Hamita! Your comic raises some thorny ethical questions! Please provide us with details!"
Hamita: "....I just wanted to lewd up the RE nurses."

Also, who is to say that in life, the nurse wasn't totally into this sort of power exchange? Don't kinkshame.

 

[MrTurtleMan]

1. Who even comes close to describing a body as "fresh" unless the person already died? In fact, who talks about a whole person as a "body" in the first place?

2. There is no original personality demonstrated for you to come to the conclusion that there's still the original consciousness there. The person evidently originally died, and the body is currently alive on account of the parasite. That's why they only ever talk about the body, and never the person. Nobody comes close to mentioning the continued consciousness of the original person because it obviously isn't there.

3. You're the one fighting so hard to label this guy as a rapist, despite the very obvious narrative incongruencies with that idea in this chapter alone. He successfully seduces every single monster girl up to this point, refuses to have his way with a monster girl when she's not into it (despite his reputation among the monsters as a monster-rapist, an obviously intended irony) and unwittingly accumulates a harem in the process, but we're somehow supposed to understand that he indicated almost immediately after that he's fine with raping a still living person not in control of her body? Despite not being okay with having sex with an unwilling woman? You think Hamita's just doing a hard three-point veer into rape in an aside conversation, this late in a romcom? Even if you actually thought this, are you not going to acknowledge that's obviously not the intention and chalk it up to a writing fumble?

You want to read Temu Rapeman for no reason, and you wanna make it everyone else's problem. Also, I'm not going to take being called "stupid" by someone who doesn't know the difference between a coma and brain death, nor let someone accuse me of not reading-- or lying-- despite misrepresenting the characters as talking about the "person" despite themselves quoting them talking about the "body".

She is dead. She has ceased to be! She is an ex-nurse!

I think the answer requires details we won't ever get from Hamita. Is the brain completely dead, like no brain stem activity? Did monsters kill the nurse or was she already dead? Was the body all the way dead and Mistletoe brought them back up from a cold start, or was the body still alive? If you are dead, can you still own your body?

Readers: "Hamita! Your comic raises some thorny ethical questions! Please provide us with details!"
Hamita: "....I just wanted to lewd up the RE nurses."

Also, who is to say that in life, the nurse wasn't totally into this sort of power exchange? Don't kinkshame.

Your justifications for why this is ok are honestly just wild

 

[Friendly-Sentence710]

Your justifications for why this is ok are honestly just wild

He said "Is that body alive" not "still alive" because she looks like a corpse - which is clearly what mistle inhabited. You are the one projecting like a drive in.

 

[Eighty-six]

Your justifications for why this is ok are honestly just wild

Apparently, critical thinking (and knowing the difference between a coma and death) is "mental gymnastics" to people who can't even correctly read what they willingly quote, let alone answer to what's actually being said-- not even to represent it properly in overwrought memes.

This isn't just about the lechery-- you made the accusation that he didn't save someone, as if there was anybody to "save", as if we're not looking at a corpse reanimated by some monster. Your communication involves too little knowledge, too little knowledge absorption, and too much concept conflation.

 

[HoangDinh]

mmm...fresh meat