Yuusha Party o Tsuihou Sareta Beast Tamer, Saikyou Shu Nekomimi Shoujo to Deau - Vol. 1 Ch. 1

[southaccel]

Im sick tired of this dumb trope like bruh where do these one dimensional characters come from

 

[Silwith]

I mean, the trope is dead for decades anyway, but how the fuck does someone don't get that people dont like him? The way they treat him is so bad that they 100% treated him badly before and not like friends... so...

 

[avathar]

Look another doormat!

 

[UncleRad]

I was just looking at the comments below and couldn't help but trying to clarify something here.

There are animals, and then there are monsters. The MC already made that clear when faced with that giant tiger thingy.

I sure hope he won't ended up taming a dragon or a Fennir, or any of those legendary beasts on the second chapter. Maybe on the last few chapter perhaps, so he'll get to vanquish the Demon Lord.

Now lemme go read chapter 2-7. 🙋

 

[nightcore34]

While the Hero party were dicks they were right, he can only scout and carry luggage. That would normally be fine but they said he also gets targeted. Even a scout should be able to handle themselves in a fight but it's clear that this guy can't, that then leads to them having to break formation to save him - which is dangerous. Remember people, on pg.15 it says "up until now my purpose of living was to defeat the Demon Lord," this dude can't even fight a D ranked monster and yet he wants them to take him to the final boss. Of course he's a burden. In fact, he is lucky they didn't take him along as a meat shield against the Demon Lord.

 

[Nk9bjP4A]

Don't insult the pigeons.

 

[akthrowaiz]

I wonder if these authors have any sort of shame when they write these stories

 

[Degernase]

I thought she was about to drop the gamer word.

 

[adhding_nerd]

The premise makes no fucking sense. Why didn't he have a magic beast when he was in the hero's party? Of course they thought he was garbage as a beast tamer without one. How the fuck did he even join in the first place?

 

[Zaedis]

"Scout the surrounding areas and carry our luggage with your animals..." that's incredibly useful though, what is this hero smoking?

 

[Striffee]

@nightcore34 It's not that he couldn't kill it, he just had a really bad weapon, it even says that the beast tamer ability relies on the abilities of the creature he has contract with, which he didn't have one. And who knows, knowing how Hero Parties go in manga, they might not have given him the chance to make a contract with strong monsters/beasts, they might have killed them before he could have tried. Anyways, this is only the first chapter so I dunno if anything has been explained in the further chapters yet.

 

[Suck-a-duck]

I find it interesting that their kicking out their animal tamer, who can survey an area and carry’s their luggage. Hell, he even controls and summons animals, that sounds pretty damn useful. Yet I’m pretty sure that their nun is even more useless, wtf does she do? Pray? Does she kill demons or something? Why kick this useful asset of party member? If he can’t really defend him self as well as the rest, give him a goddamn weapon! At least a short sword and shield would be good.

 

[Hjek098]

Yeah, how exactly did he even get into the party in the first place if he was garbage? Why bother writing it if it doesn't make sense? Legit the whole scene of him being kicked out was utterly useless. Remove that whole premise of him getting kicked out and the whole chapter wouldve been the same.

Also, isnt he an animal tamer? Where's his animal companion? Why is he fighting alone when hes an animal tamer? Make all the forest animal fight for you or something. Disney princesses does a better job than him.

 

[kenkagejack]

Wow, I thought mages were supposed to be smart. Enjoy a party campaign without logistical and psychological (floof) support.

 

[asspussy]

bye bye Scout LOL

 

[Kynnath]

I wish authors understood that "getting kicked out of the party" isn't just a scene for them to "get over with" as quickly as possible, but an interesting opportunity for world-building and getting to know the character. Like, what do we know about the MC? He apparently doesn't know when people are being polite to him but don't actually like him, since he was convinced that they were all good friends. He apparently doesn't have much of a spine, since he thinks it's ok for him to be kicked out of the party without keeping a reasonable portion of the equipment. The hero even says "it's ours", meaning it belongs to the party which he was a part of. So when he is kicked out he should get his share back out as well, since he obviously wasn't getting regular pay but instead the funds of the party were pooled and covered everyone's needs.

I find it pretty pathetic that he reasoned "my purpose in life was to defeat the demon king, but now I can't". I'm sorry, what exactly is stopping him from continuing his journey to defeat the demon king? I mean, the danger the demon king represents is still there, right? If he was motivated by revenge, or to protect his family, or riches, none of those are taken from him just because he got kicked out. This was the thing you worked your whole life for, wasn't it? Can't you form a new party, and continue with what was your life's purpose? No wonder everyone else kicked you out if you have so little motivation that the moment you run into a slight complication, you crumple immediately and give up. I mean, it's not even clear if he did it because he wanted to, or if he joined the hero when they set out (maybe they were childhood friends, something that would have been nice if the author filled in) and never thought of doing something else. If anything, the scene shows this guy absolutely had no business being in that party, he doesn't actually care about defeating the demon king, he was just along for the ride.

And apparently "the hero party" wasn't composed of adventurers? Where they getting paid by the goverment or the temple or something like that? He treats being an adventurer as a life of freedom or whatever, but wasn't that what he was doing already?

In short, like in so many other poorly done scenes, I find myself rooting for the hero rather than the MC. Sure, the hero and the others felt kind of like dicks, but we don't really know what the relationship was really like since the only insight we get is that of an unreliable narrator. "They were nice until they kicked me out" makes them sound bad, but maybe the truth was that they had been dropping hints for months and he was just too dense to notice, so they had to have an intervention and make their intentions clear.

 

[knightdtd]

This is so trashy almost to the point of so bad that it's good. It's like a parody of the genre. So many one dimensional, over-used, nonsensical story elements crammed in only 1 chapter, I'm impressed and appalled at the same time.

 

[SardonicJester]

Such a farce, moreover, a formulaic one.

 

[Saiangeli]

wowza I feel like this is a parody. *Gets kicked out for being weak, proceeds to show him mowing down goblins at a rate faster then they can react*
Author is shit at writing logical scenarios

 

[BagramPl]

@Saiangeli But those were only goblins, he got totally wrecked by a stronger monster so I actually belive he was kinda holding his "friends" back. Of course they didn't have to be such dicks about it but to me it really seemed like, at his current level, he has no place in hero's party.