Yuusha Party wo Oidasareta Kiyoubinbou ~Party Jijou de Fuyojitsushi wo Yatteita Kenshi, Bannou e to Itaru~
- Thread starter MangaDex
- Start date
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Jul 8, 2020
- Messages
- 244
Wtf is going on with that synopsis, that was like reading a stroke.
Group Leader
- Joined
- Feb 12, 2023
- Messages
- 70
We are recruiting Japanese to English and Spanish to English translators, pay $3.00 per chapter. https://discord.gg/362qjeHHzG
Member
- Joined
- May 13, 2023
- Messages
- 29
Thanks alot for picking this up
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Nov 28, 2018
- Messages
- 1,106
Whenever I see Yonezo in the artists list, I know I am going to like it
Member
- Joined
- Aug 7, 2023
- Messages
- 11
Man, isekai are such a guilty pleasure for me. This is just me rambling about the "weak MC kicked from party becomes OP" trope, so feel free to skip this comment. 
Many mangaka and editors IRL and in mangaka-MC stories have commented that the authors' real life experiences are what inform and enrich their writing. In TTRPG, I found this to be true when my college group had the guys who were the most regular about showing up for RPG sessions, but tended to have the least diverse interactions and the highest rate of rules-lawyering, min-max character design, etc. Conversely several of the players who were more casual or irregular due to other activity commitments tended to come up with more out-of-the-box thinking. Everyone had fun and contributed in their own way, of course -- the regulars knew how game/combat mechanics worked and kept things going. And no one was 100% one or the other extreme.
Same thing with people I've encountered whose exposure to a topic (fantasy fiction, let's say) comes almost exclusively from one source or a very narrow range of related sources. Single-system Dungeons and Dragons-only players, or people who have only ever gone to North American renaissance faires. Or for a totally different genre, martial arts students who have only ever learned, trained, and otherwise known one martial art system, community, training culture, or instructor. I had to initially get through this ceiling myself, when I first got into each activity or topic. New entrants tend to think the entire world of possibilities consists only of the world they have seen thus far. It takes a while to comprehend Shakespeare's line in Hamlet: "There are more things in heaven and earth, than are dreamt of in your philosophy, Horatio."
But eventually, going into new topics with that assumption as a starting point, we can more quickly establish context for the tiny bits of beginner info we first learn. And more quickly progress by asking ourselves what are the things we don't yet know?
After reading a bunch of derivative/copycat isekai, I quickly realized the kinds of writer habits or low-hanging fruit that show up again and again. It was easy to infer the kinds of limited life experiences behind each writer's story or character development. Just like renaissance faire culture has become inbred and grown into its own self-sustaining subculture, D&D art style and character design has similarly fed upon older iterations of itself (as new artists grow up using prior D&D-specific art as references for their own new work). And of course, isekai genre manga.
In a way, it's fun to armchair psychoanalyze the work to guess at the creator's background. The reading experience or life experience they may have had to date.
Specifically and more on topic now, it's really apparent that many mangaka cater to a type of narrative that emphasizes the self-made edgelord character who didn't need anyone's help to become strong. Kind of like immature US people who cling to our secular myth of the self-made man who succeeded in life and business, and often think Ayn Rand is amazing.
OTOH, many other mangaka will use this initial character as a base to then roll in another manga trope for low-hanging character growth arcs or retconned empathy in a touching backstory. MC comes to realize, has a convenient flashback, etc about key memories of a loving parent, tough teacher/coach, etc. And they realize "Oh! I was never alone to begin with!" Obvs this is a heavy-handed acknowledgement of Japanese/Asian collectivism. High school slice-of-life coming-of age stories are often all about this theme, and I think they typically tell it way better than the isekai genre does. But a good isekai can also tell it really well too. I just eat that feel-good candy up when it's done well.
Anyway, I'm biased against these artificial setups that initially cast out the poor misunderstood MC. I get that in part it's meant to appeal to an audience that self-projects their own inadequacies, social rejection, and ultimately often their imperfect or total lack of accepting responsibility for their life situation. It's a big part of growing up, I think.
But at this point, I've spent waaay too many years and hours recruiting and integrating new participants into all kinds of work/recreational teams. TTRPG gaming groups of 5-10 people. Extreme fitness classes and workshops of 10-80 students. Martial arts training sessions. A lot more boring industry jobs and projects.
And often I had to learn to work with the people and resources who were available. When the task itself is important enough and you just don't have enough hours in the day to do it yourself, you WILL have to use suboptimal tools, skills, abilities, and characters/people just to get a few more percentage points of completion on the main goal (IRL to share passion for a martial art, or in-game to clear a quest/mission/dungeon). And that lesson started with my own limited abilities, esp when I had very little experience as a beginner in a particular activity or field. I never had the luxury of a recruiter's market, with a surplus of candidates to hire or recruit. Must be nice to be spoiled for choice of talent, I imagine.
So it bugs the heck out of me to see supposedly successful (dare i say professional?) adventurer teams arbitrarily decide to throw out a suboptimal team member. Delegate lower-risk responsibilities to a guy, closer to within their ability to perform. that's still valuable manpower in a pretty high-turnover line of work. And yes, I realize it's a cheap way for the author to easily set up the arrogant former party for failure, as well as generate a cookie-cutter love-to-hate starter pack of villains.
Obviously, I could take issue with a lot of other weird, inbred isekai/JPRG style tropes, like having teams be constrained to X number of members, explicitly recruiting rigid game-style teams with "the tank", "the DPS guy", "the support mage", etc. But I know that's what the audience is familiar with -- all the more so with a lot of Korean isekai manhwa. At least a strong minority of manga strive to vary up and flip the script on these tropes b/c manga has been flogging the isekai horse for so long that bored writers eventually want to change things up (and look for an untapped niche in a very bloated genre).
Anyway, just gonna drop this into the empty void of the Internet. Happy reading (isekai, that is), everyone!
Many mangaka and editors IRL and in mangaka-MC stories have commented that the authors' real life experiences are what inform and enrich their writing. In TTRPG, I found this to be true when my college group had the guys who were the most regular about showing up for RPG sessions, but tended to have the least diverse interactions and the highest rate of rules-lawyering, min-max character design, etc. Conversely several of the players who were more casual or irregular due to other activity commitments tended to come up with more out-of-the-box thinking. Everyone had fun and contributed in their own way, of course -- the regulars knew how game/combat mechanics worked and kept things going. And no one was 100% one or the other extreme.
Same thing with people I've encountered whose exposure to a topic (fantasy fiction, let's say) comes almost exclusively from one source or a very narrow range of related sources. Single-system Dungeons and Dragons-only players, or people who have only ever gone to North American renaissance faires. Or for a totally different genre, martial arts students who have only ever learned, trained, and otherwise known one martial art system, community, training culture, or instructor. I had to initially get through this ceiling myself, when I first got into each activity or topic. New entrants tend to think the entire world of possibilities consists only of the world they have seen thus far. It takes a while to comprehend Shakespeare's line in Hamlet: "There are more things in heaven and earth, than are dreamt of in your philosophy, Horatio."
But eventually, going into new topics with that assumption as a starting point, we can more quickly establish context for the tiny bits of beginner info we first learn. And more quickly progress by asking ourselves what are the things we don't yet know?
After reading a bunch of derivative/copycat isekai, I quickly realized the kinds of writer habits or low-hanging fruit that show up again and again. It was easy to infer the kinds of limited life experiences behind each writer's story or character development. Just like renaissance faire culture has become inbred and grown into its own self-sustaining subculture, D&D art style and character design has similarly fed upon older iterations of itself (as new artists grow up using prior D&D-specific art as references for their own new work). And of course, isekai genre manga.
In a way, it's fun to armchair psychoanalyze the work to guess at the creator's background. The reading experience or life experience they may have had to date.
Specifically and more on topic now, it's really apparent that many mangaka cater to a type of narrative that emphasizes the self-made edgelord character who didn't need anyone's help to become strong. Kind of like immature US people who cling to our secular myth of the self-made man who succeeded in life and business, and often think Ayn Rand is amazing.
OTOH, many other mangaka will use this initial character as a base to then roll in another manga trope for low-hanging character growth arcs or retconned empathy in a touching backstory. MC comes to realize, has a convenient flashback, etc about key memories of a loving parent, tough teacher/coach, etc. And they realize "Oh! I was never alone to begin with!" Obvs this is a heavy-handed acknowledgement of Japanese/Asian collectivism. High school slice-of-life coming-of age stories are often all about this theme, and I think they typically tell it way better than the isekai genre does. But a good isekai can also tell it really well too. I just eat that feel-good candy up when it's done well.
Anyway, I'm biased against these artificial setups that initially cast out the poor misunderstood MC. I get that in part it's meant to appeal to an audience that self-projects their own inadequacies, social rejection, and ultimately often their imperfect or total lack of accepting responsibility for their life situation. It's a big part of growing up, I think.
But at this point, I've spent waaay too many years and hours recruiting and integrating new participants into all kinds of work/recreational teams. TTRPG gaming groups of 5-10 people. Extreme fitness classes and workshops of 10-80 students. Martial arts training sessions. A lot more boring industry jobs and projects.
And often I had to learn to work with the people and resources who were available. When the task itself is important enough and you just don't have enough hours in the day to do it yourself, you WILL have to use suboptimal tools, skills, abilities, and characters/people just to get a few more percentage points of completion on the main goal (IRL to share passion for a martial art, or in-game to clear a quest/mission/dungeon). And that lesson started with my own limited abilities, esp when I had very little experience as a beginner in a particular activity or field. I never had the luxury of a recruiter's market, with a surplus of candidates to hire or recruit. Must be nice to be spoiled for choice of talent, I imagine.
So it bugs the heck out of me to see supposedly successful (dare i say professional?) adventurer teams arbitrarily decide to throw out a suboptimal team member. Delegate lower-risk responsibilities to a guy, closer to within their ability to perform. that's still valuable manpower in a pretty high-turnover line of work. And yes, I realize it's a cheap way for the author to easily set up the arrogant former party for failure, as well as generate a cookie-cutter love-to-hate starter pack of villains.
Obviously, I could take issue with a lot of other weird, inbred isekai/JPRG style tropes, like having teams be constrained to X number of members, explicitly recruiting rigid game-style teams with "the tank", "the DPS guy", "the support mage", etc. But I know that's what the audience is familiar with -- all the more so with a lot of Korean isekai manhwa. At least a strong minority of manga strive to vary up and flip the script on these tropes b/c manga has been flogging the isekai horse for so long that bored writers eventually want to change things up (and look for an untapped niche in a very bloated genre).
Anyway, just gonna drop this into the empty void of the Internet. Happy reading (isekai, that is), everyone!
Active member
- Joined
- Jan 20, 2021
- Messages
- 23
Tired of too much reading and lack of characters charm & uniqueness
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Jun 8, 2018
- Messages
- 271
Have you got a link to your site for continued reading? The chapter says you're up to chapter 16?
- Joined
- Apr 11, 2023
- Messages
- 28
I can't find this manga on dark scan can send me the link or tell me what name go for it on the website
Active member
- Joined
- Jul 24, 2023
- Messages
- 116
The translation from dark scans is trash
enjoy the bitcoin miner the moment you step on their website
Double-page supporter
- Joined
- Sep 17, 2023
- Messages
- 97
I'm enjoying this series strictly on the basis of it being a guilty pleasure and the hope that the authors will find some way to surprise me. I didn't really see anything that could be considered all that original, other than the exact way the components are being combined. There was a surprisingly early hope spot where the old party should recognize their own limitations but sadly that didn't seem to go anywhere so we're still on track for more extreme humbling in their future.
I don't really want to get into complaining about every little thing when this story just retreads the same issue every other 'kicked from the hero's party' story does. Why do they even need a hero's party anyway? Seeing more of these stories where a hero party is apparently just an S-Rank party with good publicity. That said I might touch on a couple of issues I have.
First, the usual issue of replacing the support member without understanding their value. Nothing new there except what was the metric they were even using for deciding the new support person was better? I assume there was some sort of base magic power because there wasn't really anything else that makes sense (the MC gives better buffs at more timely intervals, and obviously has better shot calling due to tenure with the party). It's a little insulting to the audience in stories like this when they make the old party ignorant to this degree. This one has less excuse than most because they specifically call out how MC is having to constantly cast short-duration buffs rather than how others just have them applying more permanent buffs where it makes more sense the party would lose track of their current state. From there it's the usual "oh I didn't know I actually was personally not all that strong" and "oh that guy's job is probably easy" which are staples of this genre. No bonus points for him also apparently being the only one running their finances and probably other logistics.
Second (and I'll probably stop here) - the healer makes it clear she knows what's going on and yet we seem to be going days without conversations between her and the rest of the party. And somehow she still agrees to do a 'suicidal' run with them despite getting a complete runaround and told to just accept that they chose to veto any concerns she has (as the HEALER no less). Like, I get this is standard fare for the genre but I'll still call it out if she's meant to be the reasonable one she should have at least had the option to halt party activities or something, if nothing else but to not get herself killed.
I don't really want to get into complaining about every little thing when this story just retreads the same issue every other 'kicked from the hero's party' story does. Why do they even need a hero's party anyway? Seeing more of these stories where a hero party is apparently just an S-Rank party with good publicity. That said I might touch on a couple of issues I have.
First, the usual issue of replacing the support member without understanding their value. Nothing new there except what was the metric they were even using for deciding the new support person was better? I assume there was some sort of base magic power because there wasn't really anything else that makes sense (the MC gives better buffs at more timely intervals, and obviously has better shot calling due to tenure with the party). It's a little insulting to the audience in stories like this when they make the old party ignorant to this degree. This one has less excuse than most because they specifically call out how MC is having to constantly cast short-duration buffs rather than how others just have them applying more permanent buffs where it makes more sense the party would lose track of their current state. From there it's the usual "oh I didn't know I actually was personally not all that strong" and "oh that guy's job is probably easy" which are staples of this genre. No bonus points for him also apparently being the only one running their finances and probably other logistics.
Second (and I'll probably stop here) - the healer makes it clear she knows what's going on and yet we seem to be going days without conversations between her and the rest of the party. And somehow she still agrees to do a 'suicidal' run with them despite getting a complete runaround and told to just accept that they chose to veto any concerns she has (as the HEALER no less). Like, I get this is standard fare for the genre but I'll still call it out if she's meant to be the reasonable one she should have at least had the option to halt party activities or something, if nothing else but to not get herself killed.
agreed
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Aug 1, 2023
- Messages
- 535
I really like this manga at first, it felt more grounded, the art is amazing, etc. But then blackdragon fight happened and it's suddenly became one of those nonsensical OP MC manga.
Disappointing.
Disappointing.
I don't want to be disrespectful but the dark scan translation is absolutely horrendous. It was an OK manga and the previous translation was pretty nice.
This is to the point I wonder why this kind of translation is even allowed here? It's just cheap bait and a cash grab. Not only is it terrible but you'd have to use their website to read the next chapters.
This is to the point I wonder why this kind of translation is even allowed here? It's just cheap bait and a cash grab. Not only is it terrible but you'd have to use their website to read the next chapters.
Love it when the scan quality goes from great and clean to 4 part chapter splits, low res garbage with a double post of some goofy looking icon. Even worse is that the low quality is done on purpose to funnel people over to their ad covered website.
Similar threads
