Hope You're Happy, Lemon - Ch. 59

[MangaDex]

 

[Alanon]

I didnt expect his reaction to be this calm

 

[AccForManga]

I guess his dream of the breakup in the first chapter was just a more nightmare-version of what really happened instead of the exact memory.

 

[Ninoren]

I guess his dream of the breakup in the first chapter was just a more nightmare-version of what really happened instead of the exact memory.

She looked a bit older, when we've seen it the first time, so probably happened after he confronted her again 😶

Also feels bad, here he is trusting her and reacting calmly just thinking to himself she wouldn't do that and that's probably why she wanted him to stay away from her class for those malicious rumours (what he thought up to this point) and she just goes and turns the rumours into reality for him, for no reason whatsoever, instead of just also calmly talkin with him, then she just proceeds to ghost him 😐

Looking at that she really doesn't deserve a second chance in my eyes, wouldn't know how you could possibly trust her again

 

[ghostkun]

Oh, looks like he has a Switch OLED.

 

[Zreth]

So going by the past two chapters making a preemptive guess she was getting bullied in middle school.

 

[AccForManga]

She looked a bit older, when we've seen it the first time, so probably happened after he confronted her again 😶

Doesnt seem like it based on what was being said. She said the exact same line which would be odd.

"Whats going on? "

"I cheated on you...with four guys!"

Would be odd that he confronts her again with

"Whats going on?"

"I cheated on you...with four guys!"

Seems too repetitive.

I'd chalk the looks as just art evolution, plus nothing implies he confronted her twice, this chapter makes it clear that was the end and he never talked to her again.

 

[drakenation]

Also feels bad, here he is trusting her and reacting calmly just thinking to himself she wouldn't do that and that's probably why she wanted him to stay away from her class for those malicious rumours (what he thought up to this point) and she just goes and turns the rumours into reality for him, for no reason whatsoever, instead of just also calmly talkin with him, then she just proceeds to ghost him 😐

Looking at that she really doesn't deserve a second chance in my eyes, wouldn't know how you could possibly trust her again

This is the reasonable person's take.

But mangadex people are anything but reasonable. There's a manga, Harapeko Oyako to Motokare Yanushi, about a single mother who returns to her ex-boyfriend she ghosted for over 14 years just to mooch off him, and people are like "Oh, that's so cute!". Absolutely fucked up.

 

[Nobi]

So short. We were this close to the final retcon.

 

[Dark1400]

This is the reasonable person's take.

But mangadex people are anything but reasonable. There's a manga, Harapeko Oyako to Motokare Yanushi, about a single mother who returns to her ex-boyfriend she ghosted for over 14 years just to mooch off him, and people are like "Oh, that's so cute!". Absolutely fucked up.

She didn't ghost him, they broke up and didn't had contact after that, not everyone keeps contact with someone after a break up, and we don't have any info on why they broke up, or why they didn't have any contact in 17 years

 

[3turtlesinacoat]

She looked a bit older, when we've seen it the first time, so probably happened after he confronted her again 😶

Also feels bad, here he is trusting her and reacting calmly just thinking to himself she wouldn't do that and that's probably why she wanted him to stay away from her class for those malicious rumours (what he thought up to this point) and she just goes and turns the rumours into reality for him, for no reason whatsoever, instead of just also calmly talkin with him, then she just proceeds to ghost him 😐

Looking at that she really doesn't deserve a second chance in my eyes, wouldn't know how you could possibly trust her again

My thoughts exactly. People are saying its bullying or smth but at this point these guys have to have like life-ruining blackmail material on both of them for her to go this far instead of to any authority figure or, like you said, her boyfriend .
Alternatively, lemon is really that self sacrificial and doesnt know how being cheated on impacts other people. But doing that and then expecting to just come back into someones life without any changes is crazy.

 

[MaxNotHere]

I don't get it. If he was so calm and knew none of it was true from the start then what traumatized him?

 

[Dark1400]

I don't get it. If he was so calm and knew none of it was true from the start then what traumatized him?

Either retcon or sometime after this he starts to believe it is true and the flashback on chapter 1 was a memory modified by his bias

 

[Throwawail]

I don't get it. If he was so calm and knew none of it was true from the start then what traumatized him?

Either retcon or sometime after this he starts to believe it is true and the flashback on chapter 1 was a memory modified by his bias

it's probably just a retcon

 

[Dark1400]

it's probably just a retcon

Odds are you're right, but I hope something else happened to make MC believe the lie, otherwise the MC being traumatized(it was relevant like 3 chapters ago) become a continuity error

 

[ShadowStriker89]

She looked a bit older, when we've seen it the first time, so probably happened after he confronted her again 😶

Also feels bad, here he is trusting her and reacting calmly just thinking to himself she wouldn't do that and that's probably why she wanted him to stay away from her class for those malicious rumours (what he thought up to this point) and she just goes and turns the rumours into reality for him, for no reason whatsoever, instead of just also calmly talkin with him, then she just proceeds to ghost him 😐

Looking at that she really doesn't deserve a second chance in my eyes, wouldn't know how you could possibly trust her again

Hence the title, best wishes b*tch

 

[triplegks]

From ch 1.
It’s kinda weird how calm and accepting he is in this chapter, it just doesn’t make sense.
Like I said many chapters ago, a topic this heavy should’ve come up the first time they met again, not now, 60 chapters in. And somehow they’re just acting like nothing happened and continuing to do things together. It’s just... feels so unnatural.
And now, of course, the author wants to make the readers sympathize with Lemon.

 

[1orangebraincell]

I don't know how I feel about this. At one end it's believable that he is afraid of his classmates teasing him. At age 14-15 most of us would have been afraid of our rep dropping in the class. And on the other end complete douche bag move. Not even talking to her? I'm siding towards lemon more this time.

 

[Kaduufrrj]

It even seems that the traumatized character is from one dimension and the current character is from another.

 

[Ninoren]

I don't get it. If he was so calm and knew none of it was true from the start then what traumatized him?

He thought to himself it wasn't true and she wouldn't do that, but what is he supposed to think, if she keeps dodging him and starts acting strange to then just break up and drop the bomb on him herself with the cheating, without explanation whatsoever, after that she never reached out again, isn't all that unreasonable to start and develop doubts overtime