Isekai Craft Gurashi ~Jiyuu Kimama na Seisan Shoku no Honobono Slow Life~ - Ch. 36

Dex-chan lover
Joined
Apr 6, 2018
Messages
6,416
Forgot to mention one thing: the whole market A and B extensively interacting would be a thing yet to develop, if that world is at all like ours was. Medieval towns had minimal trade between them, partly due to the challenges of logistics and more importantly to the fact that craftsman's guilds had a monopoly on a given region's markets. Products from another place would not be allowed to be sold (and indeed it turned bloody if anyone persitently tried) and settlements tended to be mostly self sufficient. Grain and other foodstufs were the exception (peasants did not have guilds), as well as luxury products for the nobility (though they were sourced individually). So yeah, the capital and their own town would likely not have competed yet. It might become a thing once this kind of transportaion become common, but you can bet the guilds would fight it to the death.
Oooh, more political than economic conflict then.

I guess in that sense, it makes sense for the crafting guildmaster to oppose this. It's less an economic threat and more a challenge to his power. The merchant guildmaster seems happy to help it along though, so maybe in terms of trade, she's already got some connections to the capital.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 2, 2019
Messages
5,477
I...what?
Maybe I missed that lesson in economics class, but my impression is that while some specific industries might suffer from a merging of two economies, a larger economy as a whole in general is healthier and more productive.

Even if producers in market A are objectively worse than Market B at making all products, they would have far less opportunity cost for that same reason and everyone gets more if Market B focuses on trading their most profitable products with Market A in exchange for whatever they diverted resources away from to do so.

If I were the guildmaster, I'd be drooling at the prospect of this train and scrambling for special trading privileges rather than any sort of interference.

I was originally going to assume that the train would need 240 enchanters to move based on the 1/8th model, but I forgot about the Square-Cube law. Does x600 mean we need to hire 600 Karons or 30x600?
Regardless, this is also a good thing for Crafters because it means they get to be employed en masse. If Miyabi can figure out a way for further power engines to be easily added, they could even be bulk-hired for emergencies when the train needs extra horsepower.
I just assumed the issue is that that guy is from economy C, not connected to the railroad, and used to be a hub that one was forced to travel through between A and B before the railroad was made.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 19, 2023
Messages
8,262
"Unable to wield sword or magic..."
Can always train to wield a sword, and he can use magic, just a different kind.

"Where'd he get the cat from?"
Probably had it in a small box or bag.

Makes me think of how cats like to ride roombas.

"It's a pain in my ass is what it is!"
So you're saying it's a skill issue?

"If the project succeeds, it'll cause the economy to implode."
If it succeeds despite all attempts to sink it.
 
Last edited:
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Feb 23, 2024
Messages
639
Oooh, more political than economic conflict then.

I guess in that sense, it makes sense for the crafting guildmaster to oppose this. It's less an economic threat and more a challenge to his power. The merchant guildmaster seems happy to help it along though, so maybe in terms of trade, she's already got some connections to the capital.
Hard to tell if he's thinking that much forward. For now they've been talking about transporting people, so the members of his guild would probably have no reason to oppose it (especially if it brings some demand for their work). You're correct it would be detrimental to him in the long run, since guilds began disbanding around the time the industrial revolution was kicking off and this kind of project is something that accelerates industrialization. As for the merchants - the ones based in cities would only benefit, since procuring goods would get cheaper and safer with time. The traveling ones would start losing ground, but the guild would likely throw them under the bus - there were relatively few of them, since it was an exceptionally tough lifestyle and nowhere near as lucrative as doing business from an established shop.
 
Joined
May 21, 2025
Messages
2
Thank you for the chapter and my condolences for your loss. It's never easy to part with family, no matter how close or distant you were. Hopefully they went in peace and calm.

I also bloody hope nobody's complaining about the pace. Your quality more than makes it worth it to be patient.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 19, 2018
Messages
266
It could cripple the economy temporarily if all the carriage drivers, horse breeders, and carriage manufacturers / maintenance crews go out of business. It will take time for people to both adapt to and learn how to handle the new transportation repairs and maintenance.

Plus you cannot just have people with no magic ability opperate it like you can with carriages. It effectively shuts out a decent chunk of the population from being able to easily change from being "carriage drivers" to "train driver".

Add to it that prices for shipping would drop dramatically, and escort services would no longer be necessary either, and there would be a significant immediate economic impact.

But all of that is just immediate impact. Knowing the long term impact could either have it make the economy boom, or end up crippling it too hard before it can have a chance to take off again.

It's a single destination transportation method. The actual transportation/economy fallout is extremely low. 30,000 Karons to run, means the actual cost is, terribly high. And as such is only suitable for transport of high value time sensitive items. The primary fallout is going to be any "Post Towns" that are on the way. They're going to suffer from the drop off of shipments that rely on them to provide logistics and some adventurer escorts. But again, this isn't going to be a mainstream travel method. And, as already stated Angellium doesn't have a ton of specialized resources that need that transport in the first place. All the current plans don't mention any other exits/entrances. Only non-stop Express train service. So, everyone else, is still going to be on horses and carriages to transport things to and from places that aren't specifically Angellium or the Capitol.

And in terms of military potential, it's almost 0. Miyabi, is the entirety of the military problem. Mole-san, is the only person who can make tunnels quick enough to be an invasion issue. Everyone else, is going to take years if not decades, to make a route. And in terms of troop transport, other than an initial push, the underground entrance is really easy to target and stop, once it's discovered to be a problem.

And as a reminder, Miyabi already mentioned his inability to create a Steam Engine, an item that does not exist in game, that he doesn't actually fully understand to make himself. Chapter 31, page 17. He's an architecture buff, not a mechanical engineer. Given enough time, he might be able to remake it from first principles, but that's easily years of research and work, not the limited time scale he was given here.

I don't know about Giorgi's social standing, he could be a lower noble, but he's still subordinate to the Duke. So he has limited maneuvering potential to go against the Duke without external political support. His primary friction point is going to be his ostensible control of the Production Guild. But, that's under the Duke. If he's going to suffer because of decreased control/output, the Duke is the ultimate decision on that anyway. He's obviously going to lose power to Weiss, but he doesn't have a lot of recourse when he doesn't even employ any of the workers that could fit the job/role.
 
Last edited:
Double-page supporter
Joined
Dec 19, 2023
Messages
98
Thanks for the great TL, don't let them pressure you. Sorry for your loss and happy early birthday 🥳 love this story
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Apr 6, 2018
Messages
6,416
It's a single destination transportation method. The actual transportation/economy fallout is extremely low. 30,000 Karons to run, means the actual cost is, terribly high. And as such is only suitable for transport of high value time sensitive items. The primary fallout is going to be any "Post Towns" that are on the way. They're going to suffer from the drop off of shipments that rely on them to provide logistics and some adventurer escorts. But again, this isn't going to be a mainstream travel method. And, as already stated Angellium doesn't have a ton of specialized resources that need that transport in the first place. All the current plans don't mention any other exits/entrances. Only non-stop Express train service. So, everyone else, is still going to be on horses and carriages to transport things to and from places that aren't specifically Angellium or the Capitol.
I was actually assuming that there would be pit stops at the various towns on the way to the capital, but I guess...that wasn't actually said.

As a side, I love how we've collectively started taken to using Karon's (false) name as essentially a fantasy version of horsepower.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jul 2, 2018
Messages
100
why can't he just hook what ever is spinning the fans to make the air up to a belt and wheel or if it is magic air why not send it into a makeshift turbine and then have that spin the wheels is this guys an idiot i mean he's picked the most wasteful form of propulsion lol
Simply said: he is an architect (designs cool buildings) not a mechanical enginner (makes tools go brrrr). His own nickname from before isekai was "cupid of love"... doesn't really sound like someone that builds trains
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jun 22, 2019
Messages
709
oh yay, a new update!! thank you for translating this despite the hectic schedule (and happy early birthday!)

i must say, i'm very glad for these pretty boys and men. their hair is so damn luxurious i can practically hear the ~sha-la-la~ sparkling sfx whenever they pop up. i'm obsessed with how the artist draws the duke's and prince's hair 😆
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 18, 2018
Messages
2,033
I really love this series BC it is pretty clear Mr duke is trying to be a good dad to Cress, knowing that the poor kid has had been put in an AWFUL position from the skill he was born with.

I really hope this is the start of all the crafters and Cress having a better lot in life, especially so people can stop treating them like garbage. It makes my heart hurt to imagine how much pressure and pain all of them have experienced.

Thank you so much for this translation! And I'm really sorry for your loss, but I hope your bday goes well.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jun 7, 2018
Messages
416
You guys are debating macro and socioeconomics in a manga where the author thought of inventing locomotion vehicle based purely on WIND power. Not for kinetic force on drive mechanism but as THRUST. Where MAGIC exists.

And its boring ass regular wind to boot. At least make it combustion with turbo compressor or something.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Mar 31, 2018
Messages
1,283
You guys are debating macro and socioeconomics in a manga where the author thought of inventing locomotion vehicle based purely on WIND power. Not for kinetic force on drive mechanism but as THRUST. Where MAGIC exists.

And its boring ass regular wind to boot. At least make it combustion with turbo compressor or something.
To be fair, while it is simple in design, thrust is pretty straightforward answer in this situation where what you are moving is stuck on rails. And he isn't an engineer, so he probably couldn't make anything significantly complex like an engine or anything using combustion. And as a bonus positive, using wind will help circulate the air in the tunnel.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jun 21, 2018
Messages
1,303
To be fair, while it is simple in design, thrust is pretty straightforward answer in this situation where what you are moving is stuck on rails. And he isn't an engineer, so he probably couldn't make anything significantly complex like an engine or anything using combustion. And as a bonus positive, using wind will help circulate the air in the tunnel.
Yeah, there's also the fact that putting what is, in essence, a jet engine in a tunnel basically turns the tunnel into a gun barrel. Guns work by burning propellant to massively increase gas pressure behind a bullet, which easily overcomes the atmospheric pressure on the other side. So this would be similar, except instead of burning propellant, you're actually shifting the mass of air from one side to the other.

Also, just so everyone knows, this isn't something the mangaka is pulling out of their ass. This is a thing that actually exists.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atmospheric_railway
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top