Why did Sakura’s “cheating” provoke anger and disappointment among the overwhelming majority of story-focused readers?
Because everyone had invested long-term trust in this character and staked the greatest amount of dignity on her. Then, overnight, she handed all of it over to a scumbag who had only confessed his feelings to her a day earlier, leaving the dignity of the readers who had always supported her trampled into the dirt.
Why did Sakura only cut ties with Shinobu-kun by text message? Isn’t that too hasty?
Because the two pieces of “betrayal” evidence Sakura faced within a single day were presented in the forms of “hearing” and “sight.” Overhearing that she was about to be dropped by her manager, Shinobu-kun (being abandoned in her career), was an “auditory” stimulus; witnessing the kiss, the decisive piece of evidence (being abandoned in love), was a “visual” stimulus. So Sakura, in her collapsed state, could not agree to meet Shinobu-kun in person (visual) or talk by phone (auditory), because that would make her instantly recall the decisive moments when she was abandoned. That is why “writing a text” was the only method she could barely endure. Moreover, the timing of the breakup text is suspicious. The instant Shinobu-kun sees the message, the scene cuts to Sakura, who has just finished packing her suitcase, showing that she had been busy before then. That period was not a good time to send a formal breakup message, so it is even questionable whether it was ghostwritten. In fact, there are many similar continuity errors in the visual details. For example, when Shinobu-kun receives Nakanishi-kun’s text asking to meet, the phone’s standby screen shows the time as 4:00 p.m., but the message’s sent time is 8:00 p.m.
For viewers with an “omniscient perspective,” Shinobu-kun’s past behavior is only a string of misunderstandings. But for Sakura, who has only a limited perspective, it is a devastating stimulus. If that “kiss” during the acting coaching had appeared out of nowhere in an ordinary situation, Sakura would not have completely broken down; she would have tried to figure out what had happened. But if many chains of evidence had already been supporting it beforehand, then the final kiss could have a decisive effect.
Why would she break down so easily, to the point of just giving herself away?
Actually, it was not easy. The current Sakura’s mental armor is already much stronger than it was in Chapter 1 (built-in Sakura armor plus external Shinobu-kun armor). But the author deliberately arranged for a series of armor-piercing shots that should have had extremely low odds of hitting to shatter the external armor one by one, and also removed all the guardrails (for example, Shinobu-kun not only cannot catch up physically, even his voice cannot catch up; the story simply does not allow him to explain the truth in advance; and there is also the timing of the train’s departure). This leaves Sakura on the train home in a state of having no mental armor at all (the external armor has detached, and the internal armor has been shattered), like a walking flesh-and-blood doll. It is as if every time her rationality comes back online, her short-term memory once again throws that decisive image in front of her eyes, and then her rationality goes offline again. Nakanishi exploits exactly that gap to take advantage of her vulnerability—while she is mentally collapsing, he takes whatever he wants without restraint, and in doing so also exposes his scumbag nature.
So that whole process of “cheating” is not the kind of thing it may look like: Sakura actively hinting that they should go to Nakanishi-kun’s apartment, and then half-resisting, half-going along as she lets her carnal desires be fully satisfied for one night. Rather, it is a process in which her mental armor keeps refreshing, collapsing, refreshing, and collapsing again. Her body is completely outside the control of her self-awareness; she can only let the other person take from her, and then produce purely physiological reflexes. At its core, it is a tragic night.
Sakura’s immediate feeling at the time is that she is a completely useless thing that has been abandoned. Shinobu-kun, who once protected her, was her only emotional pillar, and now she has confirmed that he is no longer there. Relying solely on her own mental strength, she is utterly unable to withstand the fear of such total loss, so she enters a vicious cycle of repeated breakdowns. This is why this section has also been criticized by NTR viewers: the NTR appeal is weak, the two sides have almost no communication, and there is no depiction of inner thoughts. Because among these two people, one is mentally shattered and dissociated—unable to think; the other would not get any response even if he spoke—so there is no need to speak. Compared with cheating, it is more like the rape of someone who is drunk and incapacitated, a process that severely lacks interaction. NTR appeal requires an atmosphere of confusion, curiosity, shame, and anger, not a dead-fish feeling of blankness, collapse, and giving up.
Why does Sakura refuse to communicate, not answer or reply to any of Shinobu-kun’s calls or messages, yet only ask Nakanishi-kun for help?
Because she is extremely mentally fragile at that moment and believes she has been completely abandoned by Shinobu-kun (both in career and in love). As soon as she sees Shinobu-kun’s name or hears his voice, that decisive image will surface (together with the fragments of all that evidence), and then she will mentally collapse again. She simply does not dare face Shinobu-kun, fearing that she will hear him personally and apologetically deliver the formal verdict. All she can do is keep running away (and the author does not allow Shinobu-kun or Fumi to explain by text). Her only relatively harmless lifeline at the time instead becomes Nakanishi-kun, who is coveting her. This is also the intended effect of the emotional manipulation methods used by Nakanishi’s group: to make the person being controlled able to rely only on him.
Why did Nakanishi-kun not remember for so many days to tell Sakura about the “hug” incident he had seen?
At first, he intended to bring it up as an ordinary topic (because he initially thought Shinobu-kun was only Sakura’s manager). Later, once he guessed the relationship between the two of them, even if he remembered the topic, telling Sakura at the wrong time would be useless, because if Shinobu-kun was at home that night, Sakura could directly go verify it and clear up the misunderstanding. Nakanishi-kun would save this accelerant for use at a critical moment: for example, later on, when Sakura has already become suspicious and begun to waver, while Shinobu-kun is away from home on a business trip that day.
Why can Nakanishi-kun be waiting so precisely at the station when Sakura exits? She did not reveal her timetable or say whether she had already gotten home, but Nakanishi-kun seems to know already and is waiting there.
If this is not a flaw in the script’s design, then it is a deliberately planted hint: the protective amulet Sakura carries with her may very likely contain a built-in tracker, allowing Nakanishi-kun to know roughly where she is at the time. This may become a key element for a reversal later on.
Even without a tracker, if Nakanishi-kun asked Sakura for her current location when she sought help, he could still arrive at the station in time. Why go to the trouble of preparing this prop?
Because if Sakura breaks down so badly that she does not want to speak the entire way, talks to no one, and only asks for help after getting home, then Nakanishi-kun loses this golden window in which he can completely break through her armor. With a tracker, however, even if Sakura does not contact him proactively, Nakanishi-kun can arrive at the station ahead of time based on the tracker, then proactively send a message asking about the situation. The final effect is the same: while Sakura is mentally collapsed, he intercepts her and brings her to his own home.
What would Nakanishi-kun do if Sakura did not discover any more clues on this trip, or even cleared up the misunderstanding?
Then he would watch and wait, continue picking at Shinobu-kun’s faults from multiple angles, undermine Sakura’s confidence in Shinobu-kun, and at the same time show Sakura even more goodwill so that she develops emotional dependence. An opportunity would eventually appear.
Why does Nakanishi-kun proactively ask Sakura in the taxi whether she wants to go home? If Sakura agrees to go home, wouldn’t all his effort be wasted?
He needs to test the strength of Sakura’s mental armor. If she says nothing, that means she has already collapsed and the timing is right. If Sakura still chooses to go home, that means her current mental strength has not completely collapsed, and he still needs to say some leading, manipulative lines to keep triggering her until she breaks down. The result is the same either way: he wants to take the broken-down version of Sakura back to Nakanishi-kun’s own residence. If Nakanishi-kun were truly acting for Sakura’s good, then even if she did not respond, he should by default escort her back to Sakura’s own home. But that would mean Shinobu-kun would soon catch up and ease or even eliminate Sakura’s mental pressure, so the only option is to take Sakura, whose will is weak at that moment, back to his own home.
After returning to Nakanishi-kun’s residence, logically speaking, he would only run into Shinobu-kun downstairs—who came on the next train—if he stayed in the room for more than one hour. And if the two of them simply sat there doing nothing for that hour, that would be very abnormal. Is this a plot hole?
It should be a script flaw. These few scenes are meant to increase the sense of loss in the NTR genre, the feeling of “just barely missing each other.” They also use visual misdirection to make everyone feel that the two of them pass right by each other, but in fact there is some distance between them. A split view shows that distance, about five meters, so neither of them probably sees the other. But normally speaking, the two of them would not meet. Shinobu-kun has to wait an extra hour before he can take the next train, and for Nakanishi-kun, it is impossible that he would leave a one-hour golden window unused. But if he got home and immediately went downstairs to buy water, then staged the confession scene, Shinobu-kun would definitely still be on the train chatting with Fumi at that time, so it would not give readers a strong sense of loss, nor could it create the cruel contrast of “frantically searching downstairs while things are heating up upstairs.”