Kimi ga Hoeru Tame no Uta wo, - Vol. 5 Ch. 23 - Parent and Child

Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 22, 2025
Messages
644
image.png

typo on page 19
 
Supporter
Joined
Jul 11, 2025
Messages
54
Most everyone here knew Ruriko’s excuse for abandoning her daughter was unlikely to justify itself.

But hitting us with the low-hanging fruit of “she has cancer” for why she did it?

Yeah, no.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Feb 14, 2018
Messages
132
The whole "i separated my kids so the less talented one can be a better singer" is so dumb. You're her mom, if you see your kid being discouraged, do something about it. Talk to her. Dont separate her for a decade from her sister. Also iirc she left her husband during this whole fiasco. That poor dude. What the ever living fuck was she thinking?
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 3, 2025
Messages
254
The explanation for why she Parent Trapped Yuu is a little half-baked, but I'm glad they put up some resistance to it at least.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 30, 2024
Messages
93
Most everyone here knew Ruriko’s excuse for abandoning her daughter was unlikely to justify itself.

But hitting us with the low-hanging fruit of “she has cancer” for why she did it?

Yeah, no.
What got me the most was the old "had to get special treatment overseas" cliche. For 10 years. Obviously noted technologically backwards nation of Japan did not have the correct medical facilities for the super rare disease of "checks notes" throat cancer....


:wooow:
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Aug 16, 2019
Messages
624
So it turns out I partially called in my post a couple chapters back, how she separated Miyuki and Yuu for their own sakes. But rather than not having any faith in Yuu, she simply recognized that the two of them would grow at different speeds and the inevitable inferiority Yuu would feel because of that. And, strictly for the sake of playing devil's advocate, how would you explain that to a pair of children? No siblings with a functional relationship are going to understand or accept "the two of you will grow at different speeds, so we need to separate you." But explaining differing rates of growth isn't going to stave off the comparisons and self-depreciation.

And speaking as someone who has an "imperfect-but-still-vastly-better-than-this" relationship with a parent who's also had to deal with cancer (multiple times, to boot), I can empathize with what's going on here. Yuu hasn't forgiven Ruriko, I don't think, but that doesn't mean she wants her mother to die. You can be angry at someone and have issues with them, but still love and/or care enough about them that something like life-threatening cancer causes your priorities to shift. And whatever her flaws and mistakes, Yuu wants Ruriko her mother to keep living. Not just so Ruriko can make amends for her mistakes, but also because she's her freaking mother and she doesn't want her to die.

The importance of singing to her also draws a strong parallel to Haru from chapter 1, what with how singing was all she had from a young age and it completely changed her life for the better. Even setting aside that it was Ruriko's profession and identity, singing was her life. So she was so terrified of losing the one thing that had been a cornerstone of her life that she went to reprehensible lengths to preserve her singing. As for why she resorted to going to America? I read another manga called Radiation House, and that manga (which is apparently based off of a live-action drama?) establishes that in a lot of parts of Japan there is a very understandable aversion towards anything that involves radiation, which includes medical treatments. So while radiation therapy isn't nonexistent in Japan, it is possible to believe they don't have the faculties or resources needed to give her the necessary treatment. Then you also have to take into account stuff like the paparazzi and so on...

....Now having said all that, Ruriko is still very much in the wrong and could have handled this whole thing a lot better. Including at least attempting to keep semi-regular contact with Yuu. Maybe she was ashamed of her actions- even before she could acknowledge her own selfishness- and that's why she couldn't reach out. But that still does not justify tearing apart your family and going no-contact for ten goddamn years. Japan as a culture strongly emphasizes filial piety and paternal responsibility and the whole "not making personal problems other peoples' problems" stuff, but even then there should be a limit! So good on Haru for calling Ruriko out when Yuu was too gobsmacked to get her thoughts in order.

It seems all but certain that the manga is coming to a close in the near future however, and I can't help but think that this is the best the author could do to resolve the biggest plot strings rather than leaving them unattended. Perhaps this would have been more palatable had this been told over a longer passage of time. Giving us more time with Ruriko as a character, more interactions between the family, and a longer period with which to explore the emotional conflict of "I resent my mother for abandoning me for ten years but that doesn't mean I want her to die!" and how you balance holding someone accountable with making sure they live long enough to be held to account.

It's a real shame, too. But there seem to be an abundance of music-based manga, and quite a few music-based girls' love manga as well. Maybe this one just didn't manage to stand out enough to keep going.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Sep 15, 2023
Messages
3,641
I don't think there's any sign of the series being axed, it's performing fine domestically.
Do you have any data to back that up? According to the data available on Shoseki Ranking, physical volume sales are pretty bad. Not a single volume has made it into the weekly rankings. Volume 1 appeared in the daily rankings twice, volumes 2 and 4 appeared once each, and volume 3 didn't show up at all.
 
Active member
Joined
Apr 18, 2025
Messages
11
Do you have any data to back that up? According to the data available on Shoseki Ranking, physical volume sales are pretty bad. Not a single volume has made it into the weekly rankings. Volume 1 appeared in the daily rankings twice, volumes 2 and 4 appeared once each, and volume 3 didn't show up at all.

Shoseki is specifically POS sales at specific bookstores, and doesn't include online bookstores (amazon, rakuten) or other big "specialty" stores (comic zin, animate, melonbooks, toranoana, gamers, etc.) so while the data is useful and fun to look at, it's not exhaustive.

I do agree though that sales are likely modest, but the series is getting reprints as recently as September, and Kashikaze has only really only tweeted recently to say how much she's enjoying drawing it and for the pop-up shop. It's my personal opinion, but I don't think there's any reason to think she's being pressured to end it, since it feels to me like it was always made to be a short/medium volume series. There's also been no advance announcements for the story ending, so we're all but certainly at least getting a Volume 6, but I don't think we'll get more than that.

My personal wishlist is for next chapter to feature Haru & Yuu officially getting together to cap off Vol 5, and then Volume 6 being development of their relationship. And Hikari and Miyuki hooking up?

Now, that being said, if it somehow ends with next month's chapter... :worry:

image.png

typo on page 19

:notlikethis::notlikethis::notlikethis: Thank you! Let it be known this is Serica's fault :smugnako:
 
Last edited:
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Mar 26, 2018
Messages
443
What got me the most was the old "had to get special treatment overseas" cliche. For 10 years. Obviously noted technologically backwards nation of Japan did not have the correct medical facilities for the super rare disease of "checks notes" throat cancer....


:wooow:
Makes 0 sense. The longest course of radiological treatments for throat cancer is like 2 months.
 
Double-page supporter
Joined
Aug 12, 2018
Messages
255
But to be fair, I think the author kinda wrote themselves into a corner. The whole premise of a mother abandoning her daughter, never coming to see her, and then suddenly showing up out of the blue without even telling her daughter she's coming back makes it really hard to generate any sympathy for her.
pretty much this, the author had her premise for the story but when it came the moment to resolve that it kind of clashes with how out there the situation actually is
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Mar 20, 2019
Messages
525
Ngl, author failed splendidly. Nothing was explained and (this might be the tl) the mother just ended up looking even worse lmao

So, both had a talent for music but one was learning faster so she only took that one and no contact abandoned the other for no reason.

And then she just rattles down her excuses list into hugging them all "boohoo I will live for all of you".

Unironically her death wouldve been infinitely better for the story and all characters.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Sep 5, 2025
Messages
235
I don't why but it's not satisfying conclusion of this problem and maybe because i read this when this is on going manga

This is similar with the lonely girl

But when i read the lonely girl and the series already finished, its feels satisfying because they didn't really focus on the mom situation (drama) but still the main couple. So, the situation as a whole feels wholesome
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Sep 14, 2020
Messages
1,021
Yeah no sorry Ruriko that's a bullshit excuse for abandoning your daughter for 2/3 of her life without telling her anything 😭 hope the cancer gets treated easily but you're still a dogwater mom 🥀
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top