6-nin no Shinanai Shoujo to Kanarazu Shinu Unmei no Hito

[RitoTheLittle]

Reminds me of Girls Go Around but thankfully a... good ending I guess? Nonetheless, interesting read, wished there were a bit more considering each "arc" is unsatisfyingly quick but oh well.

 

[Andrei2003]

I can't give this series a score! It starts as 10/10 but at the end it gets rushed before getting axed!

it was axed? i didn't feel like it since there's no more potential plot to explore but i kinda feel it was rushed especially at the explanation

 

[acertainmangareader]

Man do I hate it when a manga with an interesting premise with a really good starting arc somehow got axed and everything fell downwards from there. It could've been a solid read!

 

[Animeka_14]

Good starting but ending and explaining of things is ass a decent read 7 out of 10

 

[Monn12]

Yeah good start, not disappointed about the ending more like about depth.
By depth i mean she indeed in fact screwed his life. He had a perfectly fine and good life, he even was friendly with her but her wish was evil straight up evil. Instead of wishing to be his girlfriend she decided to wish him a lonely life. And what the dude does? I'm angry but it's fine, my grandma is cool.......

For a story that delves deep in traumas and tough stuff it scratches the surface with every encounter actually including MC himself.
In my opinion when you enter adult or deep stuff, you as an author have a obligation to think through what you are writing.

 

[minatognzls]

Damn this got exciting, its like Re:zero

 

[Late_Komei]

The premise reminds me of Shinigami-sama to 4-nin no Kanojo.

It's funny because both series got axed.

 

[Figger]

I think it was obvious who the fated partner was right from the start.

 

[Lavenlar]

it was axed? i didn't feel like it since there's no more potential plot to explore but i kinda feel it was rushed especially at the explanation

In the last page the author said it was cancelled; however, they only planned to make the story 4-5 volumes originally, so they were still able to more or less write the story the way they wanted. Ofc some things they had to leave out which probably explains why the ending might have felt sudden but I think overall it was aight. I was more of a fan of the first two girls TBH but this ending is aight too.

 

[DG2]

Ha valido la pena, aún cuando tenía que ir al traductor para buscar las palabras complejas.

 

[mrcats]

Hold-on...
Let him cook

 

[pureexe]

Good story but seem like it got axed. The religious girl and Childhood friend seem a bit rush.

 

[MonarckSkatty]

First impressions:
Feels like if you manga-fied "Webtoon character Na Kang Lim"

 

[MonarckSkatty]

Final impression:
Imagine if "Webtoon character Na Kang Lim" was a manga but the ending isn't satisfying and he only got one girl😗

 

[shakowa]

Are you fucking kidding me the other 4 girls were a way better choice

 

[obj071]

This is.. not great. It's like watching train derailing with full speed onto your car that stuck on crossing but in the end it just gently plops to the side right before you with "eh" sound.

 

[Nhan7525]

it seems like this manga is a bit dark, so imma say something that's funny(or i think so)
....chap 8 have a tralalelo tralala
good luck

 

[etsuyudoldi]

I want to kill myself for wasting my time over this dogshit

 

[Hyperkinesis]

Hmm... so...

Normally when I come into these types of stories I have very specific reasons why I like or dislike them—but if you asked me about this one? I don't think I'd have an answer for you. On the one hand, when I'm genuinely surprised by a twist it automatically earns brownie points (I'll get into this one), but on the other hand, nothing about it particularly stands out in my mind, and it's ending felt... odd.

I can't say this'll be everybody's cup of tea but if you sit back and try to enjoy it, you'll have a good time.

Spoiler: Twist Spoilers, and why I thought it was good

The culprit was pretty obvious right from the start... the "boyfriend" was obviously fake, and my guess two thirds in was partially correct—that she was jealous of the other five girls, killing herself whenever he came close to dating them. I was however, surprised that not only did she make her own wish, but that she had basically lived an entire alternate life without him and rewrote history itself to make them childhood friends. In that regard, I didn't see it coming—so no, it wasn't jealousy, it was guilt. And she wanted him to move on so that he'd okay when she "left." Kinda heartbreaking.

Spoiler: Ending Spoilers, and why I didn't really like it

I'm a firm believer that the tone of any good story should reflect it's resolution. Feel-good stories should have happy endings, melancholic stories should have sad resolutions, slice of life stories should have realistic resolutions, and darker stories should have darker resolutions. This one is odd because it's framed as a "light romantic comedy", but it actually goes to some very dark places. And that's what I think is tripping me up. Based on the ending, the author does clearly see this story as more of a mystery than something tragic, which is fine, but for those (like myself) that saw it as more of a darker story, given it revolves around suicide and death, and even had subjects of bullying, gun use, drug use, domestic abuse, and sexual abuse, it's resolution doesn't line up with the serious tone it had.

Don't get me wrong, I love an old-fashioned happy ending. But this one didn't feel earned because everyone was suffering the whole time. I won't go so far as to say it left a bitter taste since a genuinely tragic ending for everyone involved probably would've been profoundly disappointing, but someone should've lost, and there should've been harsher consequences.

Overall, it was a great read— 8/10. But if you read too much into it, you're probably going to come to a somewhat dissatisfied conclusion as I did.

 

[GummyT]

This was good. Did not regret an hour of reading. 9/10