A "review" section for manga pages :planned:

[DANDAN_THE_DANDAN]

TL;DR
Basically a second comment section that is made specifically for reviews.

I often look through the comments when hesitating whether or not I should read a certain manga... only to find discussions that stray way off the topic of the manga or literal comments about the manga instead of reviews.

Those aforementioned examples in themselves are not wrong, since they are comments about the manga, but a review section of something alike MyAnimeList would quite efficiently solve the problem I introduced earlier.

 

[DANDAN_THE_DANDAN]

Answer: Everyone needs their daily dose of randomness. Also Potato-chan best waifu.

 

[421cookies]

Potato all the way.

 

[Pika]

Eggplants bring good luck

 

[DANDAN_THE_DANDAN]

@Pika A potato brings fiber, potassium, vitamin C, and vitamin B6 content, along with its prominent lack of cholesterol, which all brings forth heart health. Potatoes also contain significant amounts of fiber, which helps lower the total amount of cholesterol in the blood, thereby decreasing the risk of heart disease.

I totally did not plagiarize this from whatever comes first in a Google search for potato health benefits and changed a few words.

 

[Pika]

@DANDAN_THE_DANDAN
The fiber, potassium, vitamin C, vitamin B6, and phytonutrient content in eggplants all support heart health. Chlorogenic acid has been shown to decrease low-density lipid (LDL) levels. It also acts as an antimicrobial, antiviral, and anticarcinogenic agent. Polyphenols in eggplant have been shown to have anti-cancer effects. Findings from animal studies suggest that nasunin, an anthocyanin in the eggplant skin, is a powerful antioxidant that protects brain cell membranes from free radical damage. Research has suggested that the antioxidants in eggplant may help protect the liver from certain toxins.

Totally did not steal it from medicalnewstoday.com after googling eggplants health benefits

 

[DANDAN_THE_DANDAN]

@Pika Let me get your facts straight!

Spoiler

🍆 Eggplant
X
100 g
🥔 Potato
X
100 g
Calorieskcal 35 93
Carbohydrateg 8.73 21.15
Fiber, total dietaryg 2.5 2.2
Starchg ~ 17.27
Sugars, totalg 3.2 1.18
Fructoseg ~ 0.34
Glucoseg ~ 0.44
Sucroseg ~ 0.4
Lactoseg ~ 0
Maltoseg ~ 0
Galactoseg ~ 0
Proteing 0.83 2.5
Essential Amino Acids g ✓ for sufficient amount 0.271 0.739
Histidineg 0.019 0.042
Isoleucineg 0.036 0.08
Leucineg 0.052 0.119
Lysineg 0.039 0.13
Methionineg 0.009 0.038
Phenylalanineg 0.035 0.099
Threonineg 0.03 0.081
Tryptophang 0.008 0.025
Valineg 0.043 0.125
Non-Essential Amino Acidsg 0.501 1.532
Alanineg 0.042 0.076
Arginineg 0.046 0.123
Cystineg 0.004 0.029
Tyrosineg 0.022 0.058
Aspartic acidg 0.134 0.583
Glutamic acidg 0.152 0.427
Glycineg 0.033 0.069
Prolineg 0.034 0.076
Serineg 0.034 0.091
Hydroxyprolineg ~ ~
Fatg 0.23 0.13
Monoenoic Fatty Acidsg 0.02 0.003
16:1g 0.002 0.001
16:1 cisg ~ ~
16:1 transg ~ ~
18:1g 0.018 0.001
18:1 cisg ~ ~
Vaccenic acid 18:1 trans, Ω-7g ~ ~
18:1 transg ~ ~
22:1g 0 0
22:1 cisg ~ ~
22:1 transg ~ ~
14:1g ~ ~
15:1g ~ ~
17:1g ~ ~
20:1g 0 0
24:1 cisg ~ ~
Polyenoic Fatty Acidsg 0.093 0.057
18:2g 0.078 0.043
Conjugated linoleic acids (CLAs) 18:2g ~ ~
18:2 cis Ω-6g ~ ~
18:2 ig ~ ~
18:2 t not further definedg ~ ~
18:2 t,tg ~ ~
18:3g 0.015 0.013
α-Linolenic acid (ALA) 18:3 Ω-3g ~ ~
18:3 cis Ω-6g ~ ~
18:3 ig ~ ~
20:3g ~ ~
20:3 Ω-3g ~ ~
20:3 Ω-6g ~ ~
20:4g 0 0
20:4 Ω-6g ~ ~
Eicosapentaenoic acid (EPA) 20:5 Ω-3g 0 0
Docosapentaenoic acid (DPA) 22:5 Ω-3g 0 0
Docosahexaenoic acid (DHA) 22:6 Ω-3g 0 0
20:2 cis Ω-6g ~ ~
18:4g 0 0
21:5g ~ ~
22:4g ~ ~
Saturated Fatty Acidsg 0.044 0.034
Butyric acid 4:0g 0 0
Caproic acid 6:0g 0 0
Caprylic acid 8:0g 0 0
Capric acid 10:0g 0 0.001
Lauric acid 12:0g 0 0.004
Tridecylic acid 13:0g ~ ~
Myristic acid 14:0g 0.001 0.001
Pentadecylic acid 15:0g ~ ~
Palmitic acid 16:0g 0.032 0.022
Margaric acid 17:0g ~ ~
Stearic acid 18:0g 0.012 0.005
Arachidic acid 20:0g ~ ~
Behenic acid 22:0g ~ ~
Lignoceric acid 24:0g ~ ~
Trans Fatty Acidsg 0 0
Trans-monoenoic Fatty acidsg ~ ~
Vaccenic acid 18:1 trans Ω-7g ~ ~
16:1 transg ~ ~
18:1 transg ~ ~
22:1 transg ~ ~
Trans-polyenoic Fatty acidsg ~ ~
18:2 t not further definedg ~ ~
18:2 t,tg ~ ~
Cholesterolmg 0 0
Omega 3g 0.015 0.013
α-Linolenic acid (ALA) 18:3 Ω-3g ~ ~
Eicosapentaenoic acid (EPA) 20:5 Ω-3g 0 0
Docosapentaenoic acid (DPA) 22:5 Ω-3g 0 0
Docosahexaenoic acid (DHA) 22:6 Ω-3g 0 0
20:3 Ω-3g ~ ~
Omega 6g 0.078 0.043
18:3 cis Ω-6g ~ ~
20:3 Ω-6g ~ ~
20:4 Ω-6g ~ ~
20:4 Ω-6g ~ ~
20:2 cis Ω-6g ~ ~
Other Sterolssmg ~ ~
Phytosterolsmg ~ ~
Stigmasterolmg ~ ~
Campesterolmg ~ ~
Beta-sitosterolmg ~ ~
Vitamins ↓ ↓
Vitamin AIU 37 10
Vitamin Aµg 2 1
Retinolµg 0 0
Cryptoxanthin, betaµg 0 0
Carotene, betaµg 22 6
Carotene, alphaµg 0 0
Vitamin DIU 0 0
Vitamin D (D2 + D3)µg 0 0
Vitamin D2 (ergocalciferol)µg ~ ~
Vitamin D3 (cholecalciferol)µg ~ ~
Vitamin Kµg 2.9 2
Vitamin K1µg 2.9 2
Vitamin K2µg ~ ~
Vitamin Emg 0.41 0.04
Tocopherol, alphamg 0.41 0.04
Tocopherol, betamg ~ 0
Tocopherol, gammamg ~ 0
Tocopherol, deltamg ~ 0
Tocotrienol, alphamg ~ ~
Tocotrienol, betamg ~ ~
Tocotrienol, gammamg ~ ~
Tocotrienol, deltamg ~ ~
Vitamin E, addedmg 0 0
Vitamin Cmg 1.3 9.6
B Vitamins ~ ~
Vitamin B1, Thiaminmg 0.076 0.064
Vitamin B2, Riboflavinmg 0.02 0.048
Vitamin B3, Niacinmg 0.6 1.41
Vitamin B5, Pantothenic acidmg 0.075 0.376
Vitamin B-6mg 0.086 0.311
B9, Folateµg DFE 14 28
Folateµg 14 28
Folic acidµg 0 0
Folate, naturalµg 14 28
Vitamin B-12µg 0 0
B-12, naturalµg 0 0
B-12, addedµg 0 0
Choline, totalµg 9.4 14.8
Betainemg ~ 0.2
Minerals ↓ ↓
Calciummg 6 15
Ironmg 0.25 1.08
Magnesiummg 11 28
Phosphorusmg 15 70
Potassiummg 123 535
Sodiummg 1 10
Zincmg 0.12 0.36
Coppermg 0.059 0.118
Manganesemg 0.113 0.219
Seleniumµg 0.1 0.4
Fluorideµg ~ ~
Others ↓ ↓

I totally did not attempt to copy paste a chart from https://compareyourfood.com/compare/Eggplant+Potato

 

[Hounder]

I can't decide if I should be saddened by this conversation.

Or impressed.

 

[421cookies]

@Pika Potato taste better than eggplant.

 

[ununseti]

I voted broccoli because broccoli arc.

...and yes, I'd be in favour of something like this. This could be one area where the ability to rate comments might actually be good. I usually find looking at the score splits for the top "most helpful" reviews to be more informative about the quality of the manga than the raw score itself. The reader can then more quickly make a judgment about whether they agree with the reviewer or not, and whether the manga is worth checking out or not.

Though one thing I personally tend to be careful of is falling into groupthink (see also). I often have this itch to check out what other people think of a manga, but I try to go in and read it without any other opinions that may be subconsciously priming my experience of the work.

If the score distribution is particularly weird or if the score is a bit low, I usually submit to the urge to check out the comments first. Sometimes there's a really enthusiastic commenter talking about some aspect that they really enjoyed about the manga, and usually that's enough incentive for me to start reading the manga. So the priming isn't necessarily bad; it could have a positive effect (or a negative effect) on my experience reading a manga.

Previous discussions:
- #8078: Reviews

 

[Pika]

@DANDAN_THE_DANDAN
I don't even know what some of those things are
tHeReFoRe i aM iMmUnE tO yOuR aRgUmEnT

@421cookies
Have you tried comparing an unwashed potato to an unwashed eggplant? An unwashed potato fills your mouth with grainy sand and an unwashed eggplant taste just like an eggplant!
I totally can wash potatoes thoroughly

I don't even know what I just wrote

 

[Porg]

this would be helpful, diving into comments can be difficult finding out what people think overall