@starburst98 I certainly get where you're coming from. I do think this concept has serious legs and can be amusing for quite a while, but you can't eat ice cream cake for every meal. I really do hope there's some kind of emotional or story payoff, or even a message about what makes a cute anime/manga girl. (namely, that secret ingredients like this are the difference between flash-in-the-pan once-a-season moe bait and legendary-waifu. Maybe some of us here would make the ideal beauty too!)
If it's just the gag over and over, yeah, that could wear thin eventually. But for now I still love what I'm seeing and am willing to see a lot more.