another comment suggestion

[schlo]

wasn't sure how much this was seen in the other comment thread so I'll cut and paste it. It has never made sense to me that you would show comments in two different orders and in one case show it ordered one way to show some comments and then change the order to see the rest of the comments. If nothing else just make it so you don't have to reorder the comments once in the comments section.

I would however like to see a change to the comments page. Right now depending on how you enter them you see either oldest first with the ability to walk through them or you see the 20 newest comments and a button at the bottom that basically says read older comments or something like that. Then in some cases you have to start jumping around to get back to where you were. Just have one method, I would think it would make the most sense have all comments ordered newest to oldest and show with the movement buttons.

 

[hazzack]

i mean, forum rework with new forum engine is planned along with v5. the best we can do is wait and see.

 

[konzolmester]

Let's hope the next comment section won't be anything like what Disqus uses. That is one bad system. period.

 

[schlo]

the biggest thing i'm looking forward to on the forum changes is being able to reply to a message and being able to search the forums.

 

[99red66]

@konzolmester how is it is bad, i personally find it very simple and easy to use

 

[konzolmester]

@99red66 The ui is not the problem. It prioritises comments to newest or best (number of likes) This alone is plain bad.
The user block system is just superficial. It just hides the blocked guys comment but the guy can still see even reply to yours.
Basicaly you dig your head into the ground like an ostrich. Don't matter tho what changes will come to MD cause big manga reading sites close down one after another......
only a matter of time.....

 

[BestBoy]

@konzolmester That's how the current MD block system works. Every Disqus I've seen has prioritized comments by newest. Which is also how MD comments work 50% of the time.

 

[99red66]

@konzolmester then what about facebook comments the that magananelo uses, even though u can like comments it doesn't let u sort by it
the feature i want most is the ability to post images in comments and a reply button(lol), the comment section in manganelo is downright gold

 

[comeonnow0]

@99red66

the feature i want most is the ability to post images in comments and a reply button(lol)

You can already post images in comments.
Step-by-step tutorial: https://mangadex.org/thread/245459/1/#post_2080085

 

[blackyawgdom]

-> wants facebook like comments.






Zuckerbot can suck my tentacle.