Casual chatting thread

[panzerkampfwagyu]

A lot of mediocre and poor-quality yuri is held in high regard by the yuri fandom

I find it somewhat weird. It's a behaviour you usually get by a more starved audience, while Yuri, from what I can perceive from the outside, is utterly massive. You'd think that would result in Yuri fans increasing their own standards, as they now have too much to read and therefore needing to prioritize the good stuff, similar to how gaming is right now.

 

[mylovenovels]

View attachment 46631
I can't believe you're like that now @Manko-sensei

The person who reported him was probably so irritated I'm crying

 

[pandascepter]

based. a good work is a good work. but i see many yuri titles rated 8.5+ yet they're fluffy non-stories devoid of interesting characters or writing. it seems more evident by the day that the only quality yuri i can rely on are touhou doujins.

this tbh. And it happens from time to time since there are literally no good rating system.

 

[pandascepter]

I find it somewhat weird. It's a behaviour you usually get by a more starved audience, while Yuri, from what I can perceive from the outside, is utterly massive. You'd think that would result in Yuri fans increasing their own standards, as they now have too much to read and therefore needing to prioritize the good stuff, similar to how gaming is right now.

Now imagine this. A yuri fundraiser to continue the series, author need like 100k yen and it surpassed in just a few hours to 300k yen. cmiiw. Makes you wonder sometimes.

 

[gimme_yuri_plz]

based. a good work is a good work. but i see many yuri titles rated 8.5+ yet they're fluffy non-stories devoid of interesting characters or writing. it seems more evident by the day that the only quality yuri i can rely on are touhou doujins.

I find it somewhat weird. It's a behaviour you usually get by a more starved audience, while Yuri, from what I can perceive from the outside, is utterly massive. You'd think that would result in Yuri fans increasing their own standards, as they now have too much to read and therefore needing to prioritize the good stuff, similar to how gaming is right now.

It seems that, simply by being a representation of girls' love and the LGBT cause, these stories are beyond any kind of criticism or scrutiny. I understand supporting a cause — I do too. But I won't give a poor story a high rating just because there are girls flirting.

For the fandom, representation is enough to rate a story highly

 

[pandascepter]

It seems that, simply by being a representation of girls' love and the LGBT cause, these stories are beyond any kind of criticism or scrutiny. I understand supporting a cause — I do too. But I won't give a poor story a high rating just because there are girls flirting.

For the fandom, representation is enough to rate a story highly

LGBT? Since when?
Its homies being homies.

 

[bigtiddyoneesan]

It seems that, simply by being a representation of girls' love and the LGBT cause, these stories are beyond any kind of criticism or scrutiny. I understand supporting a cause — I do too. But I won't give a poor story a high rating just because there are girls flirting.

For the fandom, representation is enough to rate a story highly

tbh all it takes is good art and a feel good story for most manga to get a high rating here. it's just especially pronounced in yuri

 

[pandascepter]

tbh all it takes is good art and a feel good story for most manga to get a high rating here. it's just especially pronounced in yuri

He need to watch Pulp Fiction.

 

[bigtiddyoneesan]

He need to watch Pulp Fiction.

i will if you do homie activities with me on the couch

 

[pandascepter]

i will if you do homie activities with me on the couch

Angry pastor comes in*

 

[BakedBanana]

Angry pastor comes in*

 

[pandascepter]

Haha, look at this guy. Very funny, sir. Now put your hands up or you will be archived in the book of The Seer

 

[panzerkampfwagyu]

It seems that, simply by being a representation of girls' love and the LGBT cause, these stories are beyond any kind of criticism or scrutiny. I understand supporting a cause — I do too. But I won't give a poor story a high rating just because there are girls flirting.

For the fandom, representation is enough to rate a story highly

TBH, it really reads like a cult problem within the fandom. "Our stuff is beyond criticism against the evil outsiders"
Though, I reckon that the actually queer Yuri fans are quite a minority, given that both Yuri and Yaoi are very much still most often fetish mangas for straight men and women respectively.

 

[pandascepter]

TBH, it really reads like a cult problem within the fandom. "Our stuff is beyond criticism against the evil outsiders"
Though, I reckon that the actually queer Yuri fans are quite a minority, given that both Yuri and Yaoi are very much still most often fetish mangas for straight men and women respectively.

Truest word has been spoken. This is literally what I got it. Even straight men will be in awe seeing a women kissing each other. Look at Brokeback Mountain

 

[bigtiddyoneesan]

Look at Brokeback Mountain

i tried, but all the DVDs at the Library were already checked out

 

[pandascepter]

i tried, but all the DVDs at the Library were already checked out

Shouldve asked @BakedBanana he knows the way in the Library of Ruina.
Need to reread Mahou Shoujo Site. My beloved Magical Girl trope. Girls dying.

 

[panzerkampfwagyu]

Truest word has been spoken. This is literally what I got it. Even straight men will be in awe seeing a women kissing each other. Look at Brokeback Mountain

TBH, I personally don't see that appeal of Yuri at all.
Might be my 'tism not letting me get the straight men doing some weird by proxy stuff to get their rise out of it

 

[BakedBanana]

Shouldve asked @BakedBanana he knows the way in the Library of Ruina.

yeah

Need to reread Mahou Shoujo Site. My beloved Magical Girl trope. Girls dying.

I tried watching the anime adaption but it didn't seem that good. Is the manga any better or is it a matter of taste?

 

[pandascepter]

TBH, I personally don't see that appeal of Yuri at all.
Might be my 'tism not letting me get the straight men doing some weird by proxy stuff to get their rise out of it

Its a reading material genre, stuff like this happens pretty often, try light one i dont know. Something yuri bait like Watamote

 

[pandascepter]

yeah

I tried watching the anime adaption but it didn't seem that good. Is the manga any better or is it a matter of taste?

Its Mahou Shoujo trope... Its decent... A lot are like this just like Madoka but a bit hard on the trope. Though you get satisfying chapter here and there.

The anime is good on the animation a few scenes are being you know...