Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Jun 30, 2025
- Messages
- 85
Snip
After thinking about it, I do agree that I was making out Shigechi to be more apathetic towards Gotou than she really is, my main issue lies with trying to frame her feelings as love or affection for him though. While this story isn't a masterpiece in terms of character writing, I think that the characters have some nuance to their feelings and desires that go beyond what is typical for romcom characters. If it were not for the way that Agawa, Shiina, Akito and even Gotou were written into the story - I would agree that Shigechi is just a well written tsundere however if we look at how the other characters are written, I feel that they don't neatly fit into the typical romcom tropes. It's harder to explain without using the previous girls as they have been around for longer and so have had more time to demonstrate what I'm saying above.
Her reasons for liking Gotou when you think about it are pretty slim, your main one about respecting boundaries isn't really emphasised in the story as far as I can remember (if I forgot though then please correct me), him not fucking her while knowing she isn't really comfortable with doing the sm stuff does show that Gotou isn't some super horny guy however it is also backed by Gotou saying he isn't into that stuff and Shigechi being readily open to fuck Gotou while degrading him later on. Her behaviour comes across more as intrigue with some hormonal desire mixed in as he did satisfy her sexually but his general behaviour either confuses or grosses her out, not enough to make her disinterested but there is not really any showings of her liking or being interested in any particular attribute of Gotou unlike the other girls.
To give you my stance without including other characters to flesh it out: I feel that while Shigechi does put up a tough exterior but is softer on the inside, it is moreso that she is like an actual teenage girl who larps as a popular mean girl seeing as she likes to hang around popular groups and only hook up with a certain caliber of guy yet ended up being nervous about Gotou touching her despite initiating the SM stuff despite being a supposed slut like Agawa and Shiina. Her behaviour towards him seems more like her trying to act analytical or understand why a supposed loser is in the situation she is, outside of Gotou she even tries to go around asking Agawa questions about her love life and if she is really happy with the way things are in a direct manner yet at the same time goes on to try and get with Gotou anyways despite suspecting he could be her friends crush which just comes across as childish which fits as she is still a kid even if she tries to act more mature than she really is.
Her reasons for liking Gotou when you think about it are pretty slim, your main one about respecting boundaries isn't really emphasised in the story as far as I can remember (if I forgot though then please correct me), him not fucking her while knowing she isn't really comfortable with doing the sm stuff does show that Gotou isn't some super horny guy however it is also backed by Gotou saying he isn't into that stuff and Shigechi being readily open to fuck Gotou while degrading him later on. Her behaviour comes across more as intrigue with some hormonal desire mixed in as he did satisfy her sexually but his general behaviour either confuses or grosses her out, not enough to make her disinterested but there is not really any showings of her liking or being interested in any particular attribute of Gotou unlike the other girls.
To give you my stance without including other characters to flesh it out: I feel that while Shigechi does put up a tough exterior but is softer on the inside, it is moreso that she is like an actual teenage girl who larps as a popular mean girl seeing as she likes to hang around popular groups and only hook up with a certain caliber of guy yet ended up being nervous about Gotou touching her despite initiating the SM stuff despite being a supposed slut like Agawa and Shiina. Her behaviour towards him seems more like her trying to act analytical or understand why a supposed loser is in the situation she is, outside of Gotou she even tries to go around asking Agawa questions about her love life and if she is really happy with the way things are in a direct manner yet at the same time goes on to try and get with Gotou anyways despite suspecting he could be her friends crush which just comes across as childish which fits as she is still a kid even if she tries to act more mature than she really is.