Fukushuu wo Chikatta Shironeko wa Ryuuou no Hiza no Ue de Damin wo Musaboru

[Narehate]

@orp It’s fluffy shoujo and there isn’t anything offensively bad about it, so I’m not exactly getting why you think it’s so horrible here.

Though I suppose all you have to do to be a critic nowadays is shout “it’s generic” and nothing else.

 

[orp]

@Narehate
No, no, no, what true high-brow intellectual critics do these days is providing completely useless passive-agressive remarks to random people's opinions on the Internet.

Seriously, lol. If you feel so strongly about this manga and want better reviews, write one. My comment, at least, points out two things: it's bog-standard (which is very far from "horrible") and has nice art. This is something helpful to someone who's looking at the comment section, wondering if the manga is worth their time. Your initial reply, on the other hand, is supremely unhelpful. Now you've added that it's fluffy - I'm not even disagreeing. That's not an objection, all three things can be at the same time. Still crap story-wise, but again - random Internet opinion. Do better, lol.

 

[Aldis]

I read the web novel ahead and glad Aki is the artist since she can bring the magical fluffy shojo feelings (yet she prefer drawing all boys manga haha). However, towards the story... it's feel like rough draft. Sure it's your usual OP MC, but the main point is the cat!!! Which... hmm imo not really the main point...? That what I felt.

Overall the whole plot seems better for elementary school students reader rather than teen girl. I stop reading after Asahi's disappearance and another misunderstanding plot between MC and ML because how bland it is.

I also kind of bored, wondering, already accepting but still wondering, why another 'pale skin and platinum blonde' is 'rare jewel' and 'fair woman'. The opposite can also fair u knowww level up ur trope writersss

 

[Madologist]

Bit of nitpicking here, but since all of the chapter parts are posted here at once per chapter, why not just post them as one whole chapter?

 

[stackman]

Wow, the title makes so much sense now.

 

[Narehate]

@orp
My hobby is passive aggressively snarking at edgy commenters who try to find reasons why everything is shit so they can feel like an amazing critic, so pardon me on that one. I had you pegged for one, but you actually seem reasonable so I guess I was wrong.

If you want my actual review, it’s fluffy, inoffensive shoujo isekai that’s very tropey/cliche in its genre but it’s very easily ignored if you don’t fixate on it and just enjoy the type of story it’s trying to present. It’s got that iyashikei feel.

I’m the type of person who thinks “generic” isn’t a bad thing if it has enough other positives to balance that negative out.

 

[orp]

@Narehate
The thing is, if you mentally substitute this manga's excellent art with something mediocre (or try to read the original novel, like one commenter here apparently did), you'll probably find the story it tries to present much harder to actually enjoy.

Also, from the sound of it, it seems like you need a better hobby. Nobody cares about random throwaway comments on the Internet - not even those who write them, lol. Why should you.

 

[VoidR]

me after reading generic shitty iseaki number 300#

But yeah @orp , as someone who read all the currently released WN chapters, it gets worse

 

[Narehate]

@orp I actually read the novel and kind of enjoyed it. Definitely has... issues, things that I would change, and some of the characters act completely retarded and incomprehensible, but I’m willing to overlook a lot of stuff if I just enjoy the read overall.

 

[orp]

@Narehate
Well, to each their own, I guess.

Still, I can't help but feel for the artist who presumably has to waste their talent on this nonsense by the editor's insistence - it's isekai, it's popular, it's going to sell! I could be wrong about this, but I'm imagining the whole thing as if it was a Bakuman subplot, lol.

 

[theilikepie]

Its okay but its another one that falls into the trope of "villainess/misunderstood protagonist"

Are we ever gonna get a female isekai like 12 kingdoms ever again

 

[TheDefend]

@eustacescrubb bro. You list ch6 as ch5 on 6.1 title

 

[eustacescrubb]

@TheDefend
ok ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ don't tag me in this stuff thanks

 

[halfminute]

@theilikepie Are we ever gonna get a female isekai like 12 kingdoms ever again

I miss isekai stories before isekai was 'cool'.

 

[furopoi]

thanks for the rapid pace of translations lately. this series is nice

 

[crazybars]

I don't get this manga.

Is she training to be a trophy wife or someone's pet 'Cat'?

 

[dim1]

@crazybars: don't need to understand it, I'm just want it to be light and fluffy

 

[VoidR]

>group makes mistake
>someone points it out without being rude
>cue passive aggressive " ok ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ don't tag me in this stuff thanks"

really making yourself look good chap

 

[eustacescrubb]

@VoldR I'm translating this stuff in my own free time for you guys to enjoy. Feel free to find someone else to translate for you from now on if you don't like my attitude.

 

[TsubasaNoHana]

This manga is kinda cute and fluffy.. feels like the lighter version of The Ancient Magus Bride ? ?