Gimai Seikatsu - Vol. 4 Ch. 21.2

[Apep23]

Making solution based on assumption often strikes hard on the people whoever it might concern. As a psychiatric, they should ask the recipient what’s on their mind and gives some encouragement or solution based on the case study, not assumption based of how the psychiatric feels, it can work for someone, but often misleading for many people.

It is irresponsible from her part to says things based on her assumption of saki and her relationship but it does strikes saki’s heart because of the fact that this is a storyboard that a people made, not a real life.

 

[ohms]

Way to enter the conversation a week later.

Who said “boyfriend“? You must be an idiot if you think that incredibly inappropriate conversation with the professor was suggesting anything but her dating a few different guys to see if it feels different than when she’s with her stepbrother. She works and goes to a coed school, she “interacts“ plenty with other guys. Dating is the only ”interaction“ that she’s not already doing.

She clearly said she didn't mean about dating. That's your own delusional interpretation. Which part of "You don't have to get a lover or anything like that" was so hard for you to understand? It was literally mentioned for people like you and yet, you missed it entirely.

And Saki clearly told the professor that she had no interaction with any other men other than her family members. Again, learn how to read.

And it doesn't matter when I joined the conversation. I'll just point out stupid take when I saw one.

 

[phorx]

She clearly said she didn't mean about dating. That's your own delusional interpretation. Which part of "You don't have to get a lover or anything like that" was so hard for you to understand? It was literally mentioned for people like you and yet, you missed it entirely.

And Saki clearly told the professor that she had no interaction with any other men other than her family members. Again, learn how to read.

And it doesn't matter when I joined the conversation. I'll just point out stupid take when I saw one.

“You don't have to get a lover or anything like that" is EXACTLY the line I was referring to when I said she didn’t have to get a boyfriend. Maybe you just don’t know how dating works but most people date for a while before deciding to become an exclusive couple. That’s the norm in real life. She could date a couple guys casually and see how it goes without becoming committed.

Let‘s play along though and pretend that wasn’t what the perverse professor was suggesting. Keep in mind that she avoids guys because she knows they’re all interested in her body. Please explain with specific examples what “interactions” Saki should be pursuing with men if it’s not dating that she’s not already doing. What is she going to do to get close enough with other guys to allow her to understand whether or not her feelings for her stepbrother are just a result of him being the only guy of similar age she spends a lot of time with?
Bonus points if you can think of one where the guy on their side isn’t thinking that this is their big chance to get with her.

 

[Dzrian]

Wtf is this? The way she finds out all these sounds so unrealistic and convenient. Terrible advice as well. She shouldn't seek out to meet new people, dating or not, just because of making her feelings clearer. At that point, you're as good as trying to force yourself to move on because you're aware of what you're doing, you may end up seeking until a mistake happens, speaking from personal experience.

I hope I'm wrong for this title.
I've seen this kind of development happen in a variety of different shows and titles. It's just unnecessary drama cliche most of the time and it looks as if this might head towards that direction.
The guy and the girl seems to be in a phase where they meet different people. Upon hearing about it from each other or coincidentally spotted, it causes a reaction that makes them both think, "yep it seems i do have to move on," sometimes fuelled with misunderstanding. They end up dating these different people for the sake of it and thinking that it's the right love. Then cue some longing feelings, some interactions or whatever that basically NTRs the NTR, more drama, etc.

I hope it's not this, please. Are there raws ahead, or is it going to be in a good direction so I wont have to ease myself with the raws? If good, just say it, don't spoil me yet.

 

[ShinduPK4]

I've loved this manga thus far, but this whole arc was a mistake.
This joke of a uni professor? She's the embodiment of cringe. It's like the author asked a preschooler to describe a “cool professor”.
The setting for this arc is annoyingly bad. This little pest from the school, Shinjou Keisuke, is trying to get together with Saki. Then a sociopathic cringelord of a uni professor appears, gets absurdly interested in her, starts playing a psychologist for her, and tells her to basically try to find someone else. It almost couldn't be more obvious what the author is going for, and it's cheap as hell. The NTR arc as a trigger for the main couple's progress is such a bad cliché.

---

Again, I've loved this manga, but this arc alone might make me drop this.