Haru no Regista - Vol. 2 Ch. 9.1 - Just Give it to Me (Part 1)

Dex-chan lover
Joined
Mar 28, 2019
Messages
381
This yuri manga manages to depict modern defending better than other football mangas. Yes, not Blue Lock, at least they have the excuse of being strikers. I'm looking at you, Embers.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Oct 14, 2020
Messages
299
Blocking a player with the ball with your entire body and arm is not a legal move in soccer. :)
 
Aggregator gang
Joined
Sep 13, 2024
Messages
18
Ah yes, the typical pull other people's outfit to drag them down as long as the ref can't see it strategy. Dirty as hell, but also efficient.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 18, 2023
Messages
2,792
Blocking a player with the ball with your entire body and arm is not a legal move in soccer. :)
First of all football

Also it is indeed legal when you block the attacker from getting to the ball before it gets out of play, it happens pretty much every game.
Now what is illegal is pulling the shirt of your opponent so you can hold them back and get to the ball first… I am actually wondering if there even is a ref (sure she said refs blindspot, but come on every ref can see that foul…)
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Mar 28, 2019
Messages
381
First of all football

Also it is indeed legal when you block the attacker from getting to the ball before it gets out of play, it happens pretty much every game.
Now what is illegal is pulling the shirt of your opponent so you can hold them back and get to the ball first… I am actually wondering if there even is a ref (sure she said refs blindspot, but come on every ref can see that foul…)
Even if ref can see it, they'd only whistle when the ball changes possession (which in this case, it does, so if ref see it, it should be a foul.) But they tend to give advantage if the attacking team is still in control of the ball.

This is a textbook case of tactical foul but ref didn't see, which players like Rodri, Fernandinho, and other world-class DMs master
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Aug 15, 2020
Messages
155
Even if ref can see it, they'd only whistle when the ball changes possession (which in this case, it does, so if ref see it, it should be a foul.) But they tend to give advantage if the attacking team is still in control of the ball.

This is a textbook case of tactical foul but ref didn't see, which players like Rodri, Fernandinho, and other world-class DMs master
Most of the case, refs don't considered is as a foul if the ball's pretty far from the attacker and this is the case with Mei and Urushi. Moreover outside the box. I often do it and they don't call it as a foul.
If you talk about the shirt-tugging, yes it's a foul; but defenders usually play "innocent" by playing in the gray area: tugging the attacker for just a split of second and just a tiny bit part of the shirts. When they're already in advantage, they let go the attacker and steal the ball so the ref doesn't call it as a foul.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 18, 2023
Messages
2,792
Even if ref can see it, they'd only whistle when the ball changes possession (which in this case, it does, so if ref see it, it should be a foul.) But they tend to give advantage if the attacking team is still in control of the ball.

This is a textbook case of tactical foul but ref didn't see, which players like Rodri, Fernandinho, and other world-class DMs master
No, the ref dont only whistle if the ball changes possession, he will whistle if he can see that there is no advantage even if the attacking team keeps the ball. Also there is no advantage to give here, the defender kicked the ball out of play instantly with her tackle and it also dont really matter considering it happened inside the box, so its just a penalty nothing else to discuss.
Also this is not what you call a tactical foul… A tactical foul you use on the middle of the field to stop a dangerous attack, this literally happened inside the box, its a clear penalty everyday of the week.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 18, 2023
Messages
2,792
Most of the case, refs don't considered is as a foul if the ball's pretty far from the attacker and this is the case with Mei and Urushi. Moreover outside the box. I often do it and they don't call it as a foul.
If you talk about the shirt-tugging, yes it's a foul; but defenders usually play "innocent" by playing in the gray area: tugging the attacker for just a split of second and just a tiny bit part of the shirts. When they're already in advantage, they let go the attacker and steal the ball so the ref doesn't call it as a foul.
I mean here its pretty clear. Attacker was faster and suddenly the defender comes first, only reason its a clear shirt pull. Also thats not a tiny bit part of the shirt, she straight up put her hand inside the shirt to get a good grip🤣 Whats more it happened inside the box, so its a penalty. Any ref can see this, which is why since there apparently is a ref (hard to believe) in this games, they must be supporting the other team…
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Aug 15, 2020
Messages
155
I mean here its pretty clear. Attacker was faster and suddenly the defender comes first, only reason its a clear shirt pull. Also thats not a tiny bit part of the shirt, she straight up put her hand inside the shirt to get a good grip🤣 Whats more it happened inside the box, so its a penalty. Any ref can see this, which is why since there apparently is a ref (hard to believe) in this games, they must be supporting the other team…
It's also clear that she uses her body to block the ref's POV.
Also iirc, the ref is from Bara no En. You can check again in chapter 7.1.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 18, 2023
Messages
2,792
It's also clear that she uses her body to block the ref's POV.
Also iirc, the ref is from Bara no En. You can check again in chapter 7.1.
If I didnt know better I would think they played vs Madrid and the refs…
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top