Hiromi - Ch. 1 - Part 1

Member
Joined
Jan 21, 2024
Messages
20
Read the first chapter, thank you for translating!

My thoughts for the first part: it feels like psychological horror without anything crazy going on. Good storytelling and artwork but confusing. I'm looking forward to see how the story progresses since I'm really not sure why Shuzo (is this an autobiography?) is so scared of this kid. I understand he's a bit brash but it doesn't seem like Hiromi is a horrible bully. The teacher was definitely "eccentric"...It was somehow really intense. I guess it encapsulates the dramatic view of tamer situations as a kid? Very pecuilar manga.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Sep 10, 2019
Messages
419
I kinda relate to Sensei! For quiet students like us, people like Hiromi are so scary. In our little world called class, we can't escape him. I feel the terror just reading it. I'm curious about the sin Sensei wants to tell us.

Thanks a lot for the translation! You're the best!
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Sep 12, 2024
Messages
77
As a kid, even little things can seem like world-shattering events, and yet kids also get over their worries so quickly at times. Here we see both sides of the coin.

I wonder what will happen next considering the tags on this manga; super interesting.
 

BCS

Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 31, 2018
Messages
7,054
So it's only 2 chapters this time? Not 200?
 
Member
Joined
Jul 10, 2020
Messages
1
I kinda relate to Sensei!
At first I thought you were saying you relate to the teacher and really wanted to hear your POV! 😂

I'm really not sure why Shuzo (is this an autobiography?) is so scared of this kid. I understand he's a bit brash but it doesn't seem like Hiromi is a horrible bully.

Yeah, I think it's his first time actually putting himself into a proper series rather than a character who's basically himself with a different name! But I don't think Hiromi is a bully at all -- just a first grader with behavioral problems. I just think that Shuzo and the others find him difficult to deal with. He seems developmentally challenged and he likely annoys and hurts those around him without realizing it. I don't think he scribbled all over Shuzo's drawings or punch him out of malice and he likely encouraged the teacher's investigations because he just wanted to draw.

Hiromi is the victim. Not just because Shuzo didn't speak up about the doodle. His fellow students probably find him just as annoying as Shuzo does and accused him simply they didn't want someone they liked to be punished. It could even be that the teacher put out her odd investigation specifically as a means of punishing Hiromi for his regular behavioral patterns in class because she expected only Hiromi to start doodling without given permission. More than that, we can see that Hiromi comes from a broken home. A tiny, dirty, shack, with miserable parents who barely care about him -- contrast that to the Oshimi household's upper middle class home.

I think Shuzo's guilt goes far beyond his sin of lying about the doodle but through a realization of what it means to see the victim (and perhaps one day even a friend) in that ugly annoying kid that pisses you off and to accept that Shuzo himself contributed to that coordinated victimization surrounding Hiromi. A psychological anguish based on one's own moral compass and inability to stand up for others.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Apr 15, 2019
Messages
3,681
Read the first chapter, thank you for translating!

My thoughts for the first part: it feels like psychological horror without anything crazy going on. Good storytelling and artwork but confusing. I'm looking forward to see how the story progresses since I'm really not sure why Shuzo (is this an autobiography?) is so scared of this kid. I understand he's a bit brash but it doesn't seem like Hiromi is a horrible bully. The teacher was definitely "eccentric"...It was somehow really intense. I guess it encapsulates the dramatic view of tamer situations as a kid? Very pecuilar manga.
As an introvert, I definitely understand why he's scared of that boy. Especially when you're a kid
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Nov 20, 2023
Messages
7,845
lol I can’t imagine having a “friend” over as a kid bc my parents were strict about it (they pretty much never answered the door unless it was the delivery guy) but I wonder about “pushy” kids like these since some parents would’ve found it awkward to ask them to leave if they weren’t outright assholes

Altho voting aside I’m sure ppl would’ve outright said to his face he was annoying
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top