Hope You're Happy, Lemon - Ch. 66

Dex-chan lover
Joined
Aug 15, 2024
Messages
529
I think the flashback was successful but we’ve been flashing back for so long I forgot this was a BODY-SWITCHING STORY. Like, glad they’re figuring out their feelings but they really need to figure out what caused this body-swapping curse in the first place
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Oct 27, 2018
Messages
826
I do think making it so that she didnt actually want to see him again and that she acted to elicit hatred are a good direction, it kinda recontexualizes her ealy behaviour and clears up why she didnt ever come out with the truth (even if it relies on sunano literally gaslighting himself which she had no way of knowing happened lmao).
The dilemma she has between her own interest and what she thinks is best for sunano is also neat imo.
I distinctively remember him mentioning the fact that she "cheated on him with 3 guys" so he did bring up the past and i wonder what she means with him not bringing it up, but whatever i gues he stopped talking about it pretty quickly.
If i recall, he didnt bring up to her, but to his friend
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Oct 27, 2018
Messages
826
Can't Lemon just don't forgive this girl? she just ruined her relationship (well, it was also because of Lemon's insecurity). But taht doesn't cancel waht she did, spreading rumors and then coming with apology, is this calming your demons?

As for Lemon, she was just burning bridges, but magic happens..
The thing is, she wanted to forgive.
She feels awful because there's no more ""excuse"" for her feeling bad; feeling negative emotions.

Her just 'not forgiving this girl' would mean that Sunao shouldnt forgive her as well. Even so, she wants to apologize and make it better. Even so, she wants to get close to him

sorry for the misspellings
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Nov 28, 2020
Messages
616
I think the flashback was successful but we’ve been flashing back for so long I forgot this was a BODY-SWITCHING STORY. Like, glad they’re figuring out their feelings but they really need to figure out what caused this body-swapping curse in the first place
You're not gonna get anything of note if that's what you're after. It was a falling star that she made an accidental or intentional wish on, that's all. It's just gonna stop towards the end, they'll say they're glad it did and never explain it further. It's just a convenient story mechanism, this isn't gonna turn sci-fi/fantasy for the last chapter my man.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Feb 2, 2025
Messages
396
If i recall, he didnt bring up to her, but to his friend
I meant specifically this moment
Screenshot_20250624_023735_Chrome.jpg
 
Fed-Kun's army
Joined
May 30, 2023
Messages
45
The college manga had a flashback arc to spend months to teach you that not every classmate liked Lemon back in High School, but that they made amends before the manga started.

We now know that Lemon didn't really have a good reason to tell the lie and it was on a whim. And learned that Sunao never believed her or was hurt by it, he just wondered why.

What was even the purpose of the mangas first few chapters and premise?

Their whole situation feels more shallow and contradictory now than before. I've seen beach fanservice that develops the story and characters more.

Bad filler.

I think the best take away is that they were both awful about open communication. Instead of sitting down and talking to each other (as each of them were at least somewhat inclined to do and felt they should have), they procrastinated and wallowed in self-pity and teen angst.

Even the flash forward to Lemon's attempt to push Sunao further away is the epitome of just not being open and honest about what she wants. It's why we've had the whole story to read so far.

Even as a fairly stalwart defender of this manga, I don't know that I buy everything from the flashback POVs, but I do think they ultimately accomplish what they needed to and I do buy most of Lemon's motivations. I was once a moody, depressed, self-destructive (emphasis on self-destructive) teenager once. I still carry some of that baggage over a decade later so I can't say it's all that unrealistic.

Also, it's not filler. Filler is frilly nonsense that doesn't flesh out the story. This is the exact opposite of filler.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Aug 2, 2020
Messages
384
I think the best take away is that they were both awful about open communication. Instead of sitting down and talking to each other (as each of them were at least somewhat inclined to do and felt they should have), they procrastinated and wallowed in self-pity and teen angst.

Even the flash forward to Lemon's attempt to push Sunao further away is the epitome of just not being open and honest about what she wants. It's why we've had the whole story to read so far.

Even as a fairly stalwart defender of this manga, I don't know that I buy everything from the flashback POVs, but I do think they ultimately accomplish what they needed to and I do buy most of Lemon's motivations. I was once a moody, depressed, self-destructive (emphasis on self-destructive) teenager once. I still carry some of that baggage over a decade later so I can't say it's all that unrealistic.

Also, it's not filler. Filler is frilly nonsense that doesn't flesh out the story. This is the exact opposite of filler.
Zero story advancement with many chapters of zero-progress retcon flashbacks handled like this is still filler, or padding, or time-wasting chapters meant to prolong a series.

We got:

1. Mean girl plotline introduced and resolved before the filler flashback is over, leaving Lemon with the same romantic feelings she had at flashback start and end, and

2. Sunao being unchanged from how he is now except a single page where Sunao decides "I guess I'll just think of her as the witch" to try and hold the original stories new holes together with dental floss.

This flashback degrades the quality of the older chapters on a re-read. And nothing of value is gained from it. It just filled space to buy time for the actual story to catch up.

That's the reason all the people defending it keep adding qualifiers such as
"I don't know I buy everything"
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Feb 22, 2021
Messages
5,513
...

Even as a fairly stalwart defender of this manga, I don't know that I buy everything from the flashback POVs, but I do think they ultimately accomplish what they needed to and I do buy most of Lemon's motivations. I was once a moody, depressed, self-destructive (emphasis on self-destructive) teenager once. I still carry some of that baggage over a decade later so I can't say it's all that unrealistic.

Also, it's not filler. Filler is frilly nonsense that doesn't flesh out the story. This is the exact opposite of filler.
Lemon is even in college still trying to figure things out. She's a bit of an unreliable narrator.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top