I'm in Love with the Villainess - Ch. 47 - Revenge and Ideals

[DMBLaan99]

So is this meta gaming?

 

[SrNevik]

That felt more like from Lily than Claire...

That was from Claire and she's done that a few other times and increasingly so.

 

[FantasyMaster]

That was from Claire and she's done that a few other times and increasingly so.

Could be. In fact I said "felt", bc unless one reads the novel where it's written ""lorem ipsum" Claire said", that could come from anyone.
Now, again, it could be Claire, but personally, it's weird that in the next panel it looks like Lily is the one "flustered" while Claire is somewhat calm. Once more, it could be that Claire shouted first and then calmed down to react to Lily realization. I just stated what I felt reading that page.

 

[estrogenthief]

barring Lily processing she has a brother and the code with Arla, nothing is changed from the book here.

then again, Lily is so badly written as a character she borders on certain uncommon archetypes of the term Mary Sue.

Lily makes me scratch my head so much as to why she’s there to begin with especially when everyone else is written better and the only other weirdo of her ilk is Rei’s ara ara mom who is written off as a joke that Rei desperately is trying to avoid. Especially knowing what her character is later it’s a genuine confusion to me why was written the way she is.

 

[toapat]

Lily makes me scratch my head so much as to why she’s there to begin with especially when everyone else is written better and the only other weirdo of her ilk is Rei’s ara ara mom who is written off as a joke that Rei desperately is trying to avoid. Especially knowing what her character is later it’s a genuine confusion to me why was written the way she is.

Lily is a complete mess since shes literally just the mouthpiece for the author to primarily discuss their views on the japanese LGBT community and its handling in society, something that was handled well in the Misha: "Rae, are you what they call Gay?" discussion and then is handled poorly in Yu's Secret and then terribly in the Nur Empire trial. The Author clearly decided they liked her and continues using her after that initial scene, welding multiple other character relations onto her, and keeping her around way longer then any plan called for so she keeps inheriting things that break the character's internal logic further. As i said, she borders on earning a Mary Sue status, as an Author Insert Sue. basically the only reason she isnt, is because Rae is the designate author mouthpiece as all 4 sexuality monologues are dictated by her

the real problem, and i only started bringing this up once the manga brought her in since she comes off as a retcon in the novels, is Pope Clarise and how she breaks Lily's entire story by existing. Apparently theres a distinctly separate Rei Ohashi clone who Lily has as her Direct Superior, and is just as much of a raging lesbian as Rae Taylor, who doesnt have The Talk with a cardinal who is very clearly emotionally suffering from being publicly outed. And dont say its out of character for the Pope to abuse positional authority with her subordinate, we know shes not above committing sexual assault with a married woman.

 

[Purplelibraryguy]

"Are you sure you want to do that? If you're mistaken, it will be your head for overstepping your boundaries!"
"True, but you don't care about that. If it wasn't in there you wouldn't be trying to discourage me."

 

[Justking14]

As long as it's something that didn't get retcon'd out of happening by your intervention anyway (the typical villainess saving OG characters from their fate and derail everything)

Yeah but this is a love letter that was written years before she started interfering. Kinda hard for her to muck Things up so bad that she changes something that old

There are definitely risks to pulling this kind of stunt. You'll sound like a crazy person, which gives whoever you're making accusations of a layer of plausible deniability for both whatever you're accusing them of and of your untimely "accidental" demise that will surely follow when you make accusations of a powerful figure.

That's why Rae has still been going through the trouble of actually finding the evidence in the first place.

calling her crazy is certainly an option but if someone read you a passage from your diary verbatim, you’d panic. It means she has some way to get very dangerous and private info on you. Sure killing her is an option but she’s one of the strongest people in the kingdom. And works for the king. It’s not gonna be easy

 

[yanderecoverl]

No more Yuri, sad..

 

[Angelsheart85]

Thanks so much for the update!

 

[Shiromon]

okay, spoil me, where is this shit going from here? I started this for the cute and funny yuri antics, don't particularly care for all the drama and PLOT that revolves around the game's plot and I wanna know if this shit will be an annoying slog that will last forever until it's finally resolved