Jinsei Gyakuten - Uwaki sare, Enzai wo Kiserareta Ore ga, Gakuen Ichi no Bishoujo ni Natsukareru - Ch. 3

[TestAddress]

If you think love is all about sex or f**king especially around highschool age and it will make you cool or chad, there must be something wrong with you.

He better stop that porn. Not all women like being Exhibitionist, unlike what they watched.

 

[TestAddress]

read the WN, and it's pretty unrealistic.. the punishment for all of the culprits and the bandwagons

Because there is injustice in real life.

 

[onekele]

Woah, peak teacher? In my dumpster trash manga?

 

[Kami_Nana]

"Who is that homewrecker?" Girl you the one almost make him lose his life, without her he already on the ground lifeless

I kinda wish there was a what-if scenario...just to see how she would have reacted to her BS claiming her so called childhood friend's life. Would she blame others like here...or accept her own part in his death?

 

[Zynn8]

Revenge time is coming guys, it's time to fight back let's goo!!

 

[Ryujin_kami47]

I don't know how the manga will handle it, but while I'm excited for the front half I'm much more leery about later down the road. At some point we just start beating a dead horse.

Spoiler: What made me stop reading the WN

In the future the cheating ex gf will be so emotional beatdown from the yelling and accusations from her mother, mc's mother, her classmates, her teachers, the mc's new girl and the mc herself, that she will try to kill herself. But instead of realizing they might be pushing a bit hard, they double down on her calling her selfish and wanting to run away leaving a wound on the mc's heart.

I know many people want to see her get her comeuppance, and she does. But at some point you have to stop punishing someone for a mistake. I just don't see the point of expecting great emotional maturity and reasoning from a high school girl.

Nah that was a choice. Not a mistake.

Have you never been in a situation where you make a wrong choice and then the situation spirals out of control and you are constantly confused and pressured and not sure what to do or say, so you don't do anything or try not to rock the boat to much for fear what may happen? No?

Also I'm saying the punishment should at some point end. Ya'll seem to be thinking I'm saying let her off now, I'm not. She is going to get wrecked and I'm for it. To a point. At that point we gotta move on from kicking a person while they are down.

No, she had multiple opportunities to set things right, but no she didn't. You see shit spiraling you nip it. Did it in middle school and did it in highschool no excuse. And you take you lashing and bare it. I'll will forever call my brothers ex "The Hanger"/ "Hangman" and she have the nerve to call us and bitch that she did nothing wrong. Fuck that.

 

[Umbrum]

So bad it's funny

 

[UdenEmpati]

Huh? I think what you're saying is correct, but this sounds very strange.

How long was Eiji being bullied for then?



Wrong. This is not even true in real life. There are degrees to wrongdoing that address both intent and action. Ex: A case of attempted murder does not necessitate an equal penalty to murder of the first, or even the second, degree.

If Eiji died, this story and its consequences would be a lot different from it is now. But he didn't. So how does "any" punishment fit? Miyuki didn't intend for her to kill himself, nor did she direct him to do so. She is an accessory to his attempted suicide. This, apparently, goes both ways, as Miyuki attempts suicide herself? So if she dies, this means everyone involved in it deserves "any" punishment too, right? Including the teachers who failed to do anything about it? Know that this is also bullying and that "she started it" would not absolve the crime. An eye for an eye leaves the whole world blind.


Had Eiji died as a result of her actions, she would be punished according to that reality. But that didn't happen, so punish her in proportion to that. Lastly, I want to say that the discussions on "mistakes" and "wrong choice" are thoroughly lacking in nuance. A mistake isn't a matter of conscious decisions. A person's awareness contributes significantly. Miyuki is a child. Regardless of what they might know, they are not expected to have the emotional or mental competence of an adult. It is for this very reason that we don't take a teenager's word as consent on its own, otherwise sexual predators could get away with just that. That's just not how the world works.

I'll say it again: Miyuki is a child. Clearly a stupid and easily manipulated one. But that doesn't make her a moustache-twirling villain or a psychopath who delights in the suffering of others. Whatever you want to pin on her: cheating, accessory to bullying, a proper man or woman would shake their head in disappointment at her bullshit and tell her to wise up. It is also within their rights to wash their hands of her situation, as they have no further obligation. Teachers should reprimand her, then give options and support within their scope. Her life is barely starting, and one mistake shouldn't be the end of it. She has countless options ahead, good or bad. Someone who would celebrate a child being driven to suicide for something like this in real life would be sick in the head. Good thing that this is revenge fantasy porn.

The thing is - everything you said is true in reality.

But your last sentence is the key point, and the reason we the readers are being asked to engage with the work as it is presented.

Ideally IRL Miyuki would get some form of help and not be perpetually punished as she is. But this isn't IRL, and so she is beholden to the rules of the world the author has created.

And for the record - she didn't make "a" mistake. She realized into the two days of bullying that her childhood friend was being tormented, and did nothing out of fear of being subjected to similar if it got out she straight up cheated on him and then lied about him abusing her.

She had the image of "pure good girl" going into that school year and was afraid of losing her street cred in her class.

She also knew, at multiple junctures, that what she was doing with Kondo was wrong--all the way back at even agreeing to meet him at the suggestion of her friend. But she liked the sex, she liked the immorality of it all, and she thought so little of Eiji that she convinced herself he would forgive her because "I'm special to him".

Yeah. She's a teenager. But she absolutely made a whole series of choices that push far past "mistake". And again, IRL? She should be afforded compassion after a point and help.

But not in this universe.

 

[Kaneeehh]

why the breakup was too short, i didnt even get the feeling, also hes not even hate or sad, he just straight up dissapointed

 

[Kaneeehh]

anyway, cant wait seeing them including that bich suffer because of their act lol

 

[Hejti]

Wow school taking some actions about bullying? Thats something new for a manga.

 

[Kaneeehh]

what? i cant belive shes mad at him, she even had s*x with that ntr guy instead giving the first to mc lol, what a shame, foolishness

 

[Trash_Connoisseur]

Death penalty for both of those cheaters. Straight up medieval flaying, pouring salt on the skin and sewing it back up like seasoning a turkey for thanksgiving.

 

[BEMAX]

Goated TAKAYANAGI Sensei is here🥳
Fr he is really god damn goated, talking about wn, he is totally goated🤗

 

[jecroisenlasuperioritedubel]

You guys might hate me, but I don't think the villain, Kondo, is that bad. He might be a netori sadist fuck, but a huge part of the blame are those dumb girls lol.

Only if people knew that Great excuses Alwꜽs don't make Great reasons , a la This case — people need to make keep others accountable for Their Own actions rather than pointing finger to a person and sꜽing : « 'e decieved Me ! ».

 

[Kaneeehh]

i dont think that one mc whos gonna end his own life gonna have revenge on her lol

 

[Kaneeehh]

I mean if your partner is going to leave/cheat just because some smooth talking person says a few words, it's probably better for you in the long run.
Yeah it defo gonna suck hard when it happens but better now then when you're all tied up with kids and other stuff.

yea, nothing wrong for showing this, cause better yall dont have regrets to see your beloved one was actually a bad choice

 

[naenaeslays]

MY GUY CHAD SENSEI BRO