Kamitachi ni Hirowareta Otoko - Vol. 2 Ch. 8 - The Adventurers' Guild
- Thread starter MangaDex
- Start date
Fed-Kun's army
- Joined
- Apr 18, 2018
- Messages
- 466
Thank you for this chapter!
Active member
- Joined
- Jan 27, 2018
- Messages
- 235
If this kid and the exterminator guy from the other isekai ot together they could run a really legit business.
- Joined
- Jan 17, 2018
- Messages
- 23
@Axelord
Now you made me curious, what's the problem with the bow?
I'm no bow-expert, but that seems like a relative believable recurve/composite/traditional mongolian bow.
The string does seem a bit weird, showing it as if it was "just" tied there, but otherwise it's not that much "fantasy-weapon" to me, but that doesn't mean there is no problem with it, I just don't know enough about them, even if I was shooting with a recurve a few years ago, that doesn't make me an "expert" on any level
Now you made me curious, what's the problem with the bow?
I'm no bow-expert, but that seems like a relative believable recurve/composite/traditional mongolian bow.
The string does seem a bit weird, showing it as if it was "just" tied there, but otherwise it's not that much "fantasy-weapon" to me, but that doesn't mean there is no problem with it, I just don't know enough about them, even if I was shooting with a recurve a few years ago, that doesn't make me an "expert" on any level
- Joined
- Mar 12, 2018
- Messages
- 3
The overpowered Isekai MC doing a test to join a guild but starting from the lowest level anyway is probably my most hated trope in the genre.
"Yeah, I'm the guild master and you just outperformed any other archer I've ever seen, now go clean houses for pennies."
I like the manga so I'll stick with it but there are more than a dozen I had to drop because of stuff like this.
"Yeah, I'm the guild master and you just outperformed any other archer I've ever seen, now go clean houses for pennies."
I like the manga so I'll stick with it but there are more than a dozen I had to drop because of stuff like this.
Active member
- Joined
- Mar 9, 2018
- Messages
- 334
yeah... dat guildmaster looked like a cheap ripoff of logan... lol...
- Joined
- Jan 22, 2018
- Messages
- 61
@sgnm4872 just like to point out that there was target shooting back then and in a real battle archers wouldn't have been moving all that much. those "old archery technics" if they were actually used back then were extremely situational and for the most part are just trick shots.
EDIT:
also the guy is using a bow with a low draw weight this makes pulling it back require little force, however it will also cause the bow to have less range and force to penetrate armor compared to what would actually be used for battle. to give you an idea of how big the difference in draw weight was the bow used in the video is probably in the 30-40lb range. a medieval longbow would of had a draw weight of 90-110lb and mongolian bows were between 80-150lb.
so in short you wouldn't see archers running around doing speed shots in ancient times.
EDIT:
also the guy is using a bow with a low draw weight this makes pulling it back require little force, however it will also cause the bow to have less range and force to penetrate armor compared to what would actually be used for battle. to give you an idea of how big the difference in draw weight was the bow used in the video is probably in the 30-40lb range. a medieval longbow would of had a draw weight of 90-110lb and mongolian bows were between 80-150lb.
so in short you wouldn't see archers running around doing speed shots in ancient times.
- Joined
- Jan 17, 2018
- Messages
- 23
@sgnm4872
That guy is using so "low-pound" bows it's not "combat"-archery but "trick"-archery. Doesn't mean he's not good at that, it's just that those bows would be too weak even for hunting bigger animals, to say nothing about combat against humans in armor, which I more or less consider "needed" in a fantasy-combat situation (if you're fighting against orc, orgres, strong beasts, you will need more than just a bow which can hunt rabbits or birds). Example: http://www.bestrecurvebowguide.com/capabilities-of-different-draw-weights/ Didn't read the whole article, but at a quick glance it seems OK.
Yes, the archery in manga is almost always "fantasy", but with the "weak" bows they are using (relative to their strengths, superhuman/magic could use a "heavy bow" easily of course) I can overlook that, and say "MAGIC!" to the destruction anyway
(Example "rant" about speedshooting/trick-archery, and it even shows a bow similar to the one in the manga: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cr_1z3GwxQk )
Edit: @burdrann was faster.. damn!
That guy is using so "low-pound" bows it's not "combat"-archery but "trick"-archery. Doesn't mean he's not good at that, it's just that those bows would be too weak even for hunting bigger animals, to say nothing about combat against humans in armor, which I more or less consider "needed" in a fantasy-combat situation (if you're fighting against orc, orgres, strong beasts, you will need more than just a bow which can hunt rabbits or birds). Example: http://www.bestrecurvebowguide.com/capabilities-of-different-draw-weights/ Didn't read the whole article, but at a quick glance it seems OK.
Yes, the archery in manga is almost always "fantasy", but with the "weak" bows they are using (relative to their strengths, superhuman/magic could use a "heavy bow" easily of course) I can overlook that, and say "MAGIC!" to the destruction anyway
(Example "rant" about speedshooting/trick-archery, and it even shows a bow similar to the one in the manga: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cr_1z3GwxQk )
Edit: @burdrann was faster.. damn!
Similar threads
