Kimi ga Hoeru Tame no Uta wo, - Vol. 4 Ch. 17 - The One Beside Her Should Be...
- Thread starter MangaDex
- Start date
Double-page supporter
- Joined
- Feb 14, 2018
- Messages
- 94
Hope next time Haru and Miyuki meet that Haru is just like "I didn't agree to any of this shit" in regards to them disbanding if they lose. Like, what the hell is in it for her to make that deal? Hell, she has no incentive to honor Miyuki telling her not to tell Yuu either. She should just tell her that her sister is antagonizing her for no reason.
Double-page supporter
- Joined
- Jul 11, 2025
- Messages
- 35
Wow the sister also sucks.
Also I really want Yuu to hold some resentment over her mother and sister. Like, can we have a scene where Yuu stares daggers at them? Make the mother and sister squirm a bit as they realize Yuu isn’t going to pretend nothing’s wrong?
Ya don’t just disappear for over a decade and think you’ll be welcomed back.
Also I really want Yuu to hold some resentment over her mother and sister. Like, can we have a scene where Yuu stares daggers at them? Make the mother and sister squirm a bit as they realize Yuu isn’t going to pretend nothing’s wrong?
Ya don’t just disappear for over a decade and think you’ll be welcomed back.
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Mar 7, 2023
- Messages
- 716
It's a good thing Miyukis opinion doesn't matter 
no way she expected her sister wanted to see her after they abandoned her for 10 years. How far up your own ass do you have to be to reach such a conclusion.
you're the last person who deserves to be by her side. but I hope once you lose you at least have the dignity to leave them alone
no way she expected her sister wanted to see her after they abandoned her for 10 years. How far up your own ass do you have to be to reach such a conclusion.
you're the last person who deserves to be by her side. but I hope once you lose you at least have the dignity to leave them alone
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- May 4, 2023
- Messages
- 431
I thought I was gonna be in the minority when I thought this. Glad to see people agreeing. I know tropes are tropes for a reason, but I'd take audition politics/drama over this melodrama anytime.
Member
- Joined
- Apr 18, 2025
- Messages
- 8
I wanted to make a comment on this since I'm noticing some comments about an "ultimatum" being made.
First I want to apologize if my wording has caused confusion. I've went ahead and re-worded it to attempt to make the line more clear and re-uploaded the page.
In this line, Miyuki was more saying that if they're not good enough to pass the audition, then they shouldn't even bother to continue as a group. Miyuki sees the audition as a very low level. She's not directly telling them to disband if they lose, since at this time there's no competition. She simply sees it as "why would I need to prove I'm better if you do it for me and fail at the first hurdle." She tells them to "have some dignity" because she'd likely rather not see her sister fail to do something so basic. She's kinda just being rude, but not trying to control them or demand things of them.
Miyuki is almost certainly not going to be participating in this audition. It's her mother's company (yay nepotism) and she's been training as a singer under RURIKO all this time already and has been undergoing professional training since she was a child. More likely, she's like the "Pokémon Champion" and waiting at the peak of the summit for them as a final test once they've made it through all the trials.
All we know for sure is that Miyuki seems to idolize Yuu and her singing, and the reason she sees herself as more deserving is because she's had more training, while she considers Haru's singing flawed. Essentially, she thinks her sister deserves only the peak of perfection as a partner and is not seeing what our husky brings to the table.
Anyways, please invest my delusion of Miyuki x Hikari, because if anyone can melt this stuck-up ice queen it's that ball of sunshine.
First I want to apologize if my wording has caused confusion. I've went ahead and re-worded it to attempt to make the line more clear and re-uploaded the page.
In this line, Miyuki was more saying that if they're not good enough to pass the audition, then they shouldn't even bother to continue as a group. Miyuki sees the audition as a very low level. She's not directly telling them to disband if they lose, since at this time there's no competition. She simply sees it as "why would I need to prove I'm better if you do it for me and fail at the first hurdle." She tells them to "have some dignity" because she'd likely rather not see her sister fail to do something so basic. She's kinda just being rude, but not trying to control them or demand things of them.
Miyuki is almost certainly not going to be participating in this audition. It's her mother's company (yay nepotism) and she's been training as a singer under RURIKO all this time already and has been undergoing professional training since she was a child. More likely, she's like the "Pokémon Champion" and waiting at the peak of the summit for them as a final test once they've made it through all the trials.
All we know for sure is that Miyuki seems to idolize Yuu and her singing, and the reason she sees herself as more deserving is because she's had more training, while she considers Haru's singing flawed. Essentially, she thinks her sister deserves only the peak of perfection as a partner and is not seeing what our husky brings to the table.
Anyways, please invest my delusion of Miyuki x Hikari, because if anyone can melt this stuck-up ice queen it's that ball of sunshine.
Last edited:
If the mothers and sisters abandonment isnt brought up later im actually going to get pissed. Ive seen this kind of japanese autism more than once where the abused child is somehow meant to look up to their abuser for some god forsaken reason.
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Feb 23, 2018
- Messages
- 770
I'm hoping the situation is just that the mom is that bad, and Miyuki wants change. That's optimistic. Miyuki's lack of contact is mom's fault, and I honestly don't expect a high-schooler or middle-schooler to have the maturity to reach out or keep up contact when a parent has a zealous commitment to being zero-contact for years. It'd be smarter than I'd expect, even in this era.
So it feels like superstar mom is just really damn fake, a huge hypocrite between scenes. Like, legitimately not someone we can expect a sane excuse for. The kind of person who'd make the daughter she took along desperate to get a longer leash, to prove Yuu's worth, or it seems both by forming a duo.
Just saying. It's optimistic but Miyuki may actually make sense. She may not be mommy's good girl (still a good taunt though). And unlike someone, she's still remembering family. If Miyuki wants to collab that's her wishes, not something mom is emotionally invested in. There's going to be bs, Yuu is traumatized and can be fragile, but Haru is tough. Hikari too. Hikari clearly fights for yuri.
So it feels like superstar mom is just really damn fake, a huge hypocrite between scenes. Like, legitimately not someone we can expect a sane excuse for. The kind of person who'd make the daughter she took along desperate to get a longer leash, to prove Yuu's worth, or it seems both by forming a duo.
Just saying. It's optimistic but Miyuki may actually make sense. She may not be mommy's good girl (still a good taunt though). And unlike someone, she's still remembering family. If Miyuki wants to collab that's her wishes, not something mom is emotionally invested in. There's going to be bs, Yuu is traumatized and can be fragile, but Haru is tough. Hikari too. Hikari clearly fights for yuri.
Group Leader
- Joined
- Jan 8, 2023
- Messages
- 939
An obsessed little sister? Now where have I seen that before?
Similar threads
