Koujo Tensei: Densetsu no Dai Madoushi (♂), Hime Kishi to Narite Densetsu no Reijou Kishidan o Tsukuri Musou Suru - Ch. 1 - Princess Reincarnation

[Magatsu-no-Imouto]

Magic swordsman - i cast fist

Attack: Magic Slash

Throws a punch that deals STR*20 physical damage

 

[Flyingpantsu]

Of all those awesome nicknames, the mother focuses on the lamest...

 

[MadScientist666]

Butler Sebas seems to have an adventurous life, being present in so many worlds and manga.

 

[jubuttib]

"The strongest sword is one's fist."
-Some martial artist, somewhere, probably.

"Everyone's got a plan, until they get punched in the mouth."
-A quite famous martial artist, for a given definition of martial artist

 

[EnmaHimari]

It would be great if she renounced her noble title and became an adventurer, but there's always this ridiculous cliché of remaining a noblewoman and going to those noble schools, and the worst part of all... the arranged marriage.

 

[jonsmth]

"I'm so pathetically weak without a blessing, look at me de-atomize an assassin, punch a hole through the ozone layer and blow up New New New Namek with a mere flick of my finger, it's such a worthless ability..."

He did that while having the blessing from being related to the hero though. He kept his knowledge to do magic, but the extra output was unexpected because of the powerup.

 

[eco666]

Nick pic, but I wish they'd didn't do time skip right away. Like how did he(she) get home safely? What did his(her) reaction look like, instead of being told it was surprising? You know small things like that before a time skip. Still going to read it tho.

 

[Done25]

Well that another Gender Bender story that will... not use the fucking Gender Bender point and just ignore it
And another one with a OP prota that become even more OP

Like I am a GB coinosseur I kinda read like 80% of the one of mangadex and I still wonder why so many chose that type of story and just never do anything with it, like just write a normal girl if you are going to threat the character as a normal girl why make her a man in the past if that has no plot implication

The idea is that she's a girl who acts like a man. Aka a tomboy.

 

[Zblurth]

The idea is that she's a girl who acts like a man. Aka a tomboy.

yeah ik ik, but at that point just make her a tomboy instead of a boy that act like a boy idk.

I do not think all story have to be lean and only have what they need but that feel like complicated way to just have a tomboy.
let's see if they do more about it as the story go, at the end of the day it is a supposition on my side not a fact that they will do nothing, but the writing as of now does not give me big hope

But yeah idk I feel like a tomboy struggeling in a patriachy society is a stronger base than a guy than wake up as a girl and still act as a guy in a patriachy.
I do not believe it is that but well it kinda still feel like mansplaning a girl problem, let's hope it is more than that but I can say I already did read mroe than a few "gender bender" that where exactly that... kof kof that one story about a GB magical girl that has to show the girl how it is done (and get op power cause obviously he would not have to work for it)

 

[The_H_Guy]

Please Japan, please!
Stop gender bending female heroines that are perfect as female heroines...
Why Japan? Why are you always do that?

 

[Done25]

yeah ik ik, but at that point just make her a tomboy instead of a boy that act like a boy idk.

I do not think all story have to be lean and only have what they need but that feel like complicated way to just have a tomboy.
let's see if they do more about it as the story go, at the end of the day it is a supposition on my side not a fact that they will do nothing, but the writing as of now does not give me big hope

But yeah idk I feel like a tomboy struggeling in a patriachy society is a stronger base than a guy than wake up as a girl and still act as a guy in a patriachy.
I do not believe it is that but well it kinda still feel like mansplaning a girl problem, let's hope it is more than that but I can say I already did read mroe than a few "gender bender" that where exactly that... kof kof that one story about a GB magical girl that has to show the girl how it is done (and get op power cause obviously he would not have to work for it)

I never said they did it well. Tbh most reincarnation manga are such bare bones slop that I don't even pay attention to the reincarnation part.

 

[galaxia9]

Well that was awesome, just straight up punching him across the courtyard. Hopefully going to be a fun series.

 

[mayu_hojo]

the overdramatic "be normal!" demands from a parent instead of any other mature thought... punching a guy that sends him flying... the mother immediately collapsing in shock...

mmmh... yep that's slop alright. delicious slop

 

[Nanarnia]

of course there's sebas as butler

 

[asteconn]

I feel sorry for Sebas; getting mullered so brutally following the whim of his boss.

 

[HuntingInTheHood]

I am thinking about a recent magical girl GB one where a guy get magical girl power and show the girl how it is done and all (by being OP without any reason obviosuly you should not have to work for it), like super super patronazing and pretty digusting overall lol.
The whole women cannot do thing corretly so you need a man to take a women role to show them yeah...

Maybe the guy has the powers before her so he has experience, that's why he's showing her the ropes? Would you not appreciate a senior at your job guiding you through the job? Also, try to write with proper words please.

 

[HuntingInTheHood]

Funny how many people are pissed off about the gender bender not being utilised properly.

What does it being fully utilised mean for them? Do they want the MC to struggle with coming to terms with their new body? Struggle with being attracted to the "wrong" sex? Struggle to fit in a world that expects them to behave like their peers?

Most of them are trans

I think you're being too cynical by saying that all the gender bender does is being bait.

My recommendation for you, who seem to only value serious gender bender stories, is to avoid anything with a "comedy" tag.

Trans people love genderbend manga that do put focus on the experience of changing gender than it just being a small part of the setting. They find genderbend manga because they're "relatable".

There are plenty of manga like that which still have comedy.

To say that the genderbend tag on this manga is bait is not entirely wrong for them.

 

[HuntingInTheHood]

at that point just make her a tomboy instead of a boy that act like a boy

But this one is a boy trapped inside a girl's body.

feel like a tomboy struggeling in a patriachy society is a stronger base than a guy than wake up as a girl and still act as a guy in a patriachy.

Maybe. But seems like you're downplaying what our protagonist is going through here, very ironic of a trans person. The oppression the MC faces should be the same regardless of their initial gender, because they're still a girl in the end.

 

[MostlyHumanTLs]

Most of them are trans

Trans people love genderbend manga that do put focus on the experience of changing gender than it just being a small part of the setting. They find genderbend manga because they're "relatable".

There are plenty of manga like that which still have comedy.

To say that the genderbend tag on this manga is bait is not entirely wrong for them.

Look, I was trying not to say it directly...

 

[Khulmach]

Just going to say it, terrible mother.
She assumed her daughter has trauma and instead of doing some minor leeway help, she goes "fuck your trauma, no"