@Kaete You're now trying to make yourself look better by acting like the voice of reason. You're saying people have differing opinions? Yeah, of course. I'm not fighting that strawman.
The problem is that's not what this was about. It was about whether characters should have realistic personalities and behaviors. There needs to be some amount of realism for a story to make sense.
If you like this series, fine, that's cool too. I obviously don't, but you do you. You can say this has enough realism to make sense and be good. However, if you say you don't need any realism at all, then yes, you're saying nonsense. I said this doesn't have enough realism. Other people said herp derp, don't need any realism, herp derp. That's the real issue, and you're just trying to distract.