yeah, good advises... we are NOT dogs. you know. That's why you should find GOOD psychologists.
I don't think you really are a psychologist and if you are, you're not a good one. Trust me I'm batman. 😈
Self-punish uh? If anyone had the will power to pursue a self-punishment, they most likely have the will power to eliminate the bad deed without it. If they don't and there isn't an illness at work or is something unconscious, it's because they are lazy and they do things only when they "have to" and if that's true, i don't think they could do a self-punishment and being consistent without supervision.
Staying up all night it's not a bad habit, it's a choice. If you stay up all night when you can't, you're just irresponsible. So, you punish yourself because you don't understand that it's bad for you? What are you a child? Or a masochist? 'oh crap, i "accidentally" stayed up all night again, now I "have to" watch that shit... 😱what a bummer!😱'
Seriously, I will punish my children when there will be a need because they don't fully understand the importance of things yet and they need to learn and grow. I will obviously try to explain why, BUT sure as hell I will not, WILL NOT, public shame them to make them discard a bad behavior or i don't know... putting laxative in their coffee to make them quit smoking...
Now, I'm sorry, i didn't mean to be harsh, the whole self-punishment thing just pissed me off because it reminded me of those psychologist and psychiatrists that want to "cure" gay people with punishments causing them ptsd to make them more vulnerable to breakdowns and all those mental illness that they know so well how to treat. Because, sadly, they don't know how to change your brain without damaging it.
Even if it works, even if it's right, not everything we study and prove needs to be done if takes one's soul in the process.
People want to be rewarded, supported and they like to be pitied.
I think that's enough to be exploited , no need to punish anyone, let alone yourself.
I can understand how it can work with unconscious things we do, but if you're aware, you need will power, if you aren't strong enough, you need to be supported.
WTH... you people are crazy.
"No, it's not what you think, that whip you saw doesn't mean that! i swear! I used to bite my nails! It's a medical whip!"