MookHyang - Dark Lady

Joined
Jul 30, 2019
Messages
1
So I eventually arrived at the gender bender point and I was prepared by the comments BUT I think it was the WOST possible time and setup.
They just intruduced information about people who are able to fight him in this world
and then this?
Really dont know what kind of drug the author smoked but thats just disappointing imo
 
Joined
Jun 6, 2019
Messages
33
I understand why people hate gender bender, and I'm the same in that regard, but It seems to me like the readers are overly focused on it to the point that they miss the fact it's not the trope of gender bender, but an event that perfectly fits the story since
he's so powerful that the court wizard of the goddamn country can't do anything against him
. Heck, he didn't even get transformed to a woman, but to a specific little girl for fuck's sake. And that's because it's the thing he hates the most, which actually makes sense.
Moreover, even after the transformation, there is NOTHING related to the usual shit we see in gender bender where the protagonist is transformed into a conquest target for different characters and romance ensues. He doesn't change one bit from his usual persona as the master practitioner he was in his prime
, and even goes through despair and beyond before he accepts his fate and gets back up again because of the curse and the loss of his power, like any real person would do
. Give the writer some credit here.

People should read this with preconceptions tossed aside. It's very sad to see so many readers fixated on gender bender that they don't even realize they just give birth to outrage out of their asses to validate their preconceived notions about what is and isn't present in this manhwa, disregarding what's actually happening.

TL;DR: Unconventional take on cultivation trope. Story is very good so far. Genderswap is (unjustly) the reason the score is lower than it should be, it's not present as a theme, but as a trigger for character+story development and a nerf to the protagonist as a workaround to the fact that his enemies can't kill him. The outrage comes from people who are used to junk food levels of storytelling and want this to be another isekai/wuxia.

Definitely would give 8.5 to 9 as of chapter 51. Would recommend reading even if you're not into cultivation.
 
Joined
Dec 21, 2018
Messages
30
@Tearsax you can read the missing one from leviatanscan website, leviatan is the one that translate the comic and somehow they drop it
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Dec 25, 2018
Messages
2,874
@kuywiwat: yeah, i know, i've been reading this series there since chap 1, but it kinda sucks for people who only use Mangadex.
 
Fed-Kun's army
Joined
Feb 18, 2018
Messages
2,119
But this is not how a Wuxia should be. Genderbender did ruin it. It's like forcing a genre that wasn't meant to be. Wuxias are supposed to be manly with their heads up..!
 
Member
Joined
Jun 8, 2019
Messages
129
Its always hilarious reading comments bashing the series because of "gender bender" and "MC isnt OP it sucks".

I mean, theres dozens of generic "MC gets OP powers and a harem" series, its amazing that this series doesnt copy those.
 
Joined
Aug 25, 2018
Messages
73
I'm a fan of this series. Admittedly I, contrary to what seems to be the usual method, found it through the gender bender tag rather than despite that tag...

Still, there is very little actual gender bending involved. In fact I would say that I would not read this as a gender bender story, because on that basis it has nothing to do with that genre. Very little is done with the gender switch other than the occasional gag joke. It's mostly one more qualifier, in addition to being near-manaless, in addition to being a child, to make the MC even more 'degraded'. For me the problem with that is that it implies that being female is in itself a degradation, not just on physical strength levels but even simply as a basic humiliation. While characters comment that 'at least you're still human', it remains rather misogynistic...and every other female character doesn't accomplish very much. The blue dragon is a footnote to Karrel, even though the blue dragon should be a fullfledged character in her own right. Mediah, uh, exists? Mostly in order to take care of Lana and then Dark. And Lana, of course, exists literally only to be hated. Every character of consequence is male.

As a Murim/wuxia story, it's somewhat garbage. There's not much interesting development of techniques as they relate to a well-developed system and there are no stratagems in the combat. The qi/ki system is unexplained and the magic system of the new world is the typical visualization handwave. There was a very brief set of beautiful interaction early on, when the mercenaries explained the Remembrance of the Earth spell, which nearly struck a perfect interplay between Dark's ignorance of the new world and all of its own well-designed and thoughtful nuances. However, after that magic received less and less attention. The Titans are also unsatisfying from a mecha standpoint because every Titan we see has a single statistic associated with it that determines its value. If each of these elements was developed then I would be a great fan of the novel combination and worldbuilding.

Nevertheless, I still read this story in a single sitting and intend to continue to read new releases.

In terms of writing, despite all of the negatives that I have said, this series is extremely refreshing to me even though I didn't actually get what I came for (gender bender). While the relative levels of training/enlightenment between the two worlds are somewhat bizarre, the story has very compelling characterization, giving convincing kingliness to (some) kings, strong intelligence and planning to (most) wizards, and admirable loyalty and morality to its knights. The MC himself (for he truly is very obviously a he—this is not actually a gender bender in any but the most superficial of ways) has fortitude and cleverness, a certain kind of wisdom, and very real flaws. He is proud and irritable without arrogance or brutality. (I say this, yes, despite the fact that he goomba-stomped the first graduate he ever fought...) I can buy into the idea that he is seventy two years old and has reached enlightenment. Yet these characters do not remain static. They are given real questions to answer and even if their answers are somewhat flat they are earnest and appealing.

Although the writing is linear compared to greater works of actual literature, among its actual company of webnovel serializations and somewhat shoddy trend-followers and revenge-porn xianxia, this series stands far above those.
 
Joined
Apr 9, 2018
Messages
25
Noticed people cant find the other chapters. So here is a link that you can find up to chapter 48 here. Link removed, they don't want traffic from here.

They seemed to have stopped translating it there. But i'm glad mangdex seems to have picked it up. I prefer this site over others anyways so win.

Hope this helps so more can enjoy this story.
 
Joined
Nov 12, 2018
Messages
165
Spoils on his powers

ive read a buncha spoilers and he does not gain his power til the very end cause the publisher dropped the story/author cause he dragged this curse shit for to long. dropped

Good for like the first 27 chapters
 
Double-page supporter
Joined
Jan 22, 2018
Messages
1,307
this is actually good... i thought the genderbender thingy will ruin the story for me but its not...
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jun 23, 2018
Messages
147
For me, the reason I hate this series is not because it's genderbender specifically (I can enjoy genderbender like fantasy bishoujo for example), but because the genderbend happens in the middle while I'm already invested in the story, and it's not even a one off type thing or at least just an arc, but the genderbend carried on through the entire freaking thing.

But to be honest I probably could've tolerated this comic if I knew about the genderbend before hand, but sadly I don't.
 
Joined
Jan 11, 2019
Messages
3
i don't know man, i dropped it before the gender bender part. the character interaction felt so odd that it was like a neural network trying to understand human interaction. the crossbow scene right at the beginning was so bad that i didn't understand what happened at first until i reread it. the part where the mc talked to the priest about his isekai situation was the most awkward conversation i have ever read. it felt like the priest had some kind of bipolar disorder and he kept switching from being intrigued to being bored of the conversation. characters were ultra bland. the only thing that i liked about this manhwa was the art, but the lips and nose sometimes look strange. from my point of view this manhwa does not deserve a score of 8 but something between a 6 and a 7. while i didnt read the whole thing and maybe it gets better, the first chapters until the dude gets into a female body are bad.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top