Musket Girls! ~Tensei Sanbou to Senretsu Otome-tachi~

[hagoft]

It was perfect I looking forward for the cav unit, its get me a napoleon vibe with reading this manga.

 

[Renedemi]

Don't get fooled by the fact that it's an isekai, this one is quite informational and written well.

It takes more time in explaining the different kinds of war tactics in politics which might seem boring, but I think it is presented well enough that even for clueless people like me, I can understand what they're saying.

There is still tension even if the MC might seem overpowered at first. The important part about his ability is that it only works on himself. It is not like his soldiers are particularly skilled, and have a clear disadvantage due to genetics (god i hope people don't take that as misogyny). The tension lies in how many people can he realistically protect and not die a horrible death.

The first fight having 0 casualties in his division is a little weird to me considering the nature of the fight, and the fort even exploding. That's just a nitpick though.

Overall I would recommend this heavily. Pretty nice change of pace for isekai manga as a whole.

 

[Mantis12345678910111213141516]

Manga so far is good. Hopefully it's not a straight match to the web novel: I felt the web novel kind of jumped the shark a bit too much for my taste after it had managed to float above the standard slop-sekai

 

[Solandri]

By the way, the author's other big work is Der Werwolf - The Annals of Veight. That's also a very well thought-out nation-building isekai novel. So I have high hopes for this series.

 

[TestAddress]

Muskets for me. Not into the other works.

 

[sounami231]

huge spoiler about a certain character's fate

Spoiler: don't open unless you really have to

the genki girl will die and I'm kinda disappointed with mc's reactions. I guess this is gonna be that kind of work

Who is the genki girl ? Do you have a chapter where we can see who it is ?

 

[bakon65]

Goodness I could nitpick every little detail and minor point of generic anti-aristocracy and understanding of formations like Forming Square; Which to protect against Cavalry, not to protect your knees. When you are in Square Formation are in your most exposed to the raking fire of Muskets and Cannons, mainly Case-shot and Canister shot. The girls would probably be better off being trained as mixed bag of Skirmishers/ Dragoons. They could probably excel at that with their light frames, physique and stature. The muskets would be smaller and load quicker too. Plus the size of the Unit could be managed by 2 decent officers. Plus Staff Officer has more of an Administrative position than a combat role.