Nadeshiko Changes

[lucianone]

@Allexio I read a comment somewhere on a smut manga like this. the admin himself (not sure if it's Holo or other guy. it's a red username for sure). he said "as long as it didn't show any genital part, it's not a H tag"

 

[Vahlokdotiid]

It's Kanojo but not garbage, also any man who likes gyaru is a cultured man

 

[MavB_Ver]

@hidayato no you don't. The point is, what draws the line between hentai and heavy ecchi manga (which may also depict sexual intercourse) is whether the genital parts are shown or not (no, not even censored, there is none in the first place). Those listed here are just for reference, and think about it, does any non-h publisher want to take the risk of publishing a hentai? Read the comments all over again, don't mind the offensive words. He may sound aggrorant, but what he said is on point.

P.S. ironically, ecchi means H itself. I know, it is kind of confusing.

 

[Teasday]

Based on the definitions MangaDex categorizes by, this is pretty obviously Smut, not H

 

[atifaslam7]

This is Domestic Na Kanojo, EXTRA THICC version

 

[Nick86]

I like when characters go straight to the point without the same redundant clichè of service but nothing happen. Approve, also Eba art is amazing as always.

Noticed is already completed with only 5 chapters? So short.

@Teasday - This is correct, Champion Red is not a H magazine just ecchi.

 

[Primeskydiver39]

Uh oh Rouna is getting jelly like toast

 

[JennyTals]

Can't decide on best girl till we see sporty imouto.

 

[grom]

it's sure now, it's not hentai.

 

[SteamedBunInvasion]

@Teasday can you lock this manga information editing please?
misinformed ignorant people keep changing it to H because sex
it's so annoying since many people (including me) toggle-off the H, so you can't see the chapter.

 

[Nick86]

-

 

[Nick86]

@SteamedBunInvasion - Report to the mod so they can block the page cause vandalism. Hopefull they revoke the permission to edit the manga pages for these retards.

Poke @ixlone, @lymus.

 

[pomodoro]

Fucking trash manga

bookmarked

 

[hafizwhdh]

@SteamedBunInvasion its like 1 inch from hentai lol
how is this not H?

 

[SteamedBunInvasion]

@hafizwhdh try reading your own post. slowly and carefully now.
I already explained everything below. if any of you still don't understand why this is not a H (ero-manga), then I'm sorry but I think you're just plain retarded.

 

[Nitrook]

It's not hentai, it's ecchi and smut you bitch

 

[KTheXIII]

tfw you recognised the art style ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)

 

[Gamenot]

Honestly, considering the explicit central theme is fetish sex it is really pushing boundaries if not already crossing them. The interpretation by the rules could actually classify it as H considering there is near nothing in terms of plot and you can argue that the artist censored their work. Supporting that theory you get stuff like the C1 P11 censor which is 2 millimetres from porn even to the point of showing the outline of the guy's shween. And then the following pages of light flashes like C1 P21 covering up revealing positions that would otherwise show genitalia.

But I guess it is entirely mod call on this.

 

[DrawGray]

the artist is EBA for fuck's sake, this is the same hentai he used to draw but without explicit genitalia

 

[SteamedBunInvasion]

I wonder how many times this manga's category have changed in the past 3 hours while I wasn't looking.

@drawgray @gamenot Irrelevant. this manga is not categorized as H manga as I explained down further below already many times. This is not debatable. This is just not a H manga no matter how much you want it to be one. Unless of course, Mangadex wants to make their own new arbitrary rule where sex = hentai no matter what, then there will be a shitload of other ecchi/smut manga that will have to be categorized as Hentai as well,.