Namaiki na Gal Ane wo Wakaraseru Hanashi - Ch. 21.5 - Ding Dong

Dex-chan lover
Joined
Aug 27, 2018
Messages
3,343
You know for some reason I wouldn't mind if Egaki sensei makes a Fanbox of both of them. Takenaka doesn't give off degenerate behavior from what we've seen. Also I know I can't ping BuyVelomobiles so I hope they see this, but I'm surprised they didn't translate the Xmas special art that Egaki sensei posted on Twitter:
Thanks for the translations.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Sep 15, 2023
Messages
1,925
⚠️ This post was made using MTL, so keep that in mind while reading. The purpose is to provide the MangaDex community with some insight into Japanese audience opinions—not to fish for internet points. So, please refrain from giving a 'like' or any other reaction. ⚠️

Here are some comments from the Japanese public on the Young Jump app:

SsHBdhi.png

せっかく姉と二人きりなのに、「もっこり」 Tシャツは不味いだろ

Considering it's just him and Aneki, wearing a "Mokkori" T-shirt is a bad idea, don't you think?
D78igaJ.png

A "Mokkori" T-shirt likely refers to a shirt with the word "もっこり" (mokkori) printed on it. In Japanese slang, "mokkori" is a playful term that typically refers to a noticeable bulge in men's pants, often used in a humorous or slightly risqué context. It's a word that gained some recognition through Japanese pop culture, including comedic anime or manga.

QKNlvWl.png

望月のインパクト強くて忘れてたけどやっぱ姉可愛いな...

Mochizuki's impact was so strong I forgot, but yeah, Aneki really is cute...

shLL8iP.png

久しぶりの姉ッエッドッ

It's been a while since an Aneki episode!

Q7qhYOA.png

は? 可愛いだろ

Huh? She's cute, isn't she?

cmOZryL.png

なんなんだそのシティーハンター展にしか売ってなさそうなTシャツ

What’s up with that T-shirt that looks like it’s only sold at a City Hunter exhibition?
City Hunter is a classic manga with an anime adaptation. Although I haven't read the manga or watched the anime, I understand that the main character, Ryo Saeba, frequently uses the word "Mokkori."


I seriously doubt they would make an anime of it nowadays...

IEqMzIW.png

シスコン目線じゃなくて、一般的視点でめちゃくちゃ可愛いんか

Not from a siscon perspective, but from a general point of view, she's really cute, huh?

qbTpCO3.png

この後めちゃくちゃセッ... 展開は無いですか?

Isn't there going to be an incredibly... intimate development after this?

zDFJGA1.png

1話から考えると、随分話の印象変わったなー...

Considering from episode 1, the impression of the story has really changed, huh?

FL7Q7GG.png

そんなにお互いひとりごと言う?

Do they really talk to themselves that much?

H7AZVoP.png

友達の初対面の美人ギャル姉に
もっこりTシャツであの応対出来るの
どんなメンタルしてんだよw

What kind of mentality do you need to handle meeting your friend's beautiful, fashionable Aneki for the first time while wearing a "Mokkori" T-shirt like that? lol.

WQcoOtl.png

この2人付き合ったら上手く行きそう

If these two started dating, it seems like it would go well.

L6kGa2P.png

年上に抱く感想が「生意気」...??

he impression you have of someone older is "cheeky"...??

MNUZKtL.png

どんなシャツ着てんだよ

What kind of shirt are you wearing?

p65QT9D.png

SUSHI にもっこりT、変なTシャツコレクターなのかな

A "SUSHI" shirt and a "Mokkori" T-shirt? Are you some kind of weird T-shirt collector?

vQ2rgQo.png

それぞれお似合いでいいんじゃないですか♡

They each suit you well, don't they? ♡

AwXPdjr.png

後の冴羽了か。

So, the future Ryo Saeba, huh?

6GgA8jD.png

アプリのトップバナーになってて進捗率デカデカ出てて笑っちゃったよ
将来結婚してそうな2人だな

It was on the app's top banner with the progress rate displayed so big, I couldn’t help but laugh.
They really seem like a couple that will get married in the future.


Additionally, here are the current like counts of the last 4.5 chapters:

Jgncv3U.png
 
Supporter
Joined
Jan 18, 2018
Messages
576
I couldn't put my finger on it but the conversation flows better in this TL.

I don't know how I really feel about this. Probably just a nothingburger though.
Honestly he at least is straight up and treats her a lot better than any of the villains so it wouldn't be too bad. I'd prefer him in the main timeline making sure he's not taking advantage of her if anything did happen?

I am still rooting for oniichan though.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Feb 22, 2021
Messages
4,217
I couldn't put my finger on it but the conversation flows better in this TL.
...
After I read it I like to play the "flip game" where I go back and forth between browser tabs. That really brings out the differences.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Feb 10, 2018
Messages
109
I couldn't put my finger on it but the conversation flows better in this TL.


Honestly he at least is straight up and treats her a lot better than any of the villains so it wouldn't be too bad. I'd prefer him in the main timeline making sure he's not taking advantage of her if anything did happen?

I am still rooting for oniichan though.
If this helps avert the Incest GF route, sure, go ahead, I don't mind. :huh:

I really don't get the vibe from this version of the story that the bro has romantic feelings for the sister. It seems limited to platonic feelings of admiration and respect, wanting to get her to go back to the sister she used to be and the one who helped him when he was younger (Chapter 14, page 5, top panel). From a certain point of view it could be him repaying the favor for how she supported him during whatever that was in the flashback.

Speculation says it could even be related to "the incident" that caused her to go full delinquent/gyaru. We see in the flashback just barely that she has the downward lines on her face indicating sorrow/stress (I doubt it's just shadows because you could use a solid color for that) so Tanuki's past trauma and hers might be related. Speaking of which, Tanuki is a pretty broken character himself. Other than the friend he doesn't really interact with anyone else and even starts to disassociate when people in the class start talking about him behind his back before the friend dives in to save him (this also implies the friend knows Tanuki has issues as well and comes to his rescue, further evidence that he's best boy).

I don't know why I'm getting so invested in this story given the history behind it but Egaki somehow has me hooked for the time being. Just don't fuck it up.
 
Double-page supporter
Joined
May 30, 2024
Messages
194
I don't know how i feel about this potential route honestly. I don't mind incest ending, since it's implied that both the MC and FMC isn't real sibling, wich is could be that they doesn't related by blood or that she's his cousin or something, wich is permissible by law. The incest route is arguably the most common one so far in this type of story. That being said, a lot of people here seems to root for the friend, and honestly i couldn't for the time being. I know he's nice and all, but i generally doesn't like overly bubbly characters like that. Plus i always hate the tropes when they make the bubbly positive characters win over the more competent one, and usually the bubbly characters always come out as floppy, wich is quite cute when its a girl but as a man? I didn't see the appeal of that. Honestly if i want a FMC end up with someone, it would be the good and dependable type wich i couldn't see in both the friend who's overly bubbly it's kinda annoying to me, and the MC who seems to have some personal problem at the moments. All and all, by how the story so far, i could only see the friends as more of a comic relief so i couldn't root for him right now. If she would be end up with the friend, i hope the author make some development for the friend, make him more dependable or show us more of his good side, and then i think i could root for him. anyway, that's my opinion at least.





Ps: i also feel it's unfair that the MC got to do all the work only to have the FMC end up with the friend at the end, it just sucks. I know that the friend is the one who inspire the MC and a good guy and it's better than the other version yada yada..... I just felt that the friend is not significant enough as a character to get the FMC. As far as the story goes, i only see him as a comic relief devoid of any interesting characteristic, so if he going to be the end game, i hope egaki sensei do something about it. At least give him some character development or make him more prominent character. But as for now, i couldn't root for him.
 
Last edited:
Supporter
Joined
Jan 18, 2018
Messages
576
I really don't get the vibe from this version of the story that the bro has romantic feelings for the sister. It seems limited to platonic feelings of admiration and respect, wanting to get her to go back to the sister she used to be and the one who helped him when he was younger (Chapter 14, page 5, top panel). From a certain point of view it could be him repaying the favor for how she supported him during whatever that was in the flashback.
I agree, this series is now only readable because Egaki had to rein in a lot of vagueness of motivations and blending of the porn version in the main story. I'm more rooting for Onii-chan in the fanbox
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Sep 20, 2024
Messages
784
Bro should go with the new girl and leave his sister for the friend
If this helps avert the Incest GF route, sure, go ahead, I don't mind. :huh:
stepsister so not incest
I don't know how i feel about this potential route honestly. I don't mind incest ending, since it's implied that both the MC and FMC isn't real sibling, wich is could be that they doesn't related by blood
It's not implied, it's outright stated in chapter 1 they aren't blood related
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top