Nani mo Wakaranai

[AlvoradaGD]

reminds me of heterogenia linguistica (I think that was the name?). I'm enjoying this one and hoping there are plenty more chapters to come.

 

[Erkuel]

Not what I'm saying. I'm asking why give him amnesia if it is going to functionally change nothing about the character or their approach to the new world?

It's like if you wrote a character to have no arms but gave them telekinesis that perfectly mimics the function of arms, which they never use for things other than what arms can do. It is flavourless fluff, a waste of an idea. Do something with it, or don't add it.

Omg this 100%. I'm sitting here like "why do you remember these things at all???" Plus, the fact that he tried ONE (1) word and then gave up all speaking for three chapters got to me and he hasn't thought to just leave this place with Myaa?

RuneCrypt was saying that this MC has amnesia but isn't brainless but I'm having some serious doubts for that claim XD

 

[Ferlucio]

Omg this 100%. I'm sitting here like "why do you remember these things at all???" Plus, the fact that he tried ONE (1) word and then gave up all speaking for three chapters got to me and he hasn't thought to just leave this place with Myaa?

RuneCrypt was saying that this MC has amnesia but isn't brainless but I'm having some serious doubts for that claim XD

because there are different kinds of amnesia

 

[entr0]

Sometimes used to slow down introducing a new world - reader gets to learn with the characters.
Seems fun. Wish it had more chapters out - patience

 

[StormSen]

Not what I'm saying. I'm asking why give him amnesia if it is going to functionally change nothing about the character or their approach to the new world?

1) Obviously, it's perfectly fine to provide background/color information that does not advance the plot. 2) It homogenizes the character, thus making him "identifiable" to a larger audence. 3) The fact may come into play later. Maybe his memories would reveal some explanation of why he's in this situation - but the author is leaving that revelation for later.

It's like if you wrote a character to have no arms but gave them telekinesis that perfectly mimics the function of arms, which they never use for things other than what arms can do. It is flavourless fluff, a waste of an idea. Do something with it, or don't add it.

Amnesia is not the same as "losing all knowledge, skills, etc." IDK how to make sense of your argument here unless you think that's the case.

 

[idle.ainsel]

Mhm♪

 

[twinklecake]

Story about a dude with cheat skills that make him invincible in a sunny fantasy world full of sweaty barefoot cuties... But somehow the garbage factor remains firmly at zero?

 

[KoutaYuuta]

Any other manga with a character like myaa? Love her design

 

[2endos]

Not what I'm saying. I'm asking why give him amnesia if it is going to functionally change nothing about the character or their approach to the new world?

It's like if you wrote a character to have no arms but gave them telekinesis that perfectly mimics the function of arms, which they never use for things other than what arms can do. It is flavourless fluff, a waste of an idea. Do something with it, or don't add it.

It feels a bit early to say that the amnesia serves no purpose. It’s entirely possible a deeper purpose for the amnesia will be uncovered later on in the story.

 

[SuperMachamp]

If this premise is supposed to carry this manga then it is not long for this world.

 

[AzrefReza]

Wooooh, new cover, and it’s not Myaa-san !

 

[Asfalt]

What's the point of making him an amnesiac if he knows how to speak Japanese, write Japanese, knows about articulation, knows about English and some basic communication in it, knows English would be more universal than Japanese, knows about cultural concepts prevalent in Japan like Demon Lords...

Just make him a Japanese guy if you are incapable of imagining your mc from a perspective not based in Japan.

Maybe he's some kind of robot, that's why he's so strong and has no memories.

 

[grom]

Do someone have some spoiler for the story in the grand scheme of things ?