Noise - Vol. 3 Ch. 23 - Homecoming

Banned
Joined
Feb 20, 2023
Messages
999
Why is faking your own death and living in isolation never able to see your family again preferable to just going to jail? wouldn't he be out in 20 years?
I thought the earlier chapters were a lot better than the last 5-7.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jun 16, 2020
Messages
1,785
Why is faking your own death and living in isolation never able to see your family again preferable to just going to jail? wouldn't he be out in 20 years?
I think he just wanted to shoulder it all alone because he's the one who started the chains of event,
and didn't want his friend to be arrested too because of the flashback a few chapters back

I thought the earlier chapters were a lot better than the last 5-7.
yeah, it's a bit underwhelming,
but at least it is a tied end
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Apr 15, 2019
Messages
3,670
Why is faking your own death and living in isolation never able to see your family again preferable to just going to jail? wouldn't he be out in 20 years?
I thought the earlier chapters were a lot better than the last 5-7.
Because the reputation of the village is also at risk. The growing fig farm, the promise to build a school and the funds to develop the village. It was all due to the fig farm owned by Keita. Controversy regarding him may cause all that to be rejected. So he has to stay away. Now that all that has been achieved, he felt it's okay to come out now.

But still, I agree the last few chapters were rushed. What happened with the policeman that shot himself?
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 26, 2018
Messages
603
Manga like these live from having no plot holes or unrealistic actions by the characters. Unfortunately this story shit the bed when they didn‘t simply told everything to the police. It was clearly self-defense.

After that I just kinda skipped over the rest and it didn‘t seem to get better. Oh well.
Still thanks for the translation, still better than the millionth Isekai trash.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Apr 15, 2019
Messages
3,670
Manga like these live from having no plot holes or unrealistic actions by the characters. Unfortunately this story shit the bed when they didn‘t simply told everything to the police. It was clearly self-defense.

After that I just kinda skipped over the rest and it didn‘t seem to get better. Oh well.
Still thanks for the translation, still better than the millionth Isekai trash.
What's clear to some people isn't what's clear to everyone else. Johnny Depp is still considered an abuser by a lot of people. Benjamin Mendy is still considered a rapist by a lot of people. You're being awfully naive here no offense
 
Active member
Joined
May 27, 2023
Messages
64
ill strongly disagree w calling this an axed ending, if uve been reading tetsuya tsutsui this guy never goes above 3 volumes. its a writing and artistic decision, i doubt he was ever planning a 4th volume lol. and if he were, hes had enough hits by now to be allowed a 4th volume... and like what loose ends would even need to be closed? the cop in the hospital got closure. he cries thinking about his mom; in the middle of all of this he lost sight of her, the thing that actually matters. its thematically coherent. same thing w keita, he didnt feel it was okay to come out now, he explicitely says he put saving the life of his daughter above remaining in hiding. this is why he came out now. because hed lost sight of the thing that actually matters

not my favorite tetsuya tsutsui sadly i was a bit disappointed w this one as it feels more like ur usual crime thriller than what id come to expect from him. but maybe i just wanted to read duds hunt in 3 volumes and noise isnt duds hunt so my expectations mislead me there. noise is about decisions made in anger, its about decisions made in fear, its about decisions you dont even agree with but that you have to live with now. its about killing a guy in a shed and realizing your friend who makes a living from hunting will lose his hunting license if this becomes known- so 3 years later youre living on your own in the mountains and you didnt see your daughter grow up. and for the first time, tsutsui didnt have an ending in mind when he wrote the 1st volume and it sort of shows lol
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top