Onii-chan Is Done For! - Highschool ONIMAI (Doujinshi)

[Gekkogahiya]

Thx for your kind reply. I have taken a look at your fixes, and they are much better. The he was no longer necessary as at this point she's in high school now, and is full woman now. Your use of gorgeous is appropriate in the way Mahiro refers to Momiji as gorgeous. As even during the show, and official manga. Mahiro is referred to as her/she. Even as time went on the her/she became more used even by Mihari, and even Mahiro Refers to herself as her/she. Basically speaking. Mahiro thinks of herself as a girl. Mind, body, and soul.
Ps sorry for sounding like a jerk. I can be pretty harsh some times. I was surprised to see your reply.

idk why but i love the concept of "hrt first, pronouns later"

wish i had a magical sex changing drug

 

[sootesheepy666]

came here for the silly Yuri and stayed for the girl kissers <3

 

[sootesheepy666]

It less of a parody and more of a reinterpretation of the original work since in this alternate vision the medicine Mahiro took was permanent and irreversible. At least that’s my understanding, it could be that this doujinshi author is just trying to ape the original without understanding the authors actually intent.

in this manga the medicine wasn't initially permanent either! from what I gather, after taking it for literal years it eventually just became permanent! We see flashback-mahiro changing back she just cant anymore

 

[sootesheepy666]

You know ppl in the past could open the comment section of gender benders and not see "pronoun police" losing their sht. This doujinshi is weird more so as it is from a questionable series. The most horrible thing is "She accepted herself as a female so you should refer to her as such" bro he's 29yo who grew up second time with girls. I don't care about the feeling of some tranny pedo, pairing or shipping is already weird if you think for a moment.
This is okay only if you regard this as perverted questionable doujinshi for Yuri fanatics. I don't need no "proper identification" in that case. It's a soft core erotica, fan service sht at best. Touch some grass

don't read it if you have such a problem! :3

 

[GhostX64]

don't read it if you have such a problem! :3

Why wouldn't I read what I want to read if some dumbass in the comment section doesn't like what brain rot pronouns I use for him? :3

 

[sootesheepy666]

Why wouldn't I read what I want to read if some dumbass in the comment section doesn't like what brain rot pronouns I use for him? :3

I literally don't gaf about the pronouns thing broski, I just mean it's pointless to read something that you have such as issue with as to write a whole essay lmfao \(-O-)/

 

[GhostX64]

I literally don't gaf about the pronouns thing broski, I just mean it's pointless to read something that you have such as issue with as to write a whole essay lmfao \(-O-)/

Either you didn't read anything about my essay or have no reading comprehension because anyone who has a twat for brain even could realize the essay was more about the state of the comment section than the doujinshi.
If you're not gonna bother reading people's comment, don't waste other people's time by writing irrelevant comments.

 

[Juggernautbob]

First of all stop with the he/she crap. It's she. Also makes Mahiro sound gay, it's yuri. Momiji is a girl so she would be cute or beautiful. Not handsome. only guys are referred to as handsome. It's obvious Mahiro has made up her mind to live as a girl. So it's stupid to use the he/she with her. Here I thought I found a good fan made manga, but guess not. The use of wrong identifiers, and certain use of language made it bad.

Me when I explode over pronouns in a goofy romcom fanfic:

Also saying handsome girls don't exist is like saying cute guys don't exist, which is false because I exist 😘🥰

 

[sootesheepy666]

Either you didn't read anything about my essay or have no reading comprehension because anyone who has a twat for brain even could realize the essay was more about the state of the comment section than the doujinshi.
If you're not gonna bother reading people's comment, don't waste other people's time by writing irrelevant comments.

"This is okay only if you regard this as perverted questionable doujinshi for Yuri fanatics. I don't need no "proper identification" in that case. It's a soft core erotica, fan service sht at best. Touch some grass" this, right here, is you complaining about the manga itself. not the comment section. Not to mention here, "bro he's 29yo who grew up second time with girls. I don't care about the feeling of some tr4nny pedo, pairing or shipping is already weird if you think for a moment." you seem to be upset by the plot of the original manga itself which definitely leaves me confused on why you're reading the doujinshi of it LOL, so, I did in fact read your comment and I'm starting to wonder if you yourself did. Or maybe you're just kinda bad at putting your thoughts into words! (me too lolz) Plus the fact that you use a transphobic slur basically invalidates your opinions anyway! >O<'

 

[GhostX64]

"This is okay only if you regard this as perverted questionable doujinshi for Yuri fanatics. I don't need no "proper identification" in that case. It's a soft core erotica, fan service sht at best. Touch some grass" this, right here, is you complaining about the manga itself. not the comment section. Not to mention here, "bro he's 29yo who grew up second time with girls. I don't care about the feeling of some tr4nny pedo, pairing or shipping is already weird if you think for a moment." you seem to be upset by the plot of the original manga itself which definitely leaves me confused on why you're reading the doujinshi of it LOL, so, I did in fact read your comment and I'm starting to wonder if you yourself did. Or maybe you're just kinda bad at putting your thoughts into words! (me too lolz) Plus the fact that you use a transphobic slur basically invalidates your opinions anyway! >O<'

Learn the meaning of what "regard" from dictionary. Read the very line that you have quoted and try to understand what the person means. Nobody will spell it for you can't understand hypothetical scenario.

you seem to be upset by the plot of the original manga itself which definitely leaves me confused on why you're reading the doujinshi of it LOL

I read the original one as a comedy, and in comedy there can be many factors that you disagree with. I was there for the funny part not the for the questionable shipping.

Plus the fact that you use a transphobic slur basically invalidates your opinions anyway! >O<'

For you maybe, I normally take people more seriously if they use a transphobic slur lol.

 

[sootesheepy666]

Learn the meaning of what "regard" from dictionary. Read the very line that you have quoted and try to understand what the person means. Nobody will spell it for you can't understand hypothetical scenario.


I read the original one as a comedy, and in comedy there can be many factors that you disagree with. I was there for the funny part not the for the questionable shipping.


For you maybe, I normally take people more seriously if they use a transphobic slur lol.

I understand what regard means and my point still stands. ngl, the fact that you're sitting here arguing with some random teenager is kinda funny to me tho lmfao! Also, I personally read this as a comedy too and whether or not you read this as a comedy or not it is mildly concerning that you're ok with like at least one piss scene per every volume but not the idea of calling a character that is now a woman with proper pronouns. I don't take slur users serious because the idea that you'd have such a problem with an already oppressed group of people who do you no harm is something I find funny.

 

[GhostX64]

I understand what regard means and my point still stands. ngl, the fact that you're sitting here arguing with some random teenager is kinda funny to me tho lmfao! Also, I personally read this as a comedy too and whether or not you read this as a comedy or not it is mildly concerning that you're ok with like at least one piss scene per every volume but not the idea of calling a character that is now a woman with proper pronouns. I don't take slur users serious because the idea that you'd have such a problem with an already oppressed group of people who do you no harm is something I find funny.

"Also, I personally read this as a comedy too and whether or not you read this as a comedy or not it is mildly concerning that you're ok with like at least one piss scene per every volume but not the idea of calling a character that is now a woman with proper pronouns." The answer is easy, the piss scenes aren't shoved down my throat not is it telling me that I'm inferior for not liking piss and bending to their morals.

" I don't take slur users serious because the idea that you'd have such a problem with an already oppressed group of people who do you no harm is something I find funny." I am ignoring your moral superiority complex here because in light of you saying you are a teenager, everybody suffers from that at that age.

Let me give you a lesson in slur and why people use it. Generally slurs are used to denote to a slur deserving individual. What does it mean? It means slurs have two parts one negative and another identity.

Let's say the word "F*ggot" originates to call gays harshly. It's origination is in a slur itself.

Another word "Ret*rded" wasn't originated as a slur but as something to describe a medical condition which inappropriate use has led it to become a slur.

So If call a murderer gay, a cold Blooded f*ggot, I'm not insulting the gay people, because the word is clearly different. I am insulting the murderer. The if I call a person who acting like an as*hole in the streets ret*rded, I am obviously not insulting the medically challenged people, I am insinuating the slow aspect of that slur to that socially inept douche bag.

Nobody irl picks on words and ignores the context and says I ignore your opinion. The people who do rarely care or listen to your opinion at all. If those kind of people are the only people around you irl, I would feel bad for that person.

That's why I said I take people who say slur more seriously. The moment you utter a slur you are sending a strong message and you need to be very careful of the point you are trying to make. The same way I take people who say "lol" not seriously. You would see that even I used lol because at some point I did realize that you are a kid, but to see admit it honestly admit it is very rare so I went on to write this paragraph.

Now of course there are people who says slurs because of malicious intention, but to automatically assume every person is like that just shows your twisted mentality. I would rather assume people as naturally good then proven wrong than to assume everyone bad. Innocent until proven guilty. This is your flawed moral superiority, as you claim to be a person who "doesn't want to be rude to a oppressed few" but in reality you have made a social pyramid where everyone is automatically rude, then the oppressed are good until they do something bad to you, and you are at the top who is a angel fallen from heaven who is morally superior to everyone.

Hope this helped you in anyway. I would take your advice and not argue with you anymore, have a nice day.

 

[sootesheepy666]

"Also, I personally read this as a comedy too and whether or not you read this as a comedy or not it is mildly concerning that you're ok with like at least one piss scene per every volume but not the idea of calling a character that is now a woman with proper pronouns." The answer is easy, the piss scenes aren't shoved down my throat not is it telling me that I'm inferior for not liking piss and bending to their morals.

" I don't take slur users serious because the idea that you'd have such a problem with an already oppressed group of people who do you no harm is something I find funny." I am ignoring your moral superiority complex here because in light of you saying you are a teenager, everybody suffers from that at that age.

Let me give you a lesson in slur and why people use it. Generally slurs are used to denote to a slur deserving individual. What does it mean? It means slurs have two parts one negative and another identity.

Let's say the word "F*ggot" originates to call gays harshly. It's origination is in a slur itself.

Another word "Ret*rded" wasn't originated as a slur but as something to describe a medical condition which inappropriate use has led it to become a slur.

So If call a murderer gay, a cold Blooded f*ggot, I'm not insulting the gay people, because the word is clearly different. I am insulting the murderer. The if I call a person who acting like an as*hole in the streets ret*rded, I am obviously not insulting the medically challenged people, I am insinuating the slow aspect of that slur to that socially inept douche bag.

Nobody irl picks on words and ignores the context and says I ignore your opinion. The people who do rarely care or listen to your opinion at all. If those kind of people are the only people around you irl, I would feel bad for that person.

That's why I said I take people who say slur more seriously. The moment you utter a slur you are sending a strong message and you need to be very careful of the point you are trying to make. The same way I take people who say "lol" not seriously. You would see that even I used lol because at some point I did realize that you are a kid, but to see admit it honestly admit it is very rare so I went on to write this paragraph.

Now of course there are people who says slurs because of malicious intention, but to automatically assume every person is like that just shows your twisted mentality. I would rather assume people as naturally good then proven wrong than to assume everyone bad. Innocent until proven guilty. This is your flawed moral superiority, as you claim to be a person who "doesn't want to be rude to a oppressed few" but in reality you have made a social pyramid where everyone is automatically rude, then the oppressed are good until they do something bad to you, and you are at the top who is a angel fallen from heaven who is morally superior to everyone.

Hope this helped you in anyway. I would take your advice and not argue with you anymore, have a nice day.

I won't argue anymore about this too, arguing is kinda draining and I do see your points in all of this! I gotta say tho- really don't view myself to be an angel or anything I just have a specific dislike of trans slurs bc, as a genderfluid person with a trans little brother, I've experienced my fair share of transphobia! @.@ Also, I totally agree that shipping onmai character is high-key weird asf LOLZ!