Ore no Zensei no Chishiki de Teihen Shoku Tamer ga Joukyuu Shoku ni Natte Shimai Sou na Ken

Dex-chan lover
Joined
May 5, 2023
Messages
795
this is.. ok its not been very good thus far. solid 5.5/10 which is still better than other utter trash I have read on this site.

While the writing itself has plenty to critique, I think the art is whats seriously holding this back. Its extremely inconsistent and at times down-right amateurish. IDK if it will solidify later on but from the chapters ive read, it isn't great, which is wild because sometimes you'll get a page that is absolutely impressive, and then the very next page its like one of those "how to draw anime" books you'd find at ur middle school book fair (usually written by some western shlub that hasn't ever looked at manga)
 
Member
Joined
Jul 12, 2023
Messages
24
1/10.
Black hair = weakest job but actually it's the strongest after all! is the Japanese version of white savior syndrome.
Get's isekai'd into another world yet keeps all of his strength and is able to defeat a King beetle, and within less than 10 chapters obtain God power, making every fight a show and nothing more.
Is clueless about social etiquettes and surroundings.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Sep 20, 2018
Messages
755
I don't understand how the art keeps going between goofy as shit to actually good, constantly up and down in quality. Feels like multiple artists are involved.
Story is kinda whatever tbh, clearly more oriented towards the game harem isekai tropes, and the exp doesn't seem to actually matter (or at least it's never really shown in a way that fits into the other systems).
It's good popcorn manga, nothing great but worth scrolling through for some good dynamic fight scenes.
 
Aggregator gang
Joined
Dec 16, 2018
Messages
215
It's not a bad read. It's not going to win any awards, but if you don't take it seriously it's decently entertaining.

I get the feeling its intended audience is boys age 11-14.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Apr 8, 2018
Messages
669
This was hard to get into at first, but I've been reading the chapters as they've come out (up to #47 at time of review) and like it more now. Character designs and expressions are endearing, and they definitely mimic the shounen battle action style. Seeing as how it doesn't seem the artist has any other serials under his belt, some of the complaints about inconsistency can be attributed to adapting that style. The demographic definitely skews young teen with the strong suit being the fighting and wacky abilities, though I'll say anyone teen and up can enjoy this without too much trouble. Give it a read if you have the spare bandwidth.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Nov 9, 2023
Messages
247
in this manga somehow the people look more like bugs than the actual bugs. Especially the tsundere, who's got the eyes of a fucking praying mantis.
 
Member
Joined
Sep 9, 2024
Messages
78
Man.... This is so freaking LAAAAAME!!! The art in the first chapter was.... Sort of unique, I guess? It already showed some 'cracks' the further you get in the chapter, but after a few chapters? It's like the mangaka has a kid around that knows how to hold a pen, but has NO IDEA what things should look like and he lets the kid do pretty much everything, while he then does a few lines himself, once the kid is done messing things up. The story had a tiny amount of an interesting premise, or at least a more original way of reincarnation, than truck-kun getting involved, but other than that... This is a bloody trainwreck and it's not because truck-kun got on the tracks to derail the train, or try to isekai it. It's because of sloppy design and badly paced story telling. Even when there are a few moments of proper explanation, it's all messed up in the end.
I usually try to hold out a little longer, as long as the story is a little interesting, but this just throws one event after the other at you, which is supposed to be 'interesting', but manages to completely hit the mark 90% of the time.
Just to make sure, I took a peek at Ch.29 and somewhat to my surprise, it looks slightly better, but maybe that's because the 'artist' prefers to ONLY put in some effort in fight scenes??
I don't know. In any case, DROPPED after chapter 12.
If the art contorts my face in a continious state of cringe and the story is what this is... No way am I going to bother to finish reading this, just like the mangaka couldn't be bothered to stay consistent with the art and proportions of... Pretty much ANYTHING.
If they had showed us about 2 chapters a week, I might have understood why everything looks like a rushjob, but it took 5 years to poop out 50 chapters of THIS?!
Okay, bye now.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top